Moore: Rhode Island Needs a Holiday!

Monday, December 28, 2015

 

View Larger +

Joseph Solomon Jr.

Picking on the Rhode Island General Assembly is somewhat our state pastime here in Little Rhody.

Walk into any breakfast joint in the morning, turn on talk radio, or gather round with relatives at the dinner table and undoubtedly, if you give yourself more than a half hour, the topic of conversation will turn to the futility of our lawmakers. 

I'm probably as guilty of it as anyone. But every once in a while, and I know people aren't going to believe me, but they do come up with some good ideas now and then. 

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

A Good Plan

One such great idea came across my desk last week in the form of a press release from Warwick State Representative Joseph Solomon Jr. Solomon is filing legislation that will create a "sales tax holiday" throughout the state next year, which will take place over the weekend of August 6-8th. 

“I’m tired of seeing people leave the state to purchase goods in Massachusetts. I want to see people from other states coming here to make their retail purchases. This is a perfect concept for a small state like Rhode Island where two separate states are within a short driving distance," Solomon said in his press release.

Solomon is spot on. To quote the greatest female pop star of all time (Madonna), RI needs a holiday. The sales tax holiday would not only convince people to make purchases that they need, it would convince people to make purchases that are merely conveniences as well. And the economic multiplier effect would be significant.

Increasing economic activity

It's reminiscent of the old joke about the wife who comes home from a sale with a new, mink coat. She proceeds to tell the husband that she "saved" one thousand dollars on the coat. The husband than inquires as to how much it cost, only to hear "four-thousand dollars".
To the benefit of the Rhode Island economy, there would be so many of those such purchases if Rhode Island goes ahead and enacts this sales tax holiday next year. 

The naysayers, who seem to hate the idea of people not paying taxes, (they're the same people who have never seen a tax hike that they didn't like), complain that the sales tax holiday would deprive the state of much-needed tax revenue. 

But that's the type of shortsightedness that prevents people from being able to see past the tips of their noses. Solomon said it's hard to estimate how much the state would lose in sales tax revenue since the concept has never been enacted before. But a very conservative estimate, he said, is about $5 million. 

More, Not Less, Revenue

Assuming that that's the case, the creation of a sales tax holiday would pay for itself by virtue of all the free advertising and positive publicity alone. Every single year that Massachusetts does the tax free holiday, and every year I hear it talked about for weeks in the run up to it.
 
Further, that doesn’t take into account the increase receipts from the meal tax on those days, since people like to go out to eat after shopping, and gas tax receipts, since it would draw in people from other states—not to mention the fact that people will need to drive to the stores.
Solomon points out that the time is ripe for the state to be more aggressive in its economic development efforts. 

"I can understand that this concept is a tough sell when we're dealing with budget deficits and pension shortfalls," said Solomon during a telephone conversation on Saturday. "But the fact of the matter is we ran a surplus last year, so we have the luxury of making investments and providing incentives for economic development."

A Rally Cry

If the sales tax holiday isn't a success, the state could always scrap the idea in future years. But let's face it, the sales tax holiday would be such a success that I'm willing to bet that the state would be expanding the program due to all the increased economic activity. 

Solomon said he believes the bill’s prospects are relatively positive given that the House Speaker and Governor are looking to increase economic development. The bill stands a better chance, he said, if people rally behind it and call on their legislators to pass it.

“If people really get behind this and make it known that they are, I believe it will pass,” said Solomon. 

View Larger +

Russell J. Moore has worked on both sides of the desk in Rhode Island media, both for newspapers and on political campaigns. Send him email at [email protected]. Follow him on twitter @russmoore713.

 

Related Slideshow: 5 Economic Projects - Can Raimondo Get Them Done?

View Larger +
Prev Next

#5 Wexford-CV Properties

The Raimondo administration continues to work with the 195 Commission to seal the deal with the Baltimore-based Wexford Science and Technology for development of prime real estate on the former highway land.  While a proposal was made back in June for a mixed-use project, the negotiations between the state and the life sciences have been mostly behind the scenes, with a key vote taken on the proposal taking place Monday night -- in closed session.  

"It is important to note that a P&S while an important milestone, is still just a step in the development process," said Commission spokesperson Dyana Koelsch.  You can see the plan as presented on the Jewelry District's website HERE.   Will we see shovels shortly?

View Larger +
Prev Next

#4 General Electric

Reports that the Connecticut giant is eyeing a move elsewhere — with Rhode Island on that short list — has many a Ocean Stater excited at the possibility.  The Boston Globe not surprisingly made the case that their state should top the list (taking a dig at the others), saying that the "Boston area is on the short list of contenders for the headquarters and its 800 people, as GE’s search focuses on high-cost states in the Northeast. In relation to those states, Massachusetts compares favorably on its business tax climate."

However a Connecticut State Rep told the Hartford Courant a month earlier that Rhode Island as an option “wouldn’t surprise him.” Said State Rep John Frey in November, “It's been expressed to me by a couple of people at GE that they've been impressed by what the governor has done with state employee liabilities." To say a GE coup by Raimondo would be monumental for Rhode Island would be an understatement.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#3 Citizens' Campus

The Rhode Island-based banking powerhouse has indicated that is looking for a vacant location state as a potential new campus for 4,000 + of its employees — while maintaining its headquarters downtown at One Citizens Plaza.  There is little indication at this time however of consideration of a vacant parcel of prime Providence real estate just to its HQ's south (that being the Industrial National Bank “Superman” building); the bank is indicating that keeping its support facility in Cranston is still an option.  

“The lease for our service and support facility in Cranston expires in 2018. We are exploring several opportunities ranging from renewal to potentially consolidating some of our staff and back office functions at a new location in Rhode Island," said Citizens spokesperson Jim Hughes.  Watch to see how Citizens moves forward -- and what, if any, role Raimondo has in the process -- and outcome.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#2 Superman Building

The arguably most iconic building in Providence — and Rhode Island’s - skyline lost its last tenant in 2013, and a year later an appraiser deemed it to have “zero value.”  A failed effort to utilized tax credits and public investment by High Rock Development has left watchers asking if and when anything is going to move into the historic (if slightly aging) building.

Former Mayor and real estate developer Joseph Paolino, who has been a vocal supporter of trying to get Citizens Bank into Superman, told GoLocal, “I think the biggest problem [in the city] is Superman, because it depresses everything around it. Paolino, who bought three properties nearby downtown back in 2014 — said the revelation that the Industrial National Bank building was empty had cost him a mortgage with a major lender.

Whether there is an opportunity for a Citizens Bank move, or a new developer to re-package a viable mixed-use proposal, if the Superman building is still empty in several years' time, that is not a win for anyone -- not the city, not the state, and not the Governor.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#1 195 Rollout

When Raimondo took office, she understandably made a number of changes on the 195 Commission. A tax stabilization agreement (TSA) structure was finalized this past summer, and the Commission has the Wexford biotech proposal moving forward — but how much more development, and how soon, will the Raimondo administration be able to accomplish what it pledged it would do?

Raimondo called for the 195 land to be a manufacturing hub during her campaign — and while year one might have been setting the stage, the next years are critical for the state — and Governor.  Will she usher through her proposed Innovation Institute?  

 
 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

 
 

Sign Up for the Daily Eblast

I want to follow on Twitter

I want to Like on Facebook