Photo Emerges of Projo’s Investigative Reporter Hummel in Blackface
Tuesday, December 11, 2018
The picture, which was posted to Facebook and tagged Hummel, included a comment from Providence Journal reporter Linda Borg who wrote, “Don’t tell the NAACP about this.”
The date of the photo is not known, and it was taken when Hummel was a reporter for the Providence Journal. Today, the Providence Journal has a contract with Hummel's not-for-profit to publish investigative stories. The other person in the photo is former Providence Journal reporter Jeffrey Hiday -- who is now a communications executive for the RAND Corporation.
On Monday, the Providence Journal published a story about the Edwards Twins, who in their performance portray African-American performers. In the article about the Edwards, the Journal reported, “The white duo, who were supposed to perform their impersonation act at The Gamm Theatre on Monday, have worn skin-darkening makeup to portray Lionel Richie and Stevie Wonder, which the Providence branch of the NAACP calls 'misguided' and 'tone deaf.'"
The Gamm Theater then canceled the contract with the Edwards Twins, which was reported by the ProJo.
Blackface in National News
Professor David Leonard, Chair of Washington State University's Department of Critical Culture, Gender, and Race Studies told Vox that, "Today, blackface reinforces the idea that black people are appropriate targets of ridicule and mockery and reminds us of stereotypes about black criminality, and danger. This, says Leonard, can serve to support implicit bias and discriminatory treatment and in areas from law enforcement to employment."
The issue of blackface has recently come to the forefront not just locally -- but nationally.
During the segment, CNN reported, Kelly said it was OK when she was growing up for white people to dress up as black characters, and she spoke out against a controversy that erupted last year over a reality star who portrayed Diana Ross.
"But what is racist?" Kelly asked. "Because you do get in trouble if you are a white person who puts on blackface on Halloween, or a black person who puts on whiteface for Halloween. Back when I was a kid that was OK, as long as you were dressing up as, like, a character."
Immediately after Kelly's comments, there was a backlash against her for justifying blackface.
Kelly immediately apologized.
After she apologized for her comment, NBC fired Kelly.
Response - No Apologies
Jim Hummel told GoLocal, "My recollection is that Jeff and I went to a Halloween Party back in the 1980s when we were roommates. Miami Vice was a popular TV program at the time and we decided to go as the two main characters, Crockett and Tubbs - in part because Jeff looked like Don Johnson and had a white linen suit. It was a very long time ago when I was a young man and clearly not reflective of my values and I think anybody who knows me would see it in that context."
"Jim Hummel isn't on our staff; we have a contract to run his stories because of his excellent investigative journalism. Regarding Linda Borg, I don't know which comments you're talking about, as you haven't provided them. Whatever they are, Linda doesn't speak for the Journal. She and our other reporters maintain their own private social-media accounts, which are separate from ours," said Alan Rosenberg, Executive Editor of the Providence Journal. Rosenberg was sent a copy of the photo and the comment by Borg.
David Piccerelli of RI PBS tells GoLocal, "I have spoken with Jim and the origin of this picture is from a Halloween Party he attended in the 1980s and has absolutely no reflection on his values or beliefs. Jim is an outstanding journalist and a well-respected person in our community.”
Diversity at the Providence Journal
In 2017, GoLocal reported that the Providence Journal newsroom was void of any minority reporters or editors.
The Providence Journal currently does not employ a minority reporter or editor. For the daily newspaper in an urban community that is majority-minority, the lack of any representation in the newsroom is in stark contrast to the community it covers.
In 2015, the Providence Journal wrote a multi-piece series titled "Race in Rhode Island," but now less than two years later, the last minority reporter, Alisha Pina, has resigned and taken a job in public relations for the State of Rhode Island.
“I was saddened to see Alisha Pina move on. While our communities have become more diverse in cultures, races and languages spoken, the newsrooms made up of people of color have reduced drastically,” said Ann Clanton of the National Association of Black Journalists, New England Chapter.
Editor's Note: A previous version of the article said the Gamm production was canceled after the Journal article; it was canceled before.
Related Slideshow: Incidents of Hate: Racism, Anti-Semitism, and Politics—See All the Numbers, Oct 2018
Map produced by the Southern Poverty Law Center.
Total Hate Crimes in RI — Harassment, Vandalism and Assaults
Southern Poverty Law Center Identifies Three Hate Groups Operating in RI
Rhode Island (statewide) NEO-NAZI
Traditionalist Worker Party
Rhode Island (statewide) NEO-NAZITRADITIONALIST WORKER PARTY
Gallows Tree Wotansvolk Alliance
Rhode Island (statewide) NEO-VOLKISCH
Southern Poverty Law Center Identifies Ten Hate Groups Operating in MA
Concerned Citizens and Friends of Illegal Immigration Law Enforcement
Framingham, Massachusetts GENERAL HATE
The Daily Stormer
Massachusetts (statewide) NEO-NAZI
Waltham, Massachusetts ANTI-LGBT
Nation of Islam
Dorchester, Massachusetts BLACK NATIONALIST NATION OF ISLAM
ACT for America
Boston, Massachusetts ANTI-MUSLIMACT FOR AMERICA
Israel United In Christ
Boston, Massachusetts BLACK NATIONALIST
Israelite School of Universal Practical Knowledge
Lynn, Massachusetts BLACK NATIONALIST
Nation of Islam
Springfield, MassachusettsBLACK NATIONALIST NATION OF ISLAM
Abiding Truth Ministries
Springfield, Massachusetts ANTI-LGBT
Southern Poverty Law Center Identifies six Hate Groups Operating in CT
Connecticut (statewide) GENERAL HATE
The Daily Stormer
Connecticut (statewide) NEO-NAZI
ACT for America
Cheshire, ConnecticutANTI-MUSLIM ACT FOR AMERICA
United Nuwaubian Nation of Moors/All Eyes on Egipt
Hartford, Connecticut BLACK NATIONALIST NUWAUBIAN NATION OF MOORS
Hartford, Connecticut NEO-NAZI
Israelite Church of God in Jesus Christ
Bridgeport, Connecticut BLACK NATIONALIST
Total Hate Crimes in MA — Harassment, Vandalism and Assaults
- Projo Patinkin’s Social Media Criticized As “Demeaning” By Leading RI Women
- Less than Half of Projo’s Articles Written By Newspaper’s Reporters
- Projo Issues Apology After GoLocal Story Exposes Sexist Social Media Posts By Patinkin
- Rickman’s The Big View: Projo, Patinkin, and Sexist Social Media
- Projo Exodus Continues — Reporter Who Wrote About Trudeau’s Physical Appearance Leaves
- Whitcomb Talks ProJo Staff Exodus and Tourism Re-Do on GoLocal LIVE
- Projo’s Bogdan Leaves Paper for Raimondo’s Office - Second Reporter in Two Weeks to Quit
- Projo Reporter Tells Boston Globe “We Get Our Ass Beat All the Time” on Stories
- This Year’s Projo Guild Follies Will Be Last - End of RI Tradition
- Projo Reporter Was Covering Senate While Interviewing for $121K Senate Job
- Media Unrest: Projo Takes Strip Club Ads, Globe Suspends Pulitzer Prize Winner
- GoLocal Welcomes Environmental Columnist Scott Turner, Former Projo Contributor
- EDITORIAL: Projo Praises Mattiello. Any Ties to Trying to Preserve $700K in Legal Notices?
- National Study and Boston Media Expert Blister Projo and Parent Company for Cuts
- Projo Issues Statement After Gun Store Sticker Ad Runs on Top of Synagogue Massacre Story
- WPRI’s Parent Co. Buying Tribune, Projo’s Parent Co. Stock Plummets Along With Circulation
- Projo Cuts Reporter, Editors and Photographer and 3 Leave Newport Daily News
- Andy Smith, Music and Features Writer, Leaves Projo After 30 Years
- More Staff Reductions at Projo and Big Price Increase: UPDATED
- UPDATED: ProJo’s John Hill to Take Buyout, Three More ProJo Employees Seeking Buyouts
- Projo’s Glass House — Company Earns Hundreds of Thousands from Antiquated Legal Notices Requirement
- Projo’s Parent Company Closes More Newspapers Across the United States