Riley: RI Pensions Returns Raimondo Style 2011-2015

Wednesday, December 30, 2015

 

View Larger +

Seth Magaziner

If you are a reader of the Providence Journal you might have read recently about the near double digit returns in the Pension fund for the State of Rhode Island. These returns were used to justify a continuation of a 7.5% discount rate recently confirmed by rookie Treasurer Seth Magaziner who still has no track record of ever making a dime. This year was Mr. Magaziner’s first year actually managing money as Treasurer and he struck out. To be fair, he was hobbled by a Raimondo hodgepodge, a horribly complex massive portfolio of hedge funds, private equity funds, real estate investments, absolute return funds, junk bond specialists, leveraged long short strategies and hundreds of managers and consultants and fees. The table below shows the results of this Frankenstein experiment.

Raimondo used to defend the State’s investment results, but is now silent. New Treasurer Magaziner is like a deer caught in headlights. He‘s virtually paralyzed and meanwhile the last 24 calendar months have just ended with a pension earnings shortfall of nearly $1 billion dollars.

When Raimondo was in the mood to defend her hedge fund experiment she used her spokesperson to call Ted Nesi or K. Gregg and had them repeat the State Investment Commission Data as compiled by CIO Anne Marie Fink. Then they would dutifully publish it.

Here is what CIO Anne Marie Fink said in December 2014:
“Ms. Fink reviewed the performance of the portfolio for the last 3 years and 11 months or the term of the current administration. The portfolio has averaged 8.4% annual gain which compared to 8.3% for the bottom-up benchmark and 7.2% for the 60/40 basic allocation.”

Given the updated data in the table below, she would now have to change that sentence to  something like, and I paraphrase:

  “ ..  over the last 4 years and 11 months or the term of the current administration ,extended to the current treasure Seth Magaziner, the RI pension  portfolio has averaged 6.39% annual gain which is less than half the gain of the S&P 500.”

View Larger +

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

There is no question, that after one of the greatest bull markets in United States History Rhode Island pension system still extremely vulnerable. An appropriate and much lower discount rate would wipe out any theoretical gains that came from unilaterally altering employee pension benefits and inexcusably re-amortizing the liabilities. A more realistic calculation is coming soon in the State CAFR and I suspect the funded ratio which is currently a crisis level 55% will drop to the low 40’s. This will virtually eliminate any chance of a restoration of Cola’s for State retirees.

Until someone in the State shows leadership and tells us the truth about our debt and the economic situation in Providence there is no reason for any of us to believe the Speaker or the Governors efforts to build Stadiums, or payback a rip-off like 38 Studios or to build toll gates in order to borrow their way out of this financial mess. We can no longer bury the next generation in debt and stick our head in the sand. It’s just wrong.

View Larger +

Michael G. Riley is vice chair at Rhode Island Center for Freedom and Prosperity, and is managing member and founder of Coastal Management Group, LLC. Riley has 35 years of experience in the financial industry, having managed divisions of PaineWebber, LETCO, and TD Securities (TD Bank). He has been quoted in Barron’s, Wall Street Transcript, NY Post, and various other print media and also appeared on NBC News, Yahoo TV, and CNBC. 

 

Related Slideshow: Top Providence Pensions

View Larger +
Prev Next

#49

Name- Daniel Guertin

Annual Earning- $95,050.92

Postition- Police-5

City- Providence   

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19,1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#48

Name- Carmine Vallante

Annual Earning- $95,140.20

Postition- Fire-4

City- Johnston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19,1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#47

Name- Alfred Millard

Annual Earning- $95,368.32

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- March 24, 1994

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#46

Name- James Rattigan

Annual Earning- $95,983.44

Postition- Fire-4

City- North Providence   

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- June 30, 2003

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#45

Name- Frank Deangelis

Annual Earning- $95,986.80

Postition- Fire-4

City- North Providence   

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#44

Name- Stephen Lowe

Annual Earning- $96,156.36

Postition- Fire-4

City- Bristol   

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 17, 1992

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#43

Name- Mary Gonsalves

Annual Earning- $97,463.04

Postition- Police-5

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Beneficiary

Retirement Date- December 1, 1993

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#42

Name- William O'Neill

Annual Earning- $98,160.96

Postition- Fire-4

City- Cumberland   

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- August 22, 1990

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#41

Name- Paul Healy

Annual Earning- $98,183.28

Postition- Fire-4

City- Cranston  

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- October 20, 1993

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#40

Name- James Molloy

Annual Earning- $98,711.16

Postition- Fire-4

City- Providence   

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 18, 1987

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#39

Name- Livia Miller

Annual Earning- $99,193.80

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick 

State- RI

Retirement Type- Beneficiary

Retirement Date- May 1, 1997

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#38

Name- Joseph Battista

Annual Earning- $99,271.08

Postition- Fire-4

City- Johnston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- April 29, 2004

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#37

Name- Robert Kerfoot

Annual Earning- $100,140.36

Postition- Fire-4

City- Cranston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- March 24, 1994

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#36

Name- Ralph Ricci

Annual Earning- $100,357.44

Postition- Fire-4

City- Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- April 28, 1994

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#35

Name- Henry Latek

Annual Earning- $100,502.52

Postition- Fire-4

City- Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- June 30, 1995

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#34

Name- Joseph Bradley

Annual Earning- $100,898.52

Postition- Fire-4

City- Whitefield

State- NH

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- November 20, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#33

Name- Ronald Johnson

Annual Earning- $102,098.64

Postition- Fire-4

City- North Scituate

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- May 1, 2003

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#32

Name- Gloria Pisaturo

Annual Earning- $103,385.76

Postition- Police-5

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Beneficiary

Retirement Date- December 1, 2002

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#31

Name- Edmond Malloy

Annual Earning- $103,575.72

Postition- Police-5

City- Chepachet

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- September 5, 1990

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#30

Name- John Reposa

Annual Earning- $104,665.44

Postition- Fire-4

City- Jamestown

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- June 21, 1995

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#29

Name- Pasquale Rocchio

Annual Earning- $105,238.32

Postition- Police-5

City- North Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- August 22, 1989

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#28

Name- David Deignan

Annual Earning- $105,609.36

Postition- Police-5

City- Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#27

Name- Lee Podedworny

Annual Earning- $106,838.16

Postition- Fire-4

City- South Kingstown

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- July 23, 1992

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#26

Name- Nancy Donahue

Annual Earning- $107,757.24

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Beneficiary

Retirement Date- July 1, 2005

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#25

Name- Domenic Pono

Annual Earning- $107,850.72

Postition- Fire-4

City- Cranston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#24

Name- John Murphy

Annual Earning- $107,892.84

Postition- Fire-4

City- Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#23

Name- Robert Carlson

Annual Earning- $108,555.36

Postition- Fire-4

City- Greenville

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- April 24, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#22

Name- Robert Emmett

Annual Earning- $109,256.16

Postition- Police-5

City- Cranston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- November 13, 1990

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#21

Name- Thomas Doyle

Annual Earning- $109,329.24

Postition- Fire-4

City- West Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- August 26, 1988

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#20

Name- Joseph Errico

Annual Earning- $109,611.60

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- June 30, 1995

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#19

Name- Edward MacDonald

Annual Earning- $110,225.64

Postition- Fire-4

City- Johnston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- May 26, 1994

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#18

Name- Alfred Lamothe

Annual Earning- $110,505.96

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- September 6, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#17

Name- Ernest Silva

Annual Earning- $112,796.28

Postition- Fire-4

City- Ft. Myers

State- FL

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- April 24, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#16

Name- Edward Dolan

Annual Earning- $113,126.04

Postition- Fire-4

City- North Kingstown

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#15

Name- Paul Marianetti

Annual Earning- $113,331.60

Postition- Fire-4

City- Ormond Beach

State- FL

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- November 17, 1994

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#14

Name- Rosemary Clark

Annual Earning- $114,725.64

Postition- Police-5

City- Chepachet

State- RI

Retirement Type- Beneficiary

Retirement Date- August 1, 2004

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#13

Name- John Gannon

Annual Earning- $117,318.60

Postition-Police-5

City- Coventry

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- January 24, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#12

Name- Marcia Moise

Annual Earning- $119,791.20

Postition- Fire-4

City- Jupiter

State- FL

Retirement Type- Beneficiary

Retirement Date- April 1, 1997

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#11

Name- Robert Read

Annual Earning- $123,105.00

Postition- Fire-4

City- Cranston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#10

Name- Alfred Bertoncini

Annual Earning- $123,599.16

Postition- Fire-4

City- Smithfield

State- RI

Retirement Type- Service

Retirement Date- December 19,1994

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#9

Name- Victor Dichiara

Annual Earning- $126,845.28

Postition- Fire-4

City- East Greenwich

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 17, 1992

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#8

Name- Edmund Calcagni

Annual Earning- $135,702.72

Postition- Police-5

City- North Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 29, 1990

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#7

Name- James Kelly

Annual Earning- $137,336.04

Postition- Fire-4

City- Greenville

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- September 28, 1988

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#6

Name- Vincent Delisi

Annual Earning- $145,520.88

Postition- Fire-4

City- North Providence

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 17, 1992

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#5

Name- William Manchester

Annual Earning- $148,839.84

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- December 19, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#4

Name- William D'Iorio

Annual Earning- $156,870.60

Postition- Fire-4

City- Smithfield

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- Novemver 29, 1990

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#3

Name- Anthony Sauro

Annual Earning- $161,487.24

Postition- Fire-4

City- Johnston

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- July 5, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#2

Name- Robert Anthony

Annual Earning- $162,944.04

Postition- Fire-4

City- Smithfield

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- September 25, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

View Larger +
Prev Next

#1

Name- Gilbert McLaughlin

Annual Earning- $196,813.08

Postition- Fire-4

City- Warwick

State- RI

Retirement Type- Accidental Disability

Retirement Date- October 24, 1991

Source: This information was secured through a FOIA request from the city of Providence.

 
 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

 
 

Sign Up for the Daily Eblast

I want to follow on Twitter

I want to Like on Facebook

Delivered Free Every
Day to Your Inbox