RI Center for Freedom & Prosperity Criticizes Kilmartin Over “False Assertions”

Saturday, September 01, 2018


View Larger +

AG Peter Kilmartin

The Rhode Island Center for Freedom and Prosperity is responding to “unsubstantiated claims and false assertions” by Attorney General Peter Kilmartin.

The claims from Kilmartin followed the Center’s launch of My Pay My Say RI public awareness campaign last week.

"These responses by union officials - to honest questions by honest workers seeking to make the best decisions for themselves and their families - are blatantly false. I am more convinced than ever that the public service we are providing for public servants is very much needed. It is outrageous that high ranking government officials would conspire to keep public employees in the dark. Nothing we are doing warrants a response from the Attorney General,” said Mike Stenhouse, CEO for the Center.

The goal of the campaign is to inform public servants of their restored first Amendment rights, as ruled by the U.S. Supreme Court in the landmark Janus v AFSCME decision; that workers cannot lose their job or otherwise suffer consequences if they choose not to support the political activism of their union officials by opting-out as a dues-paying member.

On Monday, GoLocal reported that the Center had raised concerns in "Allegations of Coercion, Deception Levied in RI, As Teachers Union Tries to Hold On To Members."

Kilmartin’s False Claims and Center’s Response

According to the Center, Kilmartin’s claims came in a press release titled “outside group.”

According to the Center, in claiming My Pay My Say RI is a "campaign to misinform public sector employees,"the A.G. does not substantiate his attack by providing any evidence or even citing one specific data point that he feels is misleading.

It is false that the Janus decision "only affects ... previous fair share agency fee" payers. All public employees are impacted by the Supreme Court ruling. Every worker now has the full freedom to disaffiliate and, as the AG contradicts himself in his own statement, now must affirmatively consent to paying dues. 

In discussing "confusion about the rights of ... public sector workers" and employees "falling victim to potential misinformation", per reports and feedback the Center has received from the rank and file, it is union officials themselves who are disseminating misinformation, including the false and potentially illegal responses that:

  • The Janus ruling does not apply to Rhode Island or to one particular firefighter union
  • Those who may choose to exercise their right to opt-out of paying dues to their union would no longer be eligible for promotions or for overtime work
  • Anyone wishing to opt-out of union membership must wait until the end of their current collective bargaining agreement.
  • Just days ago, the Center exposed a threatening letter from a local union to its members in an attempt to coerce them to remain in their NEARI union.


The Center continues, “It is an incorrect assertion that the "outside group" (the Center's My Pay My Say RIcampaign) is educating public employees on how to "disaffiliate from their collective bargaining units." It is not legally possible, as far as the Center has been advised, to do what the AG suggests. The campaign does provide an option for workers to opt-out of their government designated union; but public employees, whether they choose to pay union dues or not, legally remain part of the larger collective bargaining unit. It is disconcerting that the chief legal officer of the State of Rhode Island is not aware of this legal nuance.

In no way does the My Pay My Say RI campaign interfere with the legal right for workers to collectively bargain or for public employees to perform their often vital services, as the A.G.'s statement implies. The Center agrees with the A.G. in supporting the "critical role" of public sector employees. 

Finally, the Center also agrees with the A.G. that it is "critical that (workers) seek advice ... from (a) reliable source." However, it is the information on the MyPayMySayRI.com website that is reliable. Conversely, and as evidenced in this statement, mis-information and intimidation put forth by union officials is not reliable.”


Enjoy this post? Share it with others.


Sign Up for the Daily Eblast

I want to follow on Twitter

I want to Like on Facebook


Stay Connected — Free
Daily Email