NEW: WPRI Called Wrong Winner in Cumberland Democratic Mayoral Primary
Thursday, September 13, 2018
The race among the media to be first to call the winner of a contest before it's official is a gamble -- and sometimes it doesn't pay off.
WPRI-12 called the wrong winner in the Cumberland Democratic mayoral primary on Wednesday, before issuing a correction.
WPRI initially reported that incumbent Mayor William Murray was the primary victor, only to issue a correction that challenger Jeffrey Mutter was, in fact, the winner.
The miscue is not the first in Rhode Island history. In the effort to call the race first in the highly contested 1994 Governor's race, WJAR-10 announced that Democratic candidate Myrth York had defeated Republican candidate Lincoln Almond.
In fact, Almond beat York by nearly 14,000 votes. Almond received 171,194 and York 157,361.
Almond went on to beat York again in 1998 and Republican Don Carcieri beat York in 2002.
SLIDES: RI 2018 Primary Night Winners and Losers BELOW
When 100% of the vote was in, Mutter garnered 3105 votes -- good for a 53.1% victory, to Murray's 2747 votes (46.9%).
Related Slideshow: RI 2018 Primary Night Winners and Losers
WINNER: Gina Raimondo
Vultures had been circulating over the Governor’s head for the past couple of weeks with claims that the progressive movement in RI was picking up major steam.
Raimondo flexed her superior fundraising advantage and went negative on Matt Brown and punished him. At last count 56.2 percent to Brown’s 34.2 percent and Spencer Dickinson helping Raimondo with 9.6 percent.
At her celebration on Wednesday night, Raimondo gave a big “thank you” to Rhode Islanders for coming out to vote and she added that the people have spoken, and they want her to “Do more. Go faster. Keep going.”
Raimondo spent over $60 per vote in the primary.
She will run on the performance of the economy and look for Independent Joe Trillo to take votes away from Cranston Mayor Allan Fung.
The Governor’s race has begun. Raimondo still has a reported $2.4 million cash-on-hand.
WINNERS: Women Candidates
Across the state, women candidates won nearly every competitive local or statewide race.
From town councils to the governor's office, women candidates cleaned up.
The only high profile exception was in Senate District 30 in Warwick where challenger Mark McKenney took out progressive, Bernie Sanders-supporter and sitting State Senator Jeanine Calkin. McKenney won 54-46.
And, Patricia Morgan was defeated in the GOP gubernatorial primary.
Otherwise, women retained seats or seats went from male to female. The Providence City Council increases from five women members to eight with likely November wins by Helen Anthony (Ward 2), Kat Kerwin (Ward 12), and Rachel Miller (Ward 13).
LOSER: Speaker of the House Nick Mattiello
Many of the Speaker’s targeted races turned into losses.
He pulled out all the stops to take out Smith Hill State Representative Moira Walsh and had his entire senior staff working primary day out of Patrick’s Pub on Smith Street trying to defeat Walsh.
The upstart reformer would have no part of it and at the last count beat Earnheart 55 to 45 percent.
In addition, Mattiello was on the losing side of Marcia Ranglin-Vassell, Walsh and more.
His win was Dan McKiernan in Providence in District 7 who won a narrow victory over Belen Flores 53.6 to 46.6 percent.
WINNER: Allan Fung
Fung had the more difficult matchup than Raimondo. He had to turn back House Minority Leader Patricia Morgan and he did with a comfortable margin.
Fung beat Morgan 56.4 percent to 40.1 percent. Former CEO of the defunct Benrus, Gio Feroce garnered just 3.5 percent.
Fung gets the Raimondo rematch that he wanted, but faces a number of new obstacles.
Fung needs the Republican Governor’s Association to support his campaign and make good on their $1.5 plus million commitment.
To beat Raimondo and not to get Bob Healey-ed again, he needs to convince the voters of Joe Trillo that a vote for Trillo is a vote for Raimondo.
WINNER: Progressives Locally
Candidates who are strong on progressive Democratic ideals rang up win after win with few losses in the State House or in City Halls.
In Providence, progressive Sam Bell won-a-three way race and cobbled both long-time Senator Paul Jabour and Nick Autiello to capture Senate District 5.
Progressive Rebecca Kislak won House District 4.
And, in the City Council races, Helen Anthony won Ward 2 on the East Side and Rachel Miller won Ward 13 in a four-way race over Cyd McKenna, Leslie Papp, and Ray Beraducci.
LOSERS: Progressives Statewide
Aaron Regunberg was tapped early as a candidate to watch nationally. CNN wrote in 2017 that the RI Lt. Governor’s race was one of nine Democratic primaries around the country to watch. The race did not disappoint in excitement, but in the end incumbent Dan McKee won re-election 51 to 49 percent.
Matt Brown rose from the proverbial political dead in RI and ran to the left of Gina Raimondo and pounded her on her faux pas — UHIP, and more.
But, in the end, for Brown the lack of money, Spencer Dickinson, and an in ability to convince Democrats that his vision is better for RI proved to be the downfall.
And, U.S. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse beat back progressive, peace candidate Pat Fontes.
LOSER: Giovanni Feroce
Giovanni Feroce trumpeted his experience and vision as the differentiation in the Republican gubernatorial campaign.
But, the CEO of the recently failed Benrus was soundly rejected by GOP voters.
Feroce won just 3.5 percent of the primary vote — just 1,137 votes statewide.
WINNER: Best Ad
Maybe no one had a better ad than Kobi Dennis, the Democratic candidate for Mayor of Providence. Dennis raised almost no campaign funds, but did offer up best ad — which featured him being tutored by a 9-year-old about the budget of the City of Providence.
Dennis won 24 percent of the vote in a three-way loss to sitting Mayor Jorge Elorza.
- GoLocal LIVE - Primary Coverage All Day. In Studio and Across the State All Evening.
- RI 2018 Primary Night Winners and Losers
- Insider’s Guide to RI Primary Day - Things You May Not Know
- Primary Night Coverage: RIC’s Val Endress and Former Gov. Lincoln Chafee
- Primary Night: Conservative Talk Show Host Graham and Rickman Discuss Primary Results