Guest MINDSETTER Rep Scott Slater: Replace Illicit Marijuana Industry with Legitimate Businesses
Thursday, March 05, 2015
After decades of arresting citizens for marijuana and spending tens of millions of dollars enforcing punitive marijuana laws, it is clear that efforts to eliminate marijuana use have totally failed. Just like alcohol prohibition, marijuana prohibition has not eradicated marijuana from society. Instead, prohibition has created a vacuum filled by criminals who turn a profit off of the illicit marijuana industry.
Illegal marijuana dealers have no regard for public health and safety. Because we cannot enforce product safety standards as we could in a regulated market, illegal dealers often peddle marijuana laced with dangerous drugs or toxic chemicals. Because business disputes cannot be settled in court, illegal dealers often settle their disagreements through violence, and our communities and law enforcement officers get caught in the crossfire.
By establishing a legal, regulated market for adults 21 and older, we can undercut the illicit marijuana industry with legitimate, taxpaying businesses. Colorado saw nearly $700 million in sales for legal marijuana last year — $700 million that might have otherwise gone into a violent criminal market. Eliminating the underground marijuana industry will not happen overnight, but just as Al Capone’s gangsters are no longer engaging in shootouts over turf because of alcohol, in time the illicit marijuana market will evaporate, as customers prefer a safer product in a safer setting.
Under our current policy of prohibition, profits from marijuana sales go into the pockets of criminals, leading to more crime, violence and guns on our streets. By regulating and taxing the production and sale of marijuana to adults 21 and older, we can redirect that money toward better uses, such as improving our schools and providing treatment to individuals who struggle with substance abuse.
Although marijuana is not harmless, it is important to keep in mind that virtually every objective, scientific study has found marijuana to be far less harmful to the consumer and society than alcohol. While thousands of Americans die every year from alcohol poisoning, there has never been a single recorded case of a marijuana overdose death. Research published in the British Columbia’s Mental Health and Addictions Journal found the social costs of marijuana use are far lower than the costs associated with alcohol or tobacco use. We should be comforted by the fact that well-known leaders in the Rhode Island medical community, including Dr. James Crowley, former president of the Rhode Island Medical Society, Dr. Daniel Harrop, a licensed psychiatrist, and Dr. David Lewis, founder of Brown University’s Center for Alcohol and Addiction Studies, have all publicly expressed their support for ending prohibition and regulating the sale of marijuana to adults.
Marijuana prohibition is on the way out in America, and it’s no longer a question of if, but how and when. Rhode Island has already decided that our citizens should not be burdened with a criminal record simply for using marijuana, so it makes little sense to force those marijuana consumers into a dangerous criminal market. Massachusetts, Vermont and other New England states are very likely to pass laws to regulate and tax marijuana by the end of 2016.
We do not need to wait any longer to know that prohibition is the worst policy to have for marijuana. I urge my colleagues in the General Assembly to realize that the issue before them is not whether to have marijuana in society or not. The question is whether we are going to take control away from the illegal dealers and allow the state to regulate, control, and tax marijuana in a way that benefits us all.
Related Slideshow: Marijuana Use in the New England States
According to data collected by the Substance Abuse & Mental Health Services Administration, New Englanders are among the nation's top marijuana users in the country. See how the indivdual states compare in the slides below:
Percent of respondents who used marijuana in the past year: 12.45%
National Rank: 13th most
Possession Laws: Decriminalized (2.5 ounces or less)
Percent of respondents who used marijuana in the past year: 12.50%
National Rank: 12th most
Possession Laws: Decriminalized (less than 0.5 ounce)
Percent of respondents who used marijuana in the past year: 14.19%
National Rank: 5th most
Possession Laws: Decriminalized (1.0 ounce or less)
3. New Hampshire
Percent of respondents who used marijuana in the past year: 14.60%
National Rank: 4th most
Possession Laws: Medical Use Only
2. Rhode Island
Percent of respondents who used marijuana in the past year: 14.85%
National Rank: 3rd most
Possession Laws: Decriminalized (1.0 ounce or less)
- New Report: Legalized Marijuana Could Generate up to $82M for RI
- Legalized Marijuana in Jeopardy with Mattiello as Speaker
- State Report: Marijuana Tax + Bill Targets Prostitutes and Pimps
- Will New Findings on Marijuana Dangers Hurt Legalization Efforts?
- RI Hospital: Legalizing Med. Marijuana Does Not Increase Youth Use
- Legalized, Taxed Marijuana Would Generate .1% of RI Budget
- Guest MINDSETTERS™: A Sensible Marijuana Policy for Rhode Island
- NEW: New England NAACP Calls for Marijuana Legalization in RI
- Do You Favor Legalized Marijuana and Taxation in Rhode Island?
- PODCAST: Legalized, Taxed Marijuana Would Generate .1% of RI Budget
- Marijuana Debate Evolves as New Advocacy Group Forms
- Marijuana Tax Has Bipartisan Support in RI
- NEW: ACLU Files Suit Over Medical Marijuana Discrimination
- Regulate RI Seeks to Make Rhode Island the Next State to Regulate Marijuana Like Alcohol
- Guest MINDSETTER™ David Ellison: It is Time We End the Prohibition of Marijuana
- NEW: National Marijuana Advocate in RI for Legalization Forum
- Marijuana “Patient Vapor Lounge” to Open in Downtown Providence
- Can Medical Marijuana Help Stop the Opiate Epidemic in RI?
- Synthetic Marijuana: Is it the Next Heroin?
- Obamacare Implications of Medical Marijuana in Rhode Island
- Marijuana Tax Bill Presented to Senate Committee
- Personality Test of Marijuana Users Reveals Surprising Results
- Leonardo Angiulo: Further Refining the Investigation of Marijuana Offenses
- Marijuana “Vape Lounge” to Open in Downtown Providence on Saturday