Pros and Cons for the Tiverton Casino - What Each Side Says

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

 

View Larger +

Some in Tiverton are not too excited about a casino coming their way. While the Rhode Island budget may be hooked on the revenue, some in Tiverton -- a town of just 15,000 plus.

Tiverton is old - the community was in corporated in 1694 as part of Massachusetts, but now may be the biggest game changer for the community in its history is before the voters -- whether or not to allow a major casino to locate in the seaside town.

View Larger +

Ray Rickman and Josh Fenton on In the Arena

THIS SUNDAY, ABC6's "In the Arena" explores the issues tied the proposed Tiverton Casino. John Taylor of Twin River and Ed Roderick, Former Town Council President join host Joe Paolino, former State Representative Ray Rickman, and Josh Fenton CEO of GoLocal on the panel. The show airs on Sunday on ABC6 at 7:00 am and can be viewed on GoLocalProv.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Rhode Islanders have seen millions of dollars of TV ads and digital ads on GoLocal promoting the proposed move and expansion of Newport Grand to Tiverton and an expansion to a full casino. In Tiverton, there is a group of residents who are opposed to the proposed move and expansion. According to them, the proposed move is a bad deal and it would ruin the small community.

"I think the Casino in Tiverton is nothing more than corporate greed to ruin the beauty and environment of the Town of Tiverton. Especially since it is being built on the bones and historical places of my ancestors the Pocasset Pokanoket Tribe, historically those are the hunting grounds, trails and burials of the Tribal Nation the Wattupa being close to the site originally inhabited by Pocasset's. The Corporation or the State has never reached out to us to save or even consider saving sacred areas on those grounds. So how will they treat the other residents of Tiverton. It is sad to see what this has become a gambling State when we have so many beautiful resources," said Daryl Black Eagle Jamieson Eagle. Clan Council Chief Pocasset Pokanoket.

For a casino initiative to become law it must pass statewide and the host community. Rhode Islanders will be voting on Question #1, but only Tiverton voters will be casting ballots on Question #8.

"We've spent only $700 and collected only a few hundred more (report to be filed this week). We do feel like momentum is building, particularly since we are still getting requests for signs. We also see that more of the locals supporting the casino -- politicians, town employees, school department employees, or and/or union members -- have a specific agenda," said Mike Silvia, Organizer, No Tiverton Casino. "Our only agenda is saving Tiverton from Twin River and the RI legislature. We realize the odds are daunting, but we will continue to share real data, the history of broken promises, and the path of destruction left by casinos in other communities between now and November 8."

After three of the State's Chamber of Commerce came out in support of the move to Tiverton and the expansion to a full gaming facility, John Taylor, Jr., chairman of the Twin River Management Group said, "We’re grateful for the support of these three leading chamber organizations which collectively, represent more than 3,000 businesses from all corners of the state. We’re excited about the possibility of 550 - 600 jobs at the proposed Tiverton casino as well as the additional gaming revenue – approximately $50 million - to the state which would be nearly double that of Newport Grand today. We think that’s good news for the state and we hope the voters on November 8 agree and vote yes to approve on Question 1 statewide and locally, yes to approve on Question 8.”

View Larger +

Proposed Tiverton Facility

But while statewide business and labor rally for passage of the casino questions, other continue to rail against the expansion of the proposal.

{I feel that casinos are a false hope of support to the host community they are placed in. The quality of life in Tiverton will be destroyed for little pile of crumbs left over. Plain Ridge in Massachusetts was under target revenues for its first year and all the municipalities that neighbor the casino have reported an increase of criminal and suspicious activity in the vicinity of the casino. Unless 100 percent of all the casino's revenue comes from non-residents, it will defeat it's purpose to help the host community residents but at the same time the casino will kill all of the small local businesses in the host community. It's just a bad plan all around to save or support Tiverton in the long run, just take a look at the failure of redevelopment of the host community promised in Atlantic City that casinos were suppose to bring. I am voting no on 1," said Brian Hutchings a voter in Providence.

Others are raising economic concerns. "The Net Effect: Local businesses invariably suffer, as resources are diverted out of the local market. Add to this the subsidization of Twin River's dining and entertainment facilities by its highly profitable monopoly (never mind State of Rhode Island "advertising" subsidies) and you have a recipe for continued economic chaos," said Pat Ford, head of RI's Libertarian Party.

"I have been and always will be against casinos wherever they are. The Rhode Island General Assembly has an addiction to casino gambling. I want to see clean industry here in this state. Companies Like GE, PayPal, Fidelity. I would like for this State to also be able to tap into the multimillion cyber security industry and become the Silicon Valley of cyber security. This will provide great paying jobs to the residents here that are struggling to stay afloat," said Anthony Spiratos, former Republican political candidate for RI Senate.

View Larger +

GoLocal takes a look at the claims of the anti-casino group and asked Twin River’s team to respond to the argument put forth by No Tiverton Casino.

READ BELOW the Pros and Cons

 

Related Slideshow: Pros and Cons for the Tiverton Casino - 2016

View Larger +
Prev Next

Jobs

No Tiverton Casino Claims:

FEWER JOBS Most of the 600 “well-paying” jobs Twin River promises are low-paying, part-time or temporary. The average income touted is for certain positions only, with benefits and tips (not predictable) representing well over 30% of it. In addition, existing Newport Grand employees will move into those jobs, and Twin River is now off the hook for paying Sunday overtime, meaning even lower earnings.

Twin River's Response:

The average salary at Twin River is $56,000 inclusive of tips and benefits. We have learned that some of our colleagues prefer to work part time which is why we offer a mix of full and part time.
The decision not to offer time and half on Sundays was brought to us by the unions on behalf of their employees which we supported.

 

View Larger +
Prev Next

Taxes

No Tiverton Casino Claims:

NO TAX RELIEF Despite promises, Lincoln has seen virtually no tax relief since it voted for a new Twin River facility in 2012. In fact, Lincoln’s $21.60 tax rate is 12.9% higher than Tiverton's $19.14, and Lincoln's commercial tax rate is a whopping 38% higher! Furthermore, Twin River’s revenue projections for Tiverton already fall short by $1 million. The State of Rhode Island pledges to cover the difference – with YOUR TAX DOLLARS! 

Twin River's Response:

Twin River pays for police and fire detail officers during all hours of operation to supplement security within the facility and respond to calls for service.  According to Joseph Almond, town administrator, the town of Lincoln has not had the need to hire any additional police officers or fire/medics in conjunction with the Twin River operation.  Further, the Administrator confirmed that there has been no corresponding impact on the crime rate or calls for service within the community. 
In 2015, Twin River paid to the town of Lincoln $3.8 million in property and other taxes and an additional $7.8 million from gaming revenues, making it the second largest taxpayer in Lincoln. Of Twin River's $11.6 million total contribution, $9 million supports the municipal and school department operating budgets.  This represents about 10 percent of the town's annual budget.
The Town's tax Assessment records support the finding that there has been no negative impact on residential property values in the vicinity of the twin River Casino.  Further, the town's remaining business community has shown no evidence of cannibalization of revenues and the town is experiencing an increasingly vibrant business climate.

 

View Larger +
Prev Next

Crime

No Tiverton Casino Claims:

MORE CRIME Countless newspaper, television and government reports reveal excessive criminal activity directly related to casinos. Larceny, muggings, vandalism, petty theft, embezzlement, shootings, property crime and aggravated assaults are just a few of the highlights. Twin River’s recent crime spree has included most of these. Do you know what community crime does to your insurance rates? 

Twin River's Response:

Last year, there were 1,431 incident calls, not 1,431 emergency calls. If we break down the 4 calls on average per day, approximately 2.5 - 3 of them are general reporting or daily log-incalls that might include such activity as dress code violations, self-exclude violations, touching the chips on the table and/or a guest becoming a bit too boisterous.

Those calls - the vast majority - are handled by Twin River security personnel and the on - site Lincoln Police Department personnel which Twin River pays for.

The remaining on average 1 to 1.5 calls per day may produce an incident report and a request for off- site Lincoln Police to come to the property and those incidents might include a fender bender in the parking lot, petty theft and medical emergencies.

Since 2007, when Twin River underwent an extensive renovation and increased its footprint, not a single police officer has been added to the Lincoln Police Department.

It bears underscoring that Twin River is four times the size of the proposed Tiverton Casino.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Town Resources

No Tiverton Casino Claims:

RESOURCE BURDENS In 2015 alone, Lincoln’s protection services departments received over 1600 calls directly related to incidents at Twin River -- 1,431 emergency police department calls and 222 emergency fire department calls. The Tiverton Police Department, with current staff, will be overburdened with even a small percentage of this activity. 

Twin River's Response:​

Since 2007, when Twin River underwent an extensive renovation and increased its footprint, not a single police officer has been added to the Lincoln Police Department.

It bears underscoring that Twin River is four times the size of the proposed Tiverton Casino.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Traffic

No Tiverton Casino Claims:

HEAVY TRAFFIC The round-about will not mitigate traffic because it was designed over a decade ago for existing traffic. Twin River’s own 4,000-vehicles-per-day estimate was not considered, and the round-about does not address current congestion on the single-lane road approaching the Tiverton border from Route 24 and William S. Canning Boulevard. For years, the state and RIDOT were not particularly interested in addressing the situation; however, the Twin River proposal has suddenly moved them to fast-track construction. BAD FOR BUSINESS Casinos hurt local non-gaming businesses because casino visitors generally do not leave the premises. Casinos are actually designed to encourage such behavior, and they offer food, entertainment, shopping, etc. to keep patrons on the premises until they run out of money.

Twin River's Response:​​

Twin River has complete 90 percent of the design of the roundabout. It envisions entirely new traffic patterns as a result of casino operations. If the measure passes,then we have made considerable progress.  If it fails, the town of Tiverton will benefit from our engineering and design.  We have publicly stated that the casino will not open until and unless the roundabout is in place, in fact, it's included in the legislation, now law. 
 

 
 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

 
 

Sign Up for the Daily Eblast

I want to follow on Twitter

I want to Like on Facebook