INVESTIGATION: Elorza Failed to Disclose Arrest
Thursday, August 28, 2014
Providence mayoral hopeful Jorge Elorza, who has styled himself as the candidate of ethics and transparency, was once arrested for shoplifting at a local store in an incident that has not been fully disclosed to the public, GoLocalProv has learned.
Elorza, now 37 and a law professor at Roger Williams University, was 18 years old when he stole a shirt from a department store in Warwick in a bid to impress his friends, according to a letter his campaign issued in June and information provided in response to GoLocalProv queries. He eventually pled no contest to a misdemeanor shoplifting charge and was sentenced to 20 hours of community service.
But the new revelation is at odds with the public image he has projected of himself as the ethically clean candidate amid a field populated by a two-time felon, former mayor Buddy Cianci, and a city pol, Michael Solomon, who is now under the cloud of a state ethics investigation.
In a statement, Elorza insisted that his past is not relevant, while the past wrongs of his opponents—alleged or actual—are.
“Cianci was twice convicted of felonies while serving in elected office. Solomon is currently under investigation by the State Ethics Commission, also while holding elected office. I committed a misdemeanor as a teenager, took full responsibility, did my community service, chose to disclose it all publicly, and have never had a legal problem again,” Elorza said, adding that he disclosed it to his campaign co-chairs and campaign manager before they joined.
Elorza shoplifted to ‘impress my friends’
Elorza has gone into some detail about his background in interviews with media and a bio posted on his campaign Web site. He has described how his parents came here illegally. He has discussed the meager life his family eked out on Cranston Street. He’s admitted to nearly failing out of high school. And he’s told of how the murder of a childhood friend led him to renounce a life on Wall Street for public service.
Asked when it had been publicized, a campaign official said Elorza had brought up the arrest in while speaking to some CCRI students and a group of teenagers at the Rhode Island Training School.
Elorza also mentions the arrest in a June 20 letter mailed to 7,000 likely voters in the city. In a copy of the letter which was recently obtained by GoLocalProv, Elorza describes the shoplifting incident as a senseless act from which he learned an important life lesson:
“I want to be upfront about a mistake I made years ago as a young man, because I want you to hear the story directly from me. When I was 18 years old, I was caught shoplifting a shirt from a department store. Why did I do it? I don’t have a good answer. Like a lot of teenagers, I wanted to impress my friends. I knew it was the wrong thing to do, and I accepted full responsibility immediately. I faced a judge and served my community service hours …” Elorza writes.
“I learned a valuable lesson and I’ve never been in trouble with the law again,” he concludes.
When asked why Elorza thought it relevant to mention an arrest dating back to 1994 in a letter to voters, campaign manager Marisa O’Gara responded: “Much of his story is about his struggles as a young man, and how he turned his life around. He chose to be forthright about this because he believes strongly in transparency and ethics, and he wants to be completely upfront with the people of Providence. He wants them to hear directly from him how these struggles shaped his vision for Providence.”
With less than two weeks left until the September 9 primary, political analysts said it’s hard to predict what impact news of the arrest would have on the race.
For those voters who have already decided on a favorite candidate, news of the arrest is not likely to change their minds, according to Victor Profughi, a veteran political pollster and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Rhode Island.
But it could be a different story for undecided voters. “When it comes to undecideds, they’re really a peculiar, peculiar lot,” Profughi said, saying undecideds are difficult to categorize because they come in “all shapes, sizes, and forms.” While most voters might not care too much, a small segment of undecideds might, Profughi said.
In a close primary race, that could matter, said Joe Fleming, who runs a local polling firm. “Obviously, an arrest in a close election, that could have an impact on it,” Fleming said.
But he said that without more information about the case—and without doing some polling of its own—it would be hard to know how news of Elorza’s brush with the law would affect voters. Some stories that seem like they have legs often go nowhere, Fleming said. “Other things you think are nothing and they grow like crazy,” he added.
Elorza’s chances for winning the Democratic primary have brightened considerably last week about the third major Democrat in the race, Brett Smiley, dropped out and endorsed him. At a joint press conference, Smiley expressed confidence in Elorza’s promise to run a City Hall that is clean, honest, and ethically above board.
All but one of the remaining major candidates in the race declined to weigh in on news of Elorza’s arrest. Solomon declined comment, while Cianci did not respond to a message seeking comment.
But the sole GOP contender in the race defended Elorza.
“Not relevant, and does not matter. I don’t believe he is hiding anything else. I knew about this a long time ago, someone having passed along the letter,” said Dan Harrop. “I never brought it up since at this stage in his life, after all he has accomplished, it just is not something to discuss. Just a distraction from the real issues of the city finances, in my opinion. I would prefer he spend his time discussing how he will fix the pension fund—still waiting for that.”
Stephen Beale can be reached at [email protected] Follow him on Twitter @bealenews
Related Slideshow: RI Politicians Who Sought Redemption from Misdeeds
Vincent "Buddy" Cianci
As one of the longest-serving "big city" mayors in United States history, Rhode Island has experienced Cianci's ups and downs for over 21 years.
Now twice-convicted Cianci is once again back in RI's spotlight running as an Independent in the Providence Mayoral race.
Cianci was forced to resign as Mayor in 1984 after being indicted on assault charges.
In April 2001, Cianci was indicted on federal charges of racketeering, conspiracy, extortion, witness tampering, and mail fraud.
He served four years in a federal prison.
Providence City Council President and Democratic candidate for Mayor Michael Solomon is currently being investigated by the Rhode Island Ethics Commission.
Solomon failed to report a city loan for the Conrad Building on his annual ethics filings.
Michael Long, the Providence Ward 1 Republican City Council Candidate, filed a complaint that charged Solomon with 25 violations of the disclosure requirements.
Dominick Ruggerio is the Democratic Majority Leader of the Rhode Island Senate.
A member of the Senate since 1985, he was elected Majority Leader on November 10, 2010, having won election to his 14th term in the Senate on November 2, 2010.
Ruggerio was arrested for shoplifting condoms in 1990. He was not prosecuted.
In 2012, Ruggerio was charged with a DUI.
In 2002, Former Speaker of the House John Harwood faced unproven sexual misconduct charges.
The allegations brought against Harwood, but never proven, were that he had sex with Statehouse aide Wendy Collins.
Frank Ciccone III
Democratic member of the Rhode Island Senate Frank Ciccone was arrested twice in the 1980's. He has represented District 7 since January 2005.
In 1981, Ciccone punched both a cab driver and passenger in Providence.
Just two years later, Ciccone was charged with possession of a loaded shotgun in a moving vehicle and for breaking a window in a bar.
Although Ciccone was found guilty of lesser charges for both these incidents, they were later expunged.
In 2012, Ciccone intervened when Ruggerio was stopped by police for drunk driving.
Ciccone lost committee chairmanship but is now running for re-election.
Robert A. Watson
Robert Watson, a Republican member of the Rhode Island House of Representatives and an attorney, was arrested twice for marijuana possession.
On Friday, April 22, 2011, Watson was stopped in East Haven, Connecticut at a police checkpoint. He was charged for both marijuana possession and a DUI.
Watson was arrested in South Kingston, RI for possession of marijuana on Jan 22, 2012. In his car were also three containers of alcohol.
Since 1992, Watson has represented the 30th District.
John M. Carnevale is a Democrat of the Rhode Island House of Representatives. He has represented District 3 since January 2009.
Carnevale was indicted by a grand jury on charges of first- and second-degree sexual assault in October 2011.
His alleged victim died of a pulmonary embolism shortly after the indictment.
The charges were dropped by Attorney General Peter Kilmartin, who cited the inability to proceed with the case due to no longer having the woman's testimony.
In 2012, Carnevale ran unopposed for both the September 11, 2012 Democratic Primary, winning with 550 votes and the November 6, 2012 General election, winning with 2,901 votes.
This past March, the State House office of Former Speaker of the House Gordon Fox was raided by the RI State Police in conjunction with FBI and IRS agents.
This marks the first time a State House office was ever raided by law enforcement officials.
Fox resigned from the Speakership effective March 22, 2014.
Republican candidate for Governor Allan Fung was involved in a fatal car accident in February of 1989 when he was an 18-year-old college student.
After losing consciousness at the wheel on I-95, Fung ran over and killed James W. Skipper, Jr. of Pawtucket.
A grand jury declined to indict him and his record was expunged.
A relative newcomer to politics, Providence mayoral candidate Jorge Elorza is running on a platform of ethics and transparency, but he’s had his brush with the law as well.
In a campaign letter Elorza admitted to being arrested for shoplifting as an 18-year-old.
He says he has since transformed his life, going from CCRI to a job on Wall Street, then to a profession in law. A former housing court judge, he resigned his position to run for Mayor.
- Elorza Blasts Smiley for “Intentionally Misleading Voters”
- Russell Moore: Elorza, Smiley and Double Standards
- Questions Jorge Elorza Must Answer to be Providence’s Next Mayor
- Elorza Unveils Five-Point Plan for Providence City Services
- NEW: Elorza Hires Taraborelli as Communications Director
- NEW: Providence Mayoral Candidate Elorza Closes Quarter with $82K
- NEW: Elorza Calls for Changes to School Busing Policy
- NEW: Mayoral Candidate Elorza Reports $182K in 2013 Fundraising
- NEW: Smiley Calls for Elorza to Disavow Marrocco Endorsement, Money
- Elorza Responds to Smiley Over Marrocco Support
- NEW: Former Smiley Staffers Join Elorza Ranks
- NEW: Elorza Picks Up Three More Endorsements
- Russell Moore: Elorza, Smiley Cut an Insider’s Deal
- Elorza/Smiley Deny Back Room Deal in Mayoral Shake Up
- Who Has the Best Chance to Beat Cianci - Elorza or Solomon (or Harrop)
- Elorza Outlines Vision for Curriculum and Assessments
- With Solomon Leading Democratic Primary, Smiley To Drop Out and Support Elorza
- Deal Done: Smiley and Elorza Team Up to Try and Beat Back Solomon
- INVESTIGATION: Elorza Failed to Disclose Arrest