| | Advanced Search


Gronkowski “Good to Go” Week 1—Rob Gronkowski told reporters at Gillette Stadium that…

Russell Moore: Experience Makes Caprio a No-Brainer for Treasurer—Let's face it: politics is strange business.

Smart Benefits: Two Regs Issued on Contraceptive Coverage—Two regulations on contraceptive coverage were recently issued…

Peace Flag Project to Host Rhode Island Month of Peace in September—The Peace Flag Project will host over 30…

Don’t Miss: Fall Newport Secret Garden Tours—The Benefactors of the Arts will present a…

Fall Activities for the Whole Family—Mark your calendars for the best activities of…

Skywatching: Seagrave Memorial Observatory Centennial (1914-2014)—Skyscrapers, Inc., the Amateur Astronomical Society of Rhode…

Friday Financial Five - August 29, 2014—The Tax Foundation has put together a helpful…

RI Resource Recovery Collected 6K Pounds of Clothes—RI Resource Recovery has received more than 6,000…

5 Live Music Musts - August 29, 2014—We’ve got Rhythm and Roots and a whole…


Good Is Good: Is It Time For An Obesity Tax?

Thursday, December 13, 2012


Tom Matlack is the former CFO of the Providence Journal and is the founder of The Good Men Project, a non-profit charitable corporation based in Rhode Island and dedicated to helping organizations that provide educational, social, financial, and legal support to men and boys at risk.

Sunday morning I was watching the ABC national news.  I would prefer to keep my head in the sand but my wife likes to know what is going on in the world for some reason. One of the lead stories caught my attention for its stupidity. A bar somewhere in the SouthWest had been serving three obese women and the bar tender had entered into his computer the words “Fat Girls” on their check as a way to keep track of who they were.  Apparently it was for his eyes only but he forgot to erase it before handing them their bill.  The women were very upset–”scarred” in the words of the crack ABC reporter who provided footage of the bar manager being interviewed, the FB comment from the bar owner, and the first person testimony from the ladies in question with tears running down their quite full faces.

I watched the story and just asked myself what the heck? Is this really even a news story?

As luck would have it a few hours later I was at a neighborhood Christmas party.  I live in the “Longwood” section of Brookline which is literally a stone’s throw from the most prestigious cluster of hospitals and medical research facilities in the world. As usual I was awkwardly holding my diet coke as my wife socialized with ease.  I found myself standing with an older gentleman in a bow tie and 60s era black-rimmed glasses who I had seen at church but never spoken to.  He asked me a few questions about where I lived and what I did and then I asked him what his line of work might be.  He allowed that he was the head of cardiology at one of the best known hospitals in the world.

“But I will never see you at my practice,” he said quickly.  I asked why.  ”Because you are not obese,” he responded.

What followed was a fascinating, if troubling discourse on medicine and our health care system that I can’t say that I fully understood but certainly caught my attention.

“I’m from Texas,” Mr. BowTie said. “Back in the day you had a heart attack and you died. Now we have all these drugs to keep people alive for years and years, wheeling them around in chairs and replacing their knees and all kinds of crazy stuff when the whole problem is a self-induced one to begin with.”

Mr. BowTie proceeded to tell me that indeed heart disease can be caused by a family history. But what use to be the norm is now a tiny fraction of the cases he sees.  ”All I treat now are morbidly obese people whose hearts give out,” he said.  ”And then we keep those obese people, more men than women mind you, alive forever at huge cost to everyone in the health care system.”

I thought back to John Stewart’s debate on the Daily Show with Chris Christie of New Jersey over Obamacare when he talked about the working mother with cancer and no coverage being just as much of an emergency as the victims of Sandy.  The thought crossed my mind for just an instant, even as a bleeding-hearted liberal democrat, maybe that is a false comparison based on what this guy is telling me.

Pretty soon my little Christmas party chat became an all-out discussion of national health care policy.  ”One third of the health care costs in this country are directly or indirectly caused obesity,” he claimed.  ”And that number is going down.”  I later sought to confirm that number and found a bunch of lower estimates online.  But even the ones put out by places like the national institute of health are alarmingly high. And no one seems to refute the idea that the percentage of our national health care dollar going to care for the obese is growing.  And growing quickly.

“What we need to do is force every citizen to pay for health care premiums based on their BMI,” he concluded.  ”It’s the only fair way to force the issue.  Make people who consume more of the resources pay for it and hopefully incent people to grapple with the magnitude of this issue.”

I had to admit that between the fiscal cliff, global warming, and war in the Middle East, I really hadn’t been focussed on the impact of obesity on us as a people.  But Mr. Bowtie made a lot of sense as far as a complete non-expert could tell.

What do you think?

For more of Tom's works, as well as other pieces on related topics, go to The Good Men Project Magazine online, here.

If you valued this article, please LIKE GoLocalProv.com on Facebook by clicking HERE.


Related Articles


Enjoy this post? Share it with others.


Tom, apparently you missed the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs statement last year wherein he realized that obesity is causing a national security crisis. 60% of people in society are unfit for military service due to obesity or lack of exercise. Combined with the national debt, we are in trouble.

Comment #1 by Dave Barry on 2012 12 13

What do I think? Personally I would like to know who the heck you think you are? How about before making such a despicable suggestion, those of you that agree with this, live a week in an obese person's life, and find out what it entails. Maybe they are taking steroids because they have Lupus, maybe they have a pituitary issues, maybe their thyroid has stopped working, perhaps they have degenerating disks in their back, or some other joint issue..... No one is better than someone else! How come mocking or harassing the obese is accepted in the first place? You don't allow it against minorities because you're being racist, you don't allow it against religions, because well we know where that goes .... so how dare anyone even make these comments or suggestions in regards to someone's health issue! No one has the right to tell another human being how to medically care for themselves on any level. I suggest those who feel they do, should reign in their superiority attitudes.

Comment #2 by jen atack on 2012 12 13

Maybe we should tax liberal ideas like this. An idiot tax.

Comment #3 by Michael Trenn on 2012 12 14

it would never work - the democrats in Congress do not believe in making people who consume more pay for it, no matter what the issue.

what they want to do is make the successful people pay for it, even if those people do not consume anything.

the issue would create another class for the Obama admin to consider victims of society.

and if it were implemented, the government does not have the intelligence or efficiency to perform due diligence on fraud.

Comment #4 by Mateo C on 2012 12 14

Write your comment...

You must be logged in to post comments.