The Death of the Providence Renaissance

GoLocalProv

The Death of the Providence Renaissance

Providence Place -- losing upscale retailer Nordstrom
The Providence Renaissance began in the late 1990s — it was a catchphrase for the re-invention and the marketing of the capital city.

The federal and state governments spent hundreds of millions to reclaim the rivers and create Waterplace park. The State of Rhode Island under Governor Bruce Sundlun built the Convention Center. And, then there was the de facto game changer — the development of Providence Place Mall and the return of retail to downtown Providence.

Providence adorned the front page of national newspapers, like USA Today and the New York Times, with glowing articles about the city's rebirth.

GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST

Two decades later Providence is stagnant. A new report of the fastest growing cities in America ranks Providence number 458 out of 515 ranked.  

The population of Providence has decreased over the past fifty plus years. Providence’s population in 1960 was 207,498 and today it is just 179, 219.

And now, the Renaissance seems to be morphing into the Dark Ages. On Monday, Nordstrom announced it was closing its anchor store in Providence Place Mall. It was Nordstrom’s first store in New England and its location in the then-new Providence Place Mall in 1999 made the statement that this property was for upscale shopping.

When the Mall opened the anchors were Filene’s, Lord and Taylor, and Nordstrom.

Now, Nordstrom — one of the top retailers in the country is being replaced by Boscov’s — a retail chain out-of Pennsylvania.

“Boscov’s, which describes itself as the largest family-owned, full-service department store chain in the United States, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection early Monday. It is the latest in a parade of U.S. retailers, including Mervyn’s and Steve and Barry’s, that have sought protection from creditors in a grim economy,” reported the New York Times in August of 2008. The chain has rebounded from the bankruptcy, but faces the same pressure of other retailers.

Buddy Cianci coined the phrase "Renaissance City"
“My father-in-law was also instrumental in the revival of Providence, turning it into a retail and tourist destination.  He loved to tell me the story of how he and then-Mayor Buddy Cianci traveled to Seattle to try to persuade Nordstrom to open up shop in what was believed to be a dying New England city.   It worked.  Nordstrom now anchors the Providence Place development, which has attracted national retailers, upscale condominiums, and companies that have relocated to Providence because it has become very cool city,” wrote Dennis House, the late Sundlun’s son-in-law.

Jorge Elorza’s office said that the Mayor was unaware of the Nordstrom closure. “The city was not informed of the closure or reason for closure but is encouraged by the fact that another tenant has already been secured to take its place,” said Elorza spokesman Victor Morente.

The loss of Nordstrom is a blow to Providence’s psyche and reputation.

 

Political Issue

Providence Mayoral candidate Dianne “Dee Dee” Witman called the closure of the Nordstrom store at the Providence Place Mall “another hit to the City of Providence.” She used the announcement as another opportunity to criticize Elorza.

“Nordstrom’s closure shows the lack of attention this administration is paying to businesses across the city,” said Witman. “Retailers cannot thrive in the business climate created by our Mayor.”

Witman criticizes Elorza's handling of the critical city issues
Witman also pointed to the shooting of a teenager directly outside the Nordstrom location as evidence that increased crime in the city is beginning to affect tourism and the revenues that come from families shopping and dining in the city.

“If people don’t feel safe visiting our malls or walking through our city, our businesses are the ones who ultimately lose out,” said Witman. “As Mayor, I will take proactive steps to show that Providence is safe and open for business.”

Witman says these actions would include increased foot patrols by city police at the mall and other prominent locations in the city.

 

Superman building -- closed for 5 plus years
Latest Blow

Ironically, Business Insider listed the tallest building in each state, the publication wrote, “The Bank of America Building is Rhode Island's tallest skyscraper at 428 feet. It bears the nickname the "Superman Building," since it looks like the newspaper building from the 1950s "Superman" television show.” The business publication is unaware that the building has been vacant for more than five years.

Ironically, New York developer Jason Fane has been seeking approval for two years to build a proposed 46-story apartment building. Fane's project as proposed is expected to cost more than $300 million. He has developed a similar project in Toronto, Canada. READ about Fane's Toronto project. Fane has been frustrated by the length of the review process in Providence.

 

Mt. Pleasant High School, proficiency in English 9% and math 4.5%
Student Murdered, School Buses Going on Strike, Federal Lawsuits

While the closure of Nordstrom and the vacancy of the Superman building raise questions about the financial health of the City of Providence, a series of incidents tied to Providence’s schools are raising even more questions about the city’s momentum.

A two-week-old school bus drivers’ strike is creating havoc for families and is sparking a lawsuit by the Rhode Island ACLU on behalf of special needs children. That suit is expected to be announced on Wednesday at a press conference.

In September, 15-year-old William Parson was murdered in front of a Providence School.

In August, the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division and the United States Attorney's Office of Rhode Island announced a settlement with the Providence public school district to provide English language services to the district’s nearly 8,000 English language learners. 

READ MORE about the growing number of challenges of the Providence Public Schools.


The 50 Greatest Living Rhode Islanders

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.