Greco: Why I Disagree with Hinckley’s Approach to Economic Recovery
Thursday, March 13, 2014
Aside from having the highest unemployment rate in the country, Rhode Island ranks well below its New England neighbors in many quality of life factors. Clearly, we need new, innovative ideas on how to move our state forward. This is why Barry Hinckley’s column, emblematic of so much of conservative thought these days, is so frustrating and disappointing.
Read Barry Hinckley's Column: 4 Things RI’s Government Can Do to Improve the Economy, But Won’t
To understand, however, why Mr. Hinckley’s 4 Things RI’s Government Can Do To Improve The Economy, But Won’t are not the answer. One needs to look at conservative ideas over the past forty years. In the 1970s there were a variety of problems the country faced. After forty years of new deal prosperity, the country began to decline is some key areas. There was a general feeling that inflation, crime, and taxes were too high and that we needed a vigorous defense against the iron curtain. Conservatives came up with a variety of solutions to these problems that led to electoral and (to a lesser extent) policy success.
The problem, however, is that while many of these concerns have dissipated over the past forty years and new concerns have arisen (rising health care costs, income inequality, immigration, education, an out of control financial sector, and a turbulent and ever changing world), conservative ideas have failed to address these growing problems in any meaningful way. They are still addressing problems that the country had forty years ago. This is why many conservatives are confused when words like high taxes, government spending and regulation do not carry the same outrage today than they did in the 1970s. It is also why millennials are rejecting conservative ideology in droves, as the most recent Pew poll demonstrates.
The solutions Barry Hinckley points us towards (lower taxes on the wealthy, tort reform, vouchers and school choice) are not new ideas. They are the same ideas that conservatives have been trumpeting for the past forty years. In fact, in addition to deregulation, starting wars, drilling for oil, and building a border fence, they are pretty much the ONLY ideas conservatives have provided over the past forty years. This would be fine, of course, if these ideas had a proven record of success.
The last two decades have told us that they don’t. All these ideas were implemented during George W. Bush’s eight years in office, and proved to be an unmitigated disaster. We doubled the national debt, increased income inequality, fought an unnecessary and unpopular war, and crashed the economy. Bush had a 25% approval rating the day Obama was elected. Barry Hinckley’s ideas would bankrupt the state, decimate the safety net that Bush’s reckless fiscal policies have made necessary, and provide little boost to the economy. These policies are nothing more than the same trickle down economic policies that have proven to expand income inequality and crush our already tenuous state budget. They do not address Rhode Island’s concerns. The state needs real ingenuity and creativity; not discredited ideas that have failed us in the past.
Although my political leanings are unquestionably progressive, I believe that we need both market and government solutions to solve the myriad of problems we have on the state and national level. The conservative movement’s failure to address the issues facing us today, choosing to cling to the failed policies of the past, has done both this state and this country a disservice. All Barry Hinckley’s column does is put an exclamation point on it.
Greg Greco has been a teacher for sixteen years, and is active member of the Religious Society of Bell Street Chapel and a progressive activist. Greg has been a lifelong resident of Rhode Island and is deeply invested in the future of the Ocean State.
Related Slideshow: The Ten Biggest Issues Facing the RI General Assembly in 2014
The latest report by the House Finance Committee illustrates that Rhode Island will start the next fiscal year, which starts in July 2014, with an estimated deficit of $149 million. The report shows the FY 2014 Budget contains numerous overspending problems—meaning that the General Assembly will have to cut costs somewhere.
So where will the cuts come from? Lawmakers will have to examine the state's costliest programs. According to the Rhode Island Public Expenditure Council, the most expensive government programs in Rhode Island are Elementary and Secondary Education, Public Welfare, Pensions, Higher Education, and Interest on Debt. Click here to view a comprehensive list of the state's costliest government programs.
The state may be two years removed from Central Falls filing for bankruptcy, but 2014 could be the year that other financially strapped Rhode Island communities follow suit—most notably Woonsocket and West Warwick.
With bankruptcy on the table in both 2012 and 2013, this year poses more financial uncertainty for the cash-strapped city of Woonsocket. Earlier this year, the city's bond rating was downgraded due to the city's numerous financial issues—including a growing deficit, increasing unfunded pension liability, and a severe cash crunch.
Similarly, the embattled town of West Warwick faces a variety of financial questions in 2014. With its pension fund set to run out by 2017, the town must address its unfunded liabilities this year if it hopes to regain financial stability. That, coupled with an increasing school department deficit, make West Warwick a contender for bankruptcy.
Look for Woonsocket and West Warwick's elected state officials to address their respective cities' financial issues in the upcoming legislative session.
With the Special Joint Legislative Commission to Study the Sales Tax Repeal set to report their findings to the General Assembly in February, the possibility of sales tax repeal in Rhode Island could become a reality in 2014.
"Our sales tax is killing small businesses, especially those in border communities," said Rep. Jan P. Malik (D-Dist. 67, Barrington, Warren), the commission's chair. "How can Rhode Island continue to compete at 7 percent, with Massachusetts already lower than us and considering reducing its sales tax even farther? How can Rhode Island restaurants compete at 8 percent? They can’t. We need to find a way to fix this, and a serious discussion of our sales tax is a discussion we need to have, now, before more small stores close their doors."
In addition to Malik, proponents of sales tax elimination include the Rhode Island Center for Freedom and Prosperity and Forbes Magazine.
EDC Reorganization to Commerce Corporation
On January 1, 2014, the Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation will be replaced with the Rhode Island Commerce Corporation—a move which has the potential to impact to adversely affect recipients of federal funding contracts made possible currently through the EDC.
This could include the state's Broadband Initiative, Brownfields program, and other contracts made through the EDC. As a result, recipients will now be required to re-apply for federal funding as of January 1st.
The massive overhaul of the EDC was prompted by the 38 Studios debacle, which is projected to cost Rhode Island taxpayers $102 million. 38 Studios, the now defunct video game company, filed bankruptcy in May 2012 just months after securing a $75 million loan from the EDC.
With the state's marijuana decriminalization law going into effect this past April, Rhode Island may be a candidate for marijuana legalization in 2014.
Legislation to legalize marijuana has been introduced in each of the last three years, but has never been voted on. Earlier this year, Rep. Edith Ajello (D-Dist. 3, Providence), who is chair of the Judiciary Committee, introduced the bill in the House. Roughly half of the Judiciary Committee supports the measure.
The bill also has the support of the Marijuana Policy Project, an organization focusing on drug policy reform, which hopes to legalize marijuana in ten states, including Rhode Island.
Approximately 52 percent of Rhode Island voters support legalizing marijuana for recreational use, according to a Public Policy Polling survey conducted in January.
Marijuana is currently legal in Colorado and Washington.
Come November 2014, Rhode Island voters will likely be asked whether they wish to convene a constitutional convention, which involves individuals gathering for the purpose of writing a new constitution or revising the existing one.
Every 10 years, Rhode Island voters are asked whether they wish to amend or revise the constitution. Voters rejected this opportunity in 1994 and 2004. Although rare, Rhode Islanders can vote to hold a constitutional convention and in effect, take control over the state government.
If approved, a special election is held to elect 75 delegates, who then convene to propose amendments to the Rhode Island Constitution. These amendments are then voted on in the next general election.
The likelihood of this occurring highly depends on if the General Assembly does its job to ensure residents that the state is heading in the right direction financially and structurally.
Rhode Island’s last constitutional convention took place in 1986. It proposed 14 amendments—eight of which were adopted by voters.
Education Board Structure
Less than a year after the General Assembly created the 11-member Rhode Island Board of Education to replace the Board of Regents for Elementary and Secondary Education and the Board of Governors for Higher Education, there are multiple questions surrounding the structure of this newly consolidated agency.
Although lawmakers voted to merge the state's two education boards in June, the Board of Education now wants to split its agency to create two separate councils—one with the statutory authority over kindergarten to grade 12 and another governing higher education.
The Board of Education will present its proposal to the General Assembly during its next legislative session and lawmakers will once again determine how the agency should be structured.
The Board of Education currently governs all public education in Rhode Island.
Sakonnet Bridge Tolls
Rhode Island may have implemented tolls on the Sakonnet River Bridge this past year, but they could be gone by 2014.
On January 15, the East Bay Bridge Commission—which was established to allow lawmakers and officials investigate various funding plans, potentially eliminating the need for tolls on the Sakonnet River Bridge—will report its findings to the General Assembly. The General Assembly is then required to vote on the issue by April 1.
The commission was established in July following the General Assembly's approval of the 10-cent toll.
Located on Westminster Street in Downtown Providence, the former Bank of America Building (commonly referred to as the Superman Building) may be the tallest building in the state, but as of right now, it's just a vacant piece of property.
The building's current owner, High Rock Westminster LLC, was most recently looking for a total of $75 million to rehabilitate the skyscraper—$39 million of which would come from the state.
With the sting of the 38 Studios deal still fresh in the minds of lawmakers, a $39 million tax credit appears unlikely.
The question of what will become of the Superman Building remains to be seen.
Championed by Republican gubernatorial candidate Ken Block (while head of the RI Moderate Party), the movement to eliminate the Master Level, which allows voters to vote for all candidates of one political party with a stroke of the pen, is poised to heat up in 2014.
Despite Block's strong push to repeal the 1939 law, the measure did not get a vote in the General Assembly last session.
In October, Block told GoLocal that he believes that House Speaker Gordon Fox is responsible for the General Assembly not voting on the proposal.
“Despite the support of a majority of 42 state Representatives, thousands of emails from concerned RI voters and unanimous testimony of more than 100 people who came to the State House in person to testify that the Master Lever had to go, the Speaker personally killed the bill in the most unaccountable way possible—he did not allow the House Judiciary Committee to vote on the bill,” Block told GoLocal.
Speaker Fox has stated on multiple occasions that he believes the Master Level is a legitimate tool that many voters use.
- RI Housing Market Showed Signs of Solid Economic Recovery in 2013
- RI’s Economic Recovery Hits a Bump in the Road
- Segal Unveils Plan for Economic Recovery
- 4 Things RI’s Government Can Do to Improve the Economy, But Won’t
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT RI Economic Recovery
- Lardaro Report: Progress of RI Economic Recovery Discouraging
- Guest MINDSETTER™ Barry Hinckley: Senator Whitehouse’s Vote Against RI Jobs
- NEW: RI Economic Recovery Slowing
- NEW: Report Says State’s Economic Recovery is Slowing
- RI Economic Recovery: Better Than Expected