Don Roach: When Rights Collide – Homosexuality and Religion
Wednesday, February 26, 2014
Our use of the term “anti-gay” has become a little excessive. I was reading about a law in Arizona that would allow any person or corporation the ability to claim the practice of religious exercise as a defense to violating certain sections of Arizona law.
Nowhere in the text of the law is the word “gay”, “black”, “white”, or other buzzwords used to attach an –ist claim to such language. Nevertheless, most media outlets are calling the bill an “anti-gay” piece of legislation so let me add some context around the bill.
First of all, most state have equal protection statutes the contents of which employers are required to post somewhere employees to see. These statutes usually talk about not discriminating based on race, religion, creed, national origin, and sexual orientation. For the purpose of today’s analysis, let’s only view these laws with respect to religion and sexual orientation.
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLASTIn practice, this means states cannot make laws nor support actions by any entity (unless exempted) that discriminated based upon religion or sexual orientation. For example, if I apply for a job at Citizens Bank, Citizens cannot use my religion or lack thereof as a criterion in its hiring practice. Were I a homosexual man, the same would hold true. If, during the process I felt discriminated against on those grounds, I could seek legal redress against Citizens.
The law in Arizona appears to be addressing businesses that object to certain aspects of homosexuality – namely gay marriage – and refusing to serve them based upon their religious convictions. Recently, there was a story of a wedding photographer who refused to take photos for a gay couple on religious grounds and was sued – and lost . In response to the ruling against his client, the attorney for the photographer said:
The idea that free people can be ‘compelled by law to compromise the very religious beliefs that inspire their lives’ as the ‘price of citizenship’ is a chilling and unprecedented attack on freedom.
Americans seem to agree as a Rasmussen poll found that 85 percent of Americans believe that “if a Christian wedding photographer who has deeply held religious beliefs opposing same-sex marriage is asked to work a same-sex wedding ceremony, […] he has the right to say no.”
Alternative, the lawyer for the couple who sued the photographer successfully argued in court that:
No court has ever held that the First Amendment gives businesses a license to sell goods and services to the general public but then reject customers based on race or religion or sexual orientation, in violation of state law.
While America appears to overwhelmingly agree with this photographer, the courts did not.
What happens when rights collide?
The situation with the photographer and the Arizona law are about rights colliding. Free religious exercise is one of the primary reasons people from Europe came to America as many couldn’t freely practice their religion. Still, if my religion called for me to murder someone every 28 days, religious exercise wouldn’t be a sufficient defense. In recent years, many in the faith community have discussed the implications of gay marriage and churches refusing to marry same-sex. I haven’t heard any local or national pols that churches do not have a right to marry whomever they want to marry. It’s not dissimilar to Catholic churches refusing to marry people who are not Catholic.
Thus the question is where do we draw the line between exercising our First Amendment right to practice our own religion against other rights?
In situations with gay marriage, it is a dicey legal situation. Most Americans favor allowing people to practice their religion and even a majority of Americans are fine with gay marriage. One argument in support of gay marriage has been how it doesn’t affect people who are heterosexual. That’s not the main argument, but it is certainly an argument in debate. Well, in these two examples there will be impact and if you are a businessperson with considerable convictions about an issue, where are your protections?
Where are your rights? Do you as a business person just not sell anything?
I feel we need to strike a balance, but I’m not quite sure how. I wish I could end with a solution, but unfortunately I don’t have one. Do you?
Don can be reached at [email protected] . Please follow don on Twitter at @donroach34.
Related Slideshow: Human Rights Campaign’s Municipal Equality Index Scorecard - Providence, RI
HRC's Municipal Equality Index (MEI) demonstrates the ways that many cities can—and do— support the LGBT people who live and work there, even where states and the federal government have failed to do so. GoLocal pulled the data from the 2012 and 2013 reports to show where progress has been made in Providence and Rhode Island.
This year's report rates a total of 291 cities from every state in the nation, representing a total population total of 77,851,822. To see how PVD compares to other cities, download the full 2013 MEI report here and the 2012 version here.
Related Articles
- Don Roach: 38 Studios Was Never a Good Investment
- Don Roach: A Conversation with Representative Brian Newberry
- Don Roach: Are You Ready to Kill Syrians?
- Don Roach: Carcieri Makes Chafee Look Like a Genius
- Don Roach: Fiscal Cliff? What Fiscal Cliff?
- Don Roach: Hinckley Closing in on Senator Whitehouse
- Don Roach: It’s Doherty or Bust for Rhode Island
- Don Roach: Marriage Equality Advocates Don’t Love All Minorities
- Don Roach: Newt Gingrich – Your Next U.S. President
- Don Roach: Occupy & the Tea Party – Twins Separated at Birth
- Don Roach: RI Politicians Don’t Know Jack About Business
- Don Roach: The Power Of Poverty
- Don Roach: What Happened to the Occupy Movement?
- Roach challenges RINEA’s Walsh
- Don Roach Reacts to David Cicilline’s Victory
- Don Roach: 5 Big Stories Facing RI in 2014
- Don Roach: A Moment of Truth for Mitt Romney
- Don Roach: Assessing Blame for the Latest Fiscal Crisis
- Don Roach: Chafee’s Switch Doesn’t Matter… To Anyone
- Don Roach: Fung Gains Cranston GOP Endorsement as Block Falters
- Don Roach: How Will the Next RI GOP Chair Restore Credibility?
- Don Roach: Jim Langevin Should be Very Afraid of Mike Riley
- Don Roach: Megyn Kelly Needs a Serious Reality Check
- Don Roach: No Significant Need To Wear Your Seat Belt
- Don Roach: Paul Ryan will Not Win Over Rhode Island
- Don Roach: RI Sales Tax Needs to go
- Don Roach: There Will Be Blood
- Don Roach: When Is Enough Enough, Rhode Island?
- Roach’s Radical Solution to the Pension Problem
- Don Roach’s Political Wish List
- Don Roach: 5 Most Intriguing Stories from 2012
- Don Roach: After Iowa, What Next?
- Don Roach: Black History Month Needs to Go
- Don Roach: Cicilline & Gemma Make the Case for Doherty
- Don Roach: GOP Relevancy for Dummies
- Don Roach: Hypocrisy, Thy Name Is Obama Diplomacy
- Don Roach: Jockeying for Position in the 2014 Governor’s Race
- Don Roach: Mike Riley can Beat Jim Langevin
- Don Roach: North Korea’s Napoleon Complex
- Don Roach: Paula Deen, Affirmative Action + 21st-Century Racism
- Don Roach: Religious Freedom isn’t Important to Obama
- Don Roach: Too Many Vacancies in Occupy Movement
- Don Roach: Who is Clay Pell?
- Roach: Bin Laden Brought the Best out of America
- Don Roach: Immigration reform appears imminent
- Don Roach: 5 Reasons Conservatives Don’t Trust Romney
- Don Roach: Allan Fung Needs to be RI’s Next Governor
- Don Roach: Black People are Getting Lost in the American Shuffle
- Don Roach: David Cicilline Ruined Providence
- Don Roach: Gay marriage debate at the tipping point
- Don Roach: I Am a Republican…We’re Idiots
- Don Roach: Just Say No to In-State Tuition for Illegal Immigrants
- Don Roach: My Education Crusade - An Interview with Deborah Gist
- Don Roach: OMG! The Government Shuts Down!
- Don Roach: Political Things I’m Thankful For
- Don Roach: Rhode Island Needs a Sales Tax Holiday
- Don Roach: Trying To Make Sense Of The Zimmerman Verdict
- Don Roach: Why President Obama Won Last Night’s Debate
- Roach: Targeted Providence Schools Should Close
- Don Roach: ‘Choose Life’ License Plates Another Win For Tolerance
- Don Roach: 5 Reasons Taxing the Rich is Stupid
- Don Roach: America’s Most Wanted Man Finds No Rest In Death
- Don Roach: Blind Faith in Cicilline is Reckless
- Don Roach: Deborah Gist, You Go Girl!
- Don Roach: Gemma Looks to Expose Cicilline
- Don Roach: I Didn’t Watch the Inauguration
- Don Roach: Latinos Are The Key to the Republican Revolution
- Don Roach: My Education Crusade Begins Today
- Don Roach: Obama Campaign Takes Cue from Karl Rove
- Don Roach: President Obama has Failed to Turn Around the Economy
- Don Roach: Rhode Island’s Christmas Carol
- Don Roach: Vote Republican in 2012
- Don Roach: Will Gemma Knock Off Cicilline?
- Roach: This Is Why People Hate Politics
- Don Roach: 10 Things I Want for Christmas
- Don Roach: 5 Things We Learned on Election Day
- Don Roach: An Equitable Solution to Illegal Immigration
- Don Roach: Boston Bombing—The Latest Challenge To Our Freedom
- Don Roach: Diversity is Overrated
- Don Roach: Good Intentions Often Lead to Hell
- Don Roach: If Cicilline Wins In 2012, Voters Lose
- Don Roach: Let’s Get Ready To Rumble
- Don Roach: NECAP and Gist
- Don Roach: Obama Goes on the Offensive
- Don Roach: Providence City Council Unanimously Votes Republican
- Don Roach: Super Tuesday, The Day of Reckoning?
- Don Roach: Wake Me When the CD-1 Race Begins
- Don Roach: With Santorum Out, Nothing Left to Stop Romney
- Roach: While Prov Fiscally Flounders, Cranston has No Tax Increase
- Don Roach: 2012 Election Predictions
- Don Roach: 5 Things to Watch for in 2012
- Don Roach: Angel Taveras is Losing His Shine
- Don Roach: Brendan Doherty Needs to Up His Game
- Don Roach: Does Anyone Care About Cranston School Secretaries?
- Don Roach: Governornment Loans are Bad Business
- Don Roach: If Progressives Win, We Lose
- Don Roach: MLK’s legacy is More than Just a Holiday
- Don Roach: NSA Warrantless Surveillance The Beginning of the End
- Don Roach: Obama Justified in Killing Americans?
- Don Roach: RI GOP Gun Raffle Shows Moxie