Julia Steiny: Best Beach Read—Paul Tough’s ‘How Children Succeed’
Wednesday, July 03, 2013
Tough was a New York Times journalist, so it's an easy read. He's a terrific story-teller who weaves storylines in and through his narrative, as he makes subjects like brain chemistry seem like no big deal. And, truth to tell, I felt full-on vindicated by his taste in research, given that he gravitated to many of my favorites, including the licking rat moms.
Finally, someone with celebrity cred is looking at the conditions that allow kids to learn. He unmasks the so-called "the cognitive hypothesis," which is the widespread belief that if you just jam enough academics into a kid's life -- including inanities like Baby Einstein videos and pushing reading on two-year-olds -- test scores and graduation rates will improve.
And if you don't think you're interested in kids or education, this is still your book. Yes, it speaks to the education industry, which isn't really getting anywhere, despite the bellowing about teacher evaluation, accountability, testing, and the rest of it. But it also addresses parents, and those of us freaking out about the sad state of parenting, from neglectful parents to those raising fragile, hot-house flowers who've never suffered a dodge-ball hit, never mind a well-deserved "F." Most inclusively, the book should appeal to any and all taxpayers who wish that at all levels, government would spend their hard-earned bucks more wisely and effectively.
The subtitle is -- Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of Character. These are qualities that can be nurtured, if not taught by direct instruction. Certain personal characteristics help a kid yearn to read, open her heart to algebra, or persist through the fall of the Roman Empire.
The word "grit" was reinvigorated by the Knowledge Is Power Program, or KIPP. Tough illustrates key points by recounting a turning point in the 20-year saga of KIPP's network of 125 charter schools. In 1994, two Teach For America veterans opened their first KIPP school, grades 5 - 8 in Houston, Texas. The motto is: "Work hard; be nice." Days are long; discipline is strict and unforgiving. Since charter-school families chose to send their kids to these schools, an informal selection process weeds out those who could not tolerate demands that some consider to be academic browbeating.
However, when it comes to test scores, KIPP is king. Early on, their kids were headline news; funders swooned. In an age when test scores are all-important, KIPP became widely imitated. Its flaw, to my mind, was that KIPP schools teach low-income and minority kids obedience and compliance, not creative problem-solving. What happens to their academics when no one's threatening or barking them into meeting expectations? Tough tells that story.
It turns out that as KIPP students got older, they did graduate high school in significantly greater proportions than their regular district-school peers. It was in college where they fell apart. After bouncing in and out of different colleges, one KIPP graduate said, "There's no one checking in if you did your homework. We had to deal with all the stuff that everybody goes through in high school, just growing up. And none of us were really prepared for that." Ah, there's more to success than test scores.
To their credit, the KIPP leaders flipped out as news of college drop-outs came back to them. Rather than hide the problem -- a rampant educational temptation -- they explored it.
Tough reports, "The students who persisted in college were not necessarily the ones who had excelled academically at KIPP. Instead they seemed to be the ones who possessed certain other gifts, skills like optimism and resilience and social agility. They were the students who were able to recover from bad grades and resolve to do better next time; who could bounce back from unhappy breakups or fights with their parents; who could persuade professors to give them extra help after class; who could resist the urge to go out to the movies and instead stay home and study."
KIPP has since changed much of its practice to incorporate the teaching of these "soft" skills. Authoritarian, punitive techniques are giving way to more social and personal support.
In general, How Children Succeed discusses in detail how we can care for our kids in ways that build their resilience. It starts with making sure every child is loved and attached to at least one parent, preferably two, and an extended family to boot. But he also understands that kids need "discipline, rules, limits; someone to say no."
Balancing discipline and love is the big challenge for anyone who cares for children whether at home or in institutions like schools. Our kids need far more loving care than they're getting, largely because so many people act as though the kids are someone else's problem. They're not.
EducationNews.org. She is the founding director of the Youth Restoration Project, a restorative-practices initiative, currently building demonstration projects in Rhode Island. She consults for schools and government initiatives, including regular work for The Providence Plan for whom she analyzes data. For more detail, see juliasteiny.com or contact her at [email protected] or c/o GoLocalProv, 44 Weybosset Street, Providence, RI 02903.
- Julia Steiny: A Fresh Take on Separate, but Not Remotely Equal Schools
- Julia Steiny: Bloodlust For Boston Bombers Won’t Aid Healing
- Julia Steiny: Recess Is Good For Mental Health
- Julia Steiny: Why Kids Still Need Computer Science
- Julia Steiny: Can’t Achieve STEM Goals without Computer Science
- Julia Steiny: Careful What You Want & How You Measure Getting It
- Julia Steiny: Rhode Island, Raise Your Rock-Bottom Expectations
- Julia Steiny: Schools Help Minorities Become the Serfs of the Information Age
- Julia Steiny: Equity OR Excellence—Open Enrollment or Selective Admissions?
- Julia Steiny: Students Can Take More Responsibility for Success
- Julia Steiny: The Man Who Made Algebra Child’s Play
- Julia Steiny: Fifth-Graders Having a Blast with Algebra
- Julia Steiny: Teaching to a Tech-Savvy Generation
- Julia Steiny: A “Forest Kindergarten” Grows Great Kids
- Julia Steiny: Great Communities Are Happy, Healing Places
- Julia Steiny: The Importance of Having a Father
- Julia Steiny: At Last! A Computer Science Course For All Kids
- Julia Steiny: Legislators, Stop Ruining Four Months of School
- Julia Steiny: There Is No Health Without Mental Health
- Julia Steiny: Best Beach Read—Paul Tough’s ‘How Children Succeed’
- Julia Steiny: Michelle Rhee Throws Gas on Ed Reform Hostilities
- Julia Steiny: UK Expert Marc Armitage Brings Playwork To US Educators
- Julia Steiny: Blackstone Academy ‘Kicks Butt’
- Julia Steiny: Public Schools Owe Neglected Kids More Than Academics
- Julia Steiny: What Mom Rats Can Teach Us About Child Rearing