| | Advanced Search

 

Rhode Island’s Best Communities 2013: #39 to #1—The 4th annual analysis of RI's 39 cities…

#1 Newport: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#2 South Kingstown: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#3 East Greenwich: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#4 North Kingstown: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#5 Warwick: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#6 Cranston: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#7 Providence: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#8 Richmond: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

#9 Barrington: RI’s Best Communities 2013—Cast your vote!

 
 

Scott Cordischi On Sports: Feeling The Heat!

Thursday, February 28, 2013

 

I'm feeling the heat, but staying in the kitchen!

Twenty years ago I moved to Rhode Island where I have been both a sports talk radio host and sports writer. As such I have given my opinions on many local, national and international athletes, coaches and teams. However, none have elicited the type of response that Tuesday’s column entitled “Hurley To Rutgers? Don’t Be Surprised” has.

The premise of the column was that URI men’s basketball coach may be a top candidate for jobs at Rutgers or Seton Hall should they open up in another month or so.

I was simply connecting the dots on what I believe could be a logical scenario.

Dan Hurley

Rutgers coach Mike Rice is believed to be on thin ice and could very well be fired by the school this offseason. Dan Hurley, a former Rutgers assistant and New Jersey native, is a well respected coach in his home state of New Jersey for his work as both a high school and college coach. And a program that will soon be transitioning from the Big East to the Big Ten could surely offer a financial package to its head coach far more attractive than what the University of Rhode Island can.

For all of those reasons, I did not think that it was unreasonable to suggest the possibility of a scenario whereby Hurley could be offered and accept such a job.

This generated quite a stir in both the comments section under the column here on GoLocalProv.com as well as Facebook.

I was accused of “stirring the [expletive],” “shabby journalism” and having a “PC bias.”

Criticism comes with the territory when you put your opinion in print or over the airwaves for everyone to see or to hear. I can live with that.

But, in this particular case, I think that has gone a bit too far.

Rick Barnes

I certainly understand where the loyal, diehard fan would dig in his or her heels to defend the program they love so much. No fan wants to believe that a coach could leave after only one year on the job.

You would think that college basketball fans would remember that Rick Barnes left George Mason after just one year to come here to Providence in 1988. And Hurley, himself, left Wagner after just two years on the job to come to URI.

One critic suggests that there is no way that an 8-win coach like Hurley could be hired by a team in a power conference. Generally speaking, I would agree with that statement. But there’s more to this story that meets the eye.

Hurley won 25 games at Wagner a couple of years ago and his reputation is well-known in New Jersey. Furthermore, there was no expectation of greatness in his first year in Rhode Island so this 8-win season could be easily overlooked.

What’s more important is the fact that Hurley has managed to put together a solid first recruiting class which combines talented freshman and transfers that will all join the mix next fall. That is what a smart basketball person will focus on.

If offered a job at Rutgers or Seton Hall, would Hurley feel guilty about leaving URI after just one year? Certainly! He had mixed emotions about leaving Wagner to come here last spring. Those feelings are only natural.

However, ultimately, there would be other factors to consider, factors such as more money, a higher level of competition and exposure and the chance to return home.

To put it in terms that the average Joe like you and me can understand, it would be like having a chance to double your salary AND go back home to work. Who would say “no” to that type of opportunity? Not too many people.

Maybe my favorite comments are those suggesting that I have some type of “PC bias” that has prompted me to write such a story.

Let me make a few things clear.

First, I like Dan Hurley and think that he is an excellent coach and would like nothing more than to see him remain at URI and lead the program back to prominence.

I am a fan of URI basketball just as much as I am a fan of the Providence Friars and the Bryant Bulldogs. If I have any bias, it would be towards Syracuse (my alma mater) or Brown (the team whose games I have broadcast for many years).

Ed Cooley

In fact, earlier this season, I wrote an article critical of Friars head coach Ed Cooley for how he handled his postgame press conference following a loss to Brown. There were some Friar fans who didn’t agree with my opinion in that story which was fine. But that’s what I get paid to do, give my opinion on sports. And it’s funny how I didn’t have one URI fan suggest that I had a “PC bias” then.

But, back to this story. This whole scenario may ultimately never take place. Rutgers and Seton Hall may not fire their head coaches. And, even if they do, maybe Hurley wouldn’t be on their short lists of candidates. And maybe Hurley wouldn’t leave URI after just one year.

Still, unlike some of my critics, I don’t see any harm in suggesting that this scenario is a possibility to consider. There are plenty of logical reasons to support the argument and I stand by my story that it remains a possibility.

-If anyone has a old, dirty pair of socks, can you please stuff them in Terrell Suggs’ mouth? I’m sick of hearing him whine about how nobody likes the Patriots. Enough already! You have your Super Bowl title, don’t you? Now shut up and go away!

Terrell Suggs

-Did you see where Red Sox 3B Will Middlebrooks reinjured his right wrist last night in the team’s exhibition game against Baltimore? Not good!

-You’ve gotta love new Sacred Heart Athletic Director Bobby Valentine who said, “not even Connie Mack” could win with the Red Sox last year.

-Tom Brady renegotiates his contract to help the Patriots and he still gets criticized. I don’t get it. Meanwhile, Peyton Manning is on the books for $18 million with Denver this season but nobody criticizes him.

-This just in: the Bruins are good!

-Given the way that the #1 team in the country has fared this season in division one men’s college basketball, I wouldn’t want to be the top-ranked team heading into this year’s NCAA Tournament.

Bobby Valentine

-Various reports say that the New England Patriots may cut WR Brandon Lloyd. That would seem to make re-signing Wes Welker an absolute must.

-I wish I could figure out a way that the Miami Heat don’t win another NBA title this year. But, short of an injury to LeBron James, I can’t.

-The “Open Tournament” for Rhode Island high school basketball is now in its third year and continues to be an overwhelming success.

-Did you see where police in Milwaukee are searching for the sausage? I kid you not. Police are investigating the theft of a $3,000 Italian sausage costume used for the sausage races at Milwaukee Brewers games at Miller Park.

Milwaukee sausage races

-Congratulations to Rhode Island College men’s basketball player Tahrike Carter who became the first player in Little East Conference history to win Player of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year and Little East Tournament MVP honors all in the same season. And congrats to the Anchorman who have won another Little East title. I have said it before and I’ll say it again, when is RIC’s Bob Walsh going to get his much-deserved shot at being a D-1 head coach?

-When will the Ivy League wake up and have a conference tournament for men’s and women’s basketball?

-The Rhode Island Interscholastic League’s Unified Sports pairing students with intellectual disabilities with able-bodied students in co-ed basketball is a fantastic program that has grown from a participation rate of 10 to about 30 schools in just a few short years and should be celebrated.
 

 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

Comments:

Bobby Townsend

I hear ya Scott. I don't get paid to make opinions here but honestly, I DO think Rice will get fired at Rutgers. His seat got much hotter when he was suspended for a few games early this season. As for Willard, I think he will stay on at Seton Hall.
You may not remember Scott but when Hurley got the URI job last year, I was totally against it and felt Walsh should have at least been a serious candidate.. He is already being paid by the state anyway isn't he??
I went on a rant last year saying how URI was being shortsighted and not hire a coach to use as a stepping stone to a bigger job two years down the road. That does the program no good whatsoever.

Bobby Townsend

There are three things gauranteed in life.... death, taxes and Bobby Valentine saying the wrong things during any interview. And I am positive Connie Mack could have led them to about 85 wins, not 69 even though Mr. Mack has been dead for several years now.
Word on Middlebrooks is there is no structual damage to his hand and that he felt a sharp pain when swinging at a high, inside fastball. Says he going to hit in the cage on Thursday but even if all is well with him, he better figure out how to turn on that pitch, otherwise, he will be seeing alot of that once the scouts take note of that.
Guido, the Italian Sausage has been found. I feel like having one right now.

Bobby Townsend

Could this be the year a 16 seed beats a 1 seed in the NCAA?. Should be interesting to see how the committee seeds the teams this year
I think the Ivy League should have a tournament with both men and women in the same venue at the same time.
The Metro Atlantic did that last year with the Mens and Womens tournament held in Springfield, Mass (Mass Mutual Center they call it) I have been there and it is smaller than the DUNK so I am sure they can find a site roughly that size. Even the DCU Center in Worcester wouldn't be a bad place to have it. I have been saying that for years.

Charles D.

I have been one of the most vocal critics of Mr. Cordischi in this matter, but in fairness to him, the issue is broader than him as it involves some confusion at GoLocalProv about its role and mission. In print journalism especially broadsheets, there is a clear cut distinction between news stories and the editorial pages where opinion and dissenting commentaries are found, but with GoLocalProv there is a blurring of that distinction. This point appears lost to Mr. Cordishi and his defenders as evidenced by their countless paragraphs repeating over and over the logic of the Hurley scenario. I agree with them that this development is very plausible, but again that is not the issue, it is this blurring between news and opinion that is the crux of my criticism. So even if the Hurley scenario comes true, I stand by this criticism. It is a basic principle to good journalism.

The reason I reacted to this story was because I think Sports is the last place for this kind of blurring. When you blur the boundaries between opinion and news you also get unwanted side effects such as an accusation of bias, so no one at GLP should be surprised by that.

This blurring already occurs at GLP in the more important arena of Politics, and it is one reason I come to this site less frequent. Frankly when I do come I’m interested in the Food & Wine articles which are outstanding and my compliments to GLP for that. But sadly, in an environment where some people crave balanced views, GLP could be so much better.

Harold Stassen

@ Charles D.
A friendly suggestion; step down from your high horse regarding the tenor and content of this sports column. Scott's article's are no different than those of Bill Reynolds or other ProJo writers. He offers comments and observations regarding a variety of local and national sports news. That's what I expect when reading his column.
With respect to the Hurley piece, the reaction by some posters was beyond over the top and without merit, for a story that as you write was, "very plausible."

Charles D.

Mr. Stassen, the fact that you think I'm on some high horse may just indicate the low regard you have about quality of journalism and most likely, the importance of quality in other areas. I hope I am wrong on these points. This is an unfortunate characteristic of some Rhode Islanders who are deeply negative about many things and have a collective inferiority complex based on the inherent belief that nothing great can be created in a small state.

My friendly advice to you, Mr. Stassen, is to man up. Be proud of Rhode Island, believe in the many qualities RI has, believe that this state can become a quality corner of this country, never accept mediocrity and the belief that Rhode Island cannot do better. Demand excellence in all things.

Harold Stassen

@ Charles D.
The fact that you don't realize you're on a high horse speaks for itself. Question: what does expressing my support for a sports column have to do with believing in RI's many qualities? Answer: Zero.
You may be well intentioned but you're off base in this matter.

Charles D.

Two points in response, Mr. Stassen:

1. Psychology tells us that people making accusations like your "high horse" comment, do so as reflection of their own internal feelings about self worth and not the words of the other person. Besides the comment was totally off the subject.

2. The expectations you expressed for sports columns sounded negative with no aspirations for a higher level of journalism. You appear to accept mediocrity, so I thought I’d give you a pep talk on RI.

joe adamowicz

"Rutgers coach Mike Rice is believed to be on thin ice and could very well be fired by the school this off season. Dan Hurley, a former Rutgers assistant and New Jersey native, is a well respected coach in his home state of New Jersey for his work as both a high school and college coach. And a program that will soon be transitioning from the Big East to the Big Ten could surely offer a financial package to its head coach far more attractive than what the University of Rhode Island can.

For all of those reasons, I did not think that it was unreasonable to suggest the possibility of a scenario whereby Hurley could be offered and accept such a job."
Scott, well said, and who can disagree with this (except that one hyper-oversensitive poster who blindly follows URI). I am a Rhode Island fan, all teams, but am realistic. It's not like URI is a well-known basketball school or belongs to an elite conference, especially after this year when the A-10 is going to be plucked butt-naked clean when Xavier, Butler, and other top teams that belong to it (I don't put URI in this category)leave. So why all the bluster? Opportunity knocks, Danny, go better your position in life. Really, what is the big deal?

Charles D.

Please, Mr Adamowicz, spare us your protest that you are a Rhode Island fan. You don't even have the common courtesy to read what the dissent is about or else you wouldn't ask what is the bluster about. And learn what the difference is between the editorial page and the news page is all about. Then come back and comment.


And if anyone is blind, it's not the URI fan. You should have higher standards.

Wally M

Natural reaction Scott, you were the first to suggest the possibility of Dan Hurley moving back to his home state with word of Mike Rice's eventual demise, so you got the heat my man and I know you can handle it. For me, I just hate to hear it because I like many others in RI want to see URI basketball succeed, and I'm a PC fan. I think we all have "great expectations" for next and don't want anyone bursting our bubble. We deserve to dream a little. Anyway, you do a great job and stirring a little controversy is a good thing. Can't wait to kick your azz on the course though!!!!!

wally

Scott Cordischi

Wally: Well said! Except for the golf part! lol!

Scott Cordischi

Charles:

I hope that you check this link out. http://www.nydailynews.com/sports

New York Daily News columnist Gary Myers (who is a very well respected journalist) wrote a column today. As you will see, on the link, the headline is: "Darrelle Revis To The Patriots? It Could Happen Says Our Gary Myers."

So I ask you, what is the difference between that column and mine? They are both stories about future scenarios that could happen based on both logic and speculation. Is that wrong?

Again, my contention is that there is nothing wrong with this.

Your thoughts?

Rod Carri

A long time ago, I learned from my parents, that two wrongs don't make a right.
Trying to justify yourself with someone elses' try for readership, doesn't excuse you.
Me thinks ye doeth protest too much.

Scott Cordischi

Rod:

I don't think that Myers or I am wrong. And your last line "ye doeth protest too much" applies to you in this situation, not me my friend.

Charles D.

Mr. Cordischi, thanks for the shot.
Why this situation is very different than your Hurley speculation...

1. The NFL and Patriots season is over. Hurley’s is not.
2. Darrelle Revis is a free agent next year and will be up for grabs. Free agency is all about speculation. Hurley is in the first year of a long-term contract.
3. Darrelle Revis, however an important cornerback, is one player among many players. Dan Hurley is THE coach of a 14 man squad, many of whom made the trek to Kingston just to play for him. Coaches are more critically important to the success of a team than one player.
4. Gary Meyers offers up one stage of speculation. Your Hurley story had four stages of speculation: 1) Mike Rice will get fired. 2) Hurley is on the long list. 3) Hurley makes the short list. 4) Hurley is offered and accepts the Rutgers job.
5. Meyers is a columnist for a tabloid newspaper. You, Mr. Cordischi, are the Sports Editor of a fairly new site trying to make a mark in its community.
6. RI is a small market where everyone knows everyone and even small incidents can be easily fanned out of proportion. New York is, well, the Big Apple.

Scott Cordischi

Charles:

I appreciate your passion and input but respectfully disagree with you. We will obviously not see eye to eye on this one.




Write your comment...

You must be logged in to post comments.