Rob Horowitz: Tough Fight Coming On Immigration Reform
Tuesday, July 16, 2013
Of course, it was too much to expect that President Bush’s words would sway the strong opposition of a good number of the members of his own party in the House to the legislation that has passed the Senate, many of whom are vociferously opposed to any path to citizenship for the 11 million or so undocumented immigrants already living in the country. That became immediately clear at a meeting of the House Republican Caucus dedicated to immigration which took place soon after Bush’s speech. As anti-immigration reform leader Representative Steve King (R-IA) said the next morning on CBS in referring to undocumented immigrants,. “They came here to live in the shadows. They had to expect they were going to live in the shadows."
Along with the hard line opponents in the House, however, there are also many Republican members who would like to see immigration reform proceed and grasp the political risks of being blamed for its failure. Fortunately, these proponents include Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) and the rest of the House Republican leadership team. While Speaker Boehner dashed the fond wishes of immigration reform advocates by ruling out simply bringing the recently adopted Senate bill up for a vote, he also indicated he understood the need for action on immigration reform. “We’ve got a broken system, it needs to be fixed, and I made a strong case yesterday that it needs to be fixed and the Republicans ought to be part of the solution,” Boehner said. “It’s always in the party’s best interest when we’re doing the right thing for the country.” The Speaker even held out hope that a path to citizenship would be considered saying, “we’re going to find out” if the House can back some sort of a citizenship or legalization proposal.
The recently adopted Senate bill aims to fix our broken immigration system by paving the way for the 11 million or so undocumented immigrants already here to emerge from the shadows and fully participate in American life, opening up our doors more widely through expanded legal immigration targeted to attract the world’s best and brightest, and stepping up enforcement to prevent future illegal immigration. More specifically, it creates a tough, but achievable path to citizenship. It offers sensible interim steps, permitting undocumented immigrants already here in the nation to immediately emerge from the shadows. It also expands the number of visas available for highly skilled workers while providing them with a smoother path to permanent residency, steps up enforcement, and tightens border security.
As best we can tell, it appears that the Senate bill’s component parts will be broken up and considered separately as well as modified in the House. The result is likely a tough and lengthy battle —a fight made much more difficult by the fact that Speaker Boehner has indicated that he will adopt the Hastert rule in this instance and only move to the floor for a vote measures that have the support of a majority of Republicans.
It will be up to the advocates of immigration reform, which include many national Republicans and the Chamber of Commerce, to engage in an aggressive district by district campaign to move Republican House members on the fence into the pro-immigration reform column. Republican sponsors of the Senate Bill, such as Marco Rubio (R-FL) and John McCain (R-AZ) must keep up their strong national advocacy. Comprehensive immigration reform is with-in our grasp, but there is much hard work ahead.
Rob Horowitz is a strategic and communications consultant who provides general consulting, public relations, direct mail services and polling for national and state issue organizations, various non-profits and elected officials and candidates. He is an Adjunct Professor of Political Science at the University of Rhode Island.
- Rob Horowitz: How The Boston Marathon Tragedy Brings Us Together
- Rob Horowitz: Obama Proposes Common Sense Gun Policies
- Rob Horowitz: Signs of Life for Grand Bargain
- Rob Horowitz: Imagine Democracy, Powered Digitally
- Rob Horowitz: Obama Puts Retiree Entitlement Programs on the Table
- Rob Horowitz: Supreme Court Fuels National Push for Gay Marriage
- Rob Horowitz: Immigration Reform Moves Forward
- Rob Horowitz: Obama Steps Up on Climate Change
- Rob Horowitz: The Ties That Bind Help Us Weather the Storm
- Rob Horowitz: Immigration Reform Moves to the Front Burner
- Rob Horowitz: President Hillary Clinton? Not So Fast
- Rob Horowitz: The Ultimate City: Bohemians, Gays & Jobs
- Rob Horowitz: Important Climate Change Milestone Exceeded
- Rob Horowitz: Progress on Comprehensive Immigration Reform
- Rob Horowitz: Universal Background Checks Gain Traction
- Rob Horowitz: Bob Woodward Goes Off the Rails
- Rob Horowitz: Let’s Get Serious About Prescription Drug Abuse
- Rob Horowitz: RI’s Congressional Delegation—Afraid of the Elderly
- Rob Horowitz: WA Bridge Collapse A Wake-Up Call For Rhode Island
- Rob Horowitz: Climate Change Adaptation Moves on to the Public Agenda
- Rob Horowitz: Let’s Celebrate RI’s Adoption of Marriage Equality
- Rob Horowitz: Republican Orthodoxy on Marriage Equality Cracking
- Rob Horowitz: Congress Should Keep A Lid On Student Debt
- Rob Horowitz: New Media Trends Accelerate
- Rob Horowitz: Rutgers President Ducks Responsibility On Rice