Moore: RI is Too Poor To Bid For Pawsox
Monday, October 19, 2015
In the end, all the talk about the sentimental value of Pawtucket Red Sox is just white noise, as meaninglessness as Lincoln Chafee's Presidential bid.
That's because from a rational perspective, state leaders really don't have a choice but to play hard ball (pun intended) with the Pawtucket Red Sox owners. The state of Rhode Island can't afford to waste money on a minor league baseball team—and the taxpayers are well aware of the fact. That's something the Pawtucket Red Sox owners apparently never considered when they began their plot to get their hands on Rhode Island taxpayer money.
News reports surfaced last week that the owners of the Pawtucket Red Sox have had early conversations with the city of Springfield, in western Massachusetts about a potential move, and have also rekindled talks with Fall River about a possible relocation there. Whether or not the city leaders intend to throw tens of millions of taxpayer cash directly into the pockets of the already wealthy Pawtucket Red Sox owners is their decision.
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLASTSpringfield may very well have the extra revenue in its hand thanks to the construction of an $800 million casino that's currently in the works. If that's the case, God bless. Hopefully western Massachusetts residents will enjoy their 8 dollars beers.
No Money
But here's the sad truth about Rhode Island: we cannot afford to get into a bidding war with an out-of-state municipality to spend several tens of millions to build a new minor league stadium.
Let's face it: the Pawtucket Red Sox have made it clear, without saying it explicitly, that they intend to be a revenue negative proposition for whomever they happen to grace next with their presence. We don't have to like that the owners of the team aren't anywhere near as civic-minded as the Mondor family was, as evidenced by not only their ungodly financial demands from the state, but also their increases in concession prices since they've been in charge.
It's frustrating. But that's how these guys are.
So when we get down to brass tacks, it becomes apparent rather quickly that a minor league baseball team that wants huge subsidies is something that's cool to have, but that we cannot afford.
Cool, But Unaffordable
First of all, the state is considering implementing a massive new toll system on trucks (at first, but a betting man would say that eventually, Rhode Island drivers will be paying them), as well as borrowing hundreds of millions more, in order to fix out deficient bridges.
We can all argue about the best way to fix our bridges. I happen to agree with the Republican Policy group, led by the heroic efforts of Patricia Morgan (R-Coventry, West Warwick), that would cut spending in the state budget to fix them. But no one that I know of is believes that our bridges, not to mention our roads (and another winter is right around the corner) need to be fixed.
And we cannot make the case that we need to toll truckers to fix our bridges if we can afford to shell out tens of millions to the owners of the Pawtucket Red Sox.
Tolls, Taxes, and Debt
Meanwhile, the capital city of Providence is locked into a heated court battle with the city's firefighters union over a shift realignment that Mayor Jorge Elorza believes will save about $5 million a year in call back reductions. Naturally, the firefighters contest this figure.
But how can the state of Rhode Island give the wealthy owners of the Pawtucket Red Sox a huge subsidy when the capital city is locked is dealing with labor unrest over an estimated savings of $5 million a year?
The state needs to take a lesson from former Massachusetts House Speaker (and fellow Golocal Mindsetter) Tom Finneran.
Get Tough
When Bob Kraft bought the New England Patriots, he was looking for a government handout. He threatened to move out-of-state. Kraft considered moving to Providence, and had a deal to move to Hartford, Connecticut. But Finneran held tight and refused to finance the stadium with taxpayer dollars. He called Kraft's bluff.
Kraft folded. The rest is history. Kraft built the stadium with his own funds. (And surprise! The stadium was built ahead of schedule and under budget.)
The state would do well to emulate Finneran. Hold firm, and call the bluff of the Pawtucket Red Sox owners. If they leave, we should wish them well, congratulate them for fleecing taxpayers somewhere else. (Better those taxpayers than us, for a change.)
And then we should find some other ball club to play affordable baseball in McCoy stadium.
The world will go on. And we'll have that much extra money to fund the things government is actually supposed to do.
Russell Moore has worked on both sides of the desk in RI media, both for newspapers and political campaigns. Send him email at [email protected]. Follow him on twitter @russmoore713
Related Slideshow: PawSox Stadium Aftermath: Winners and Losers
The Providence baseball stadium looked like a sure thing. Powerful owners pushing the project. Top politicians coupled with influential lobbyists and PR consultants all on board. Then, everything changed.
Related Articles
- Russ Moore: Raimondo vs. Taveras = Clinton vs. Obama in RI
- Russ Moore: Who Wins + Who Pays In RI’s $20M Blue Cross Settlement
- Russ Moore: Ignore the Rating Agency’s 38 Studios Extortion
- Russ Moore: Chafee, Licht—Poster Boys for Old School Politics
- Russ Moore: Journal Bought by Notorious Cost-Cutter
- Russ Moore: Can Raimondo Out-Spin The Unions?
- Russ Moore: Langevin’s Mature Approach To Domestic Surveillance
- Russ Moore: Sorry Raimondo, Summits Won’t Fix Our Economy
- Russ Moore: Providence Should Enact Electoral College
- Russ Moore: Raimondo’s First Test, Keep The Pawsox in RI
- Russ Moore: Will Fundraising Conflict with Raimondo’s Ethics Rhetoric?
- Russ Moore: 5 Ideas To Improve The Economy
- Russ Moore: RhodeMap RI, Full of Fury, But Insignificant
- Russ Moore: 5 Things To Hate About Raimondo’s Budget
- A Timeline of the PawSox Stadium Controversy
- Guest MINDSETTER™ David Norton: PawSox Owners Trying to Buy Support
- Sec of State Sends PawSox CEO Congrats Letter and Opponents Warning Letter
- PawSox Stadium Opponents Claim Political Intimidation from State
- PawSox Stadium Opponent “Intimidated” by Cranston Police After Calling Fung
- GoLocalTV: PawSox Stadium Opponents Rally at RI State House
- PawSox Stadium Opponents to Up Pressure at State House this Week
- What’s Next for the PawSox?
- Pawtucket Fights to Keep PawSox: Mayor Grebien’s Letter to Larry Lucchino
- NEW: Bill to Require Voter Approval for PawSox Stadium in House Finance
- Providence Residents Increasing Opposition to PawSox Stadium
- Tens of Thousands Sign Petitions Against PawSox Providence Stadium Deal
- ANALYSIS: Boston’s Olympics Bid is Dead, Will PawSox Providence Stadium Be Next?
- 12 Reasons Why the PawSox Move to Providence is in Peril
- PawSox Providence Stadium is Dead Says Speaker Mattiello
- PawSox Stadium Winners and Losers: The 2nd Bloodless Revolution
- NEW: PawSox Stadium Opponents Declare Success, Rally Planned for Thursday
- Guest MINDSETTER ™ Art Norwalk: Should We Swing at the PawSox Owners’ Next Pitch?
- Guest MINDSETTER ™ Berwick: The Best Deal for RI Taxpayers is to Keep PawSox in Pawtucket
- PawSox Owners Not Registered to Lobby in Providence
- Ethics Leaders Call for PawSox to be Fined for Failing to Register as Lobbyists
- Guest MINDSETTER ™ John Loughlin: PawSox Listening Tour? Listen to This!
- PawSox to Host Miss RI Night on August 24