| | Advanced Search

 

TONIGHT: Fund for Community Progress Honors GoLocalProv + ACLU—Recognizing outstanding contributions to the RI community

Deadline for newportFILM’s Ripple Effect Video Contest is Friday—Drawing attention to RI's coastline + waterways

Patriots’ 2014 Schedule Released—Patriots' 2014 Schedule Released

John Perilli: Battle Heats Up to Succeed Fox in House District 4—Keep an eye on this one...

Newport Goes Daffy with Weeklong Daffodil Celebration—Over 250,000 blooming daffodils on display

B’s Dominate Wings, Take Game 3—shut out Detroit 3-0 to take 2-1 series…

Organize + Energize: 4 Ways Getting Organized Will Save You Money—Stop wasting time and money

Dear John: Single Dad - How Do I Handle Daughter’s Adolescence?—How to support your daughter through puberty

State Report: Marijuana Tax + Bill Targets Prostitutes and Pimps—Plus increased sentences for gang crimes

John Rooke - Thinking Out Loud—JR's column on the sports stories and personalities…

 
 

Donna Perry: Gambling on a Jobs Strategy

Thursday, October 11, 2012

 

Less than four weeks from now, Americans will have decided who will be President and Rhode Islanders will have decided who will represent them in Washington, at the General Assembly, on local councils and school committees, and whether they want to see full-fledged casinos in Newport and at Twin River in Lincoln.

This election season has been a wild ride with high decibel debates ranging from who is truly responsible for the nation’s mind numbing debt to who should be responsible for purchasing a woman’s birth control pills. But perhaps no issue has galvanized the debate and the finger pointing more than the issue over jobs, and more specifically the lack of them. In the days following last week’s game changing debate between Mitt Romney and President Obama, the federal Labor Department’s release of improved employment numbers started its own new debate over whether the numbers were real or perhaps getting a little “cooked” by the now nervous Administration.

But whether they have “helped” the numbers will ultimately end up beside the point. The drop of a few tenths of a percent in a federal data analysis may look good on charts and in national headlines but it doesn’t really matter to the long term unemployed like the roughly 60-thousand Rhode Islanders who remain out of work.

That’s why the incumbents in the state’s Washington delegation have been more than happy to latch onto a litany of other issues all season to change the conversation from the jobs front. Congressman James Langevin has grown increasingly defensive as energetic challenger Michael Riley has unapologetically questioned whether the well liked Langevin remains an effective voice in Washington as the state’s fiscal condition worsens. Brendan Doherty calls out Ciccilline for preferring to scare seniors rather than own up to Providence lies or talk jobs, and Barry Hinckley points out that lifelong public official Sheldon Whitehouse seems unfamiliar—and uninterested-- in private sector job creation.

Regardless of where you stand, Rhode Islanders owe it to themselves to look long and hard at how –or even if-- their own Washington delegation really grasps the true condition of their home state. Rhode Island is beyond a jobs problem; it has an employment crisis and has been characterized by economic analysts as being caught in what could amount to a “lost decade” of protracted job loss and business sector decline.

So against this bleak backdrop, it’s all the more curious to see that the only job sector growth being predicted this campaign season has little to do with promising new day jobs and has everything to do with a certain type of nightlife. If you believe that grooming younger or not so young unemployed Rhode Islanders for service jobs as waitresses, hostesses, bartenders, or “gaming dealers”, then I guess you could say job opportunities are emerging. The central promise of new jobs is coming not from business growth in a cutting edge industry or the arrival of a vibrant large company into our state, but from a campaign spokesman for glitzed up gambling halls.

The most visible figure on the scene this fall talking jobs is the unelected Twin River Chairman John Taylor, who is pushing the ballot referendums to bring table games and full casino status to Newport Grand and Twin River. Despite evidence around the region and the country that long established casinos have been experiencing serious revenue decline (Foxwoods) and Massachusetts has several casinos going on line that are likely to keep the Bay State visitors to our establishments gambling elsewhere in the near future, Rhode Island seems to have settled on a casino jobs strategy.

In fairness, this fall has also seen notable events (RI Foundation’s MakeItHappen 2-day seminar) to draw attention, focus, and new energy toward examining job sectors, workforce training, and rethinking the state’s promotional approaches. Proposals have also been forwarded for a complete makeover of the state’s economic development apparatus. But the gambling expansion forces, cleverly branding the casino referendums as a “Jobs RI” campaign, have dominated the jobs message and they’ve certainly done their job well, as recent polls show the ballot initiatives are likely to pass. It’s true that the state’s third largest source of revenue brings in close to $300 million to the state and Twin River alone is currently tied to 900 jobs with another 350 expected to come on line with the expansion to a full casino.

Even without dissecting the merits of what those jobs or “careers” really are, there are other troubling realities that should be noted. First off, the revenue produced by these establishments was tied to a profit sharing arrangement with the state that was far more generous than what the Legislature approved for going forward. Secondly, as casino revenues drop, as they have everywhere, the state could find the only true winner will be parent company UTGR, Inc. and the guaranteed take it will extract from the casinos in the years to come even as the state’s take continues shrinking.

The truth is having casino industry jobs serve as a central employment strategy is an approach that may not only quickly run out of luck, experience elsewhere shows it may already be running out of time.

Donna Perry is Executive Director of RISC, RI Statewide Coalition
 

 

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

Comments:

J. Ferreira

Scott McKay at WRNI (RI Public Radio) has nailed this issue on the head repeatedly. As long as the true path to fiscal and business improvement, a well-educated work-force, is starved of financial support by consistently cutting funding to the state college, university and community college, then we will remain the Louisiana of New England.

The vast majority of citizens of this state are so wedded to the long-absent image of middle class attainment through factory work that they STILL insist that their kids will get good jobs as soon as the factories re-open. Until then, Uncle Guido can get them a decent position working on a road crew for the Department of Transportation.

Our political leaders, even those who are visionary and progressive thinking, are hamstrung by voters who never understood the true value of education, even at the K-12 level, and who continue to pass that ignorance onto their kids. Face it, when it comes to progressive politics, we aren't the Louisiana of New England. We're the Central Falls of the Northeast....

Captain Blacksocks

Other than Twin Rivers proposal, I haven't seen any candidates put foward a Job Plan that convinces me they spent more than 20 minutes thinking about the issue. Maybe they are all just giving up, understanding that no intelligent business is going to choose to move into RI as long as the state ranks dead last in nearly all categories that would matter most to a growing business. The problem isnt gambling, or that manufacturing jobs have gone overseas. The problem is that RI does not have a business climate that's built to attract businesses likely to bring a high number of good paying jobs to RI. Vote for change!

Art West

J. and Captain -- two good comments.

Education must be geared to teach relevant job skills, and the government has to create the conditions for business to thrive. In the latter case, government has to get out of the way more than anything else.




Write your comment...

You must be logged in to post comments.