Brown Poll Becomes Political Football Among Candidates
Saturday, August 07, 2010
The poll showed Providence Mayor David Cicilline leading the Democratic primary for the Congressional First District with 32 percent support. Gubernatorial candidates Frank Caprio and Lincoln Chafee were nearly dead even, with the General Treasurer holding a razor-thin lead with 27.9 percent and the former U.S. Senator close on his heels with 26.5 percent.
Large Numbers of Voters Undecided
One the most notable results of the poll was not where candidates came out—but the sheer number of undecided voters in several of the races. In the race for governor and the First District a little over 30 percent of voters said they had not made up their minds. In the Democratic primary for Attorney General, 60 percent were undecided.
“That is why a plurality of voters are undecided in the two most competitive races—for governor and the Democratic nomination for the First Congressional District,” Starr said. “Until late August, the hardest choice should be, 'Should I go to the beach or go sailing? And, once everyone gets the sand out of their toes, the campaigns will ratchet up their advertising and there will be movement in the polls.”
The gubernatorial campaigns for Moderate Party candidate Ken Block and Republicans John Robitaille and Victor Moffitt were more focused on the 30 percent of voters who were undecided than the single-digit support they garnered in the polls.
“This poll should be an embarrassment for both the Caprio and Chafee campaigns. They are well known career politicians and cannot capture enough votes to win in November,” Robitaille said. He said the undecided voters would gravitate toward him as soon as they learned more about his positions on lower taxes, cutting spending, and standing up to unions.
The campaign for Chafee, on the other hand, took the poll as good news, even though he was slightly behind Caprio. Campaign manager J.R. Pagliarini pointed out that the poll was taken during President Clinton’s visit to Rhode Island on behalf of Caprio—and after Patrick Lynch dropped out of the Democratic primary.
“We’re very pleased with the results,” Pagliarini said. “We don’t see the progress on the Treasurer’s front, so we’re very encouraged by it.”
But Caprio spokesman Nick Hemond said the Treasurer would rise in the polls as voters learned more about the differences between the two candidates. “Many voters remain undecided, and as they learn more about Senator Chafee’s plan to raise taxes and Frank’s plan to cut wasteful spending and get government out of the way and out of the pocket of small businesses, we are confident in earning their support,” Hemond said.
Democratic candidate for Attorney General Joe Fernandez garnered only 7 percent in the poll—behind Steve Archambault, with 11.4 percent, and apparent frontrunner Peter Kilmartin, with 21.3 percent.
But he sensed opportunity in the 60.3 percent of voters who hadn’t made up their minds.
“If this poll tells us anything with regard to the Attorney General’s race it’s that the race is wide open given that 60 percent of those responding are undecided,” said Fernandez campaign manager Dan Herkert. “The other candidates in this race are entrenched politicians, and neither has been able to move into a commanding position. All of this is good news for a candidate like Joe Fernandez who’s never run for office but who has the resources necessary to communicate his message to voters.”
A spokesman for Archambault also thought the campaign was in a good position. “We are within striking range of Peter Kilmartin,” said Rob Horowitz, noting that he was receiving about one percentage point of support for about every year he had been in public office. “With six out of ten primary voters undecided and advertising yet to begin we are right where we want to be.”
Kilmartin spokesman Brett Broesder said the poll was further proof that his message of cracking down on violent crime, mortgage fraud, and public corruption was resonating with voters. He declined to comment on criticism of the poll, saying Kilmartin could better use his time meeting with voters. “We’ll let our opponents spend time complaining about their lackluster showing in this poll,” Broesder said.
Several candidates also ripped into Brown for failing to properly measure voter opinion. All three of the Congressional candidates behind Cicilline in the poll said its sample size of 174 voters was too small and its 7.4 percent margin of error was too big.
“I am disappointed in Brown for releasing the sample size,” said Bill Fischer, a spokesman for Bill Lynch, who had 15 percent of voters supporting him. “There is not a campaign in Rhode Island or the country that would rely on a sample size that small.”
"We knew something was suspect immediately because the numbers are significantly at odds with our own internal tracking polling,” added Rachel Miller, the campaign manager for David Segal. “But we were shocked when it took only an elementary glance at the numbers to see the methodological flaws.”
Anthony Gemma also blasted the poll yesterday, saying it was “statistically invalid and politically meaningless.”
Starr said it was ultimately up to readers to determine how valid the poll results were, since Brown had been up front in its press release about the margin of error in the two Congressional races. “The determination as to whether the results are credible depends on how the reader wants to use the information,” Starr said. “From my perspective, the results provide me a picture with broad strokes, which is that Cicilline has a lead but there are a lot of undecided voters with more than a month left in the campaign.”
Frontrunner David Cicilline was alone among the Congressional candidates in praising the poll results. “While we’re pleased that today’s Brown University poll shows that David's message is resonating across the First Congressional District, this campaign is about listening to voters and their concerns,” said campaign manager Eric Hyers.
Marion Orr, the director of Brown’s Taubman Center for Public Policy, which did the poll, told GoLocalProv yesterday that the university stood by the results of the poll. He declined to respond to the specific criticisms of the candidates.
Besides the margin of error and small sample size, the Block and Robitaille campaigns took issue with the fact that the poll included both Republican candidates when they asked voters who they would support for governor. They suggested that that painted an unrealistic picture of the election, since only one Republican candidate would be in it after the primary.
“It would have been preferable to have two ballots test in the gubernatorial race to test the statewide preference for each Republican candidate,” Starr said. “However, having both Republican candidates in the horserace question should not change the key information, which is that a plurality of voters are undecided and it is a competitive race.”
- Breaking News: Chafee Ahead of Caprio in Latest Poll
- Campaign 2010 – Summer Starts with a Dead Heat
- Rasmussen: Chafee and Caprio in a dead-heat
- BREAKING: Brown Poll Shakes Up Political Race