Welcome! Login | Register

Subscribe Now: Free Daily EBlast


What Projo Desperately Needs in Sale: Local Buyer, Low Price

Thursday, May 08, 2014


I was talking to a newspaper executive the other day about the mergers-and acquisition-scene in his business, and as the conversation unfolded, it became evident that the Providence Journal, even in its diminished state, should find a credible buyer.

Here is a paper that is still generating $90 million or so annually in revenue. It has been cut to the bone, so expenses are in line. It still is the largest news organization in the market, despite everything. And one analyst estimates that it is at least “modestly profitable.”

The fact is, modestly profitable, while nothing like the glory days of newspapers, is pretty good. Here is an eye-opening graphic from Pew Research:


Not bad

Sure, it’s not 25 percent or 30 percent, which these days is Google territory, but mid-teens beats a sharp stick in the eye. Compare that to your passbook savings account, Bunky.

To do some back-of-the-envelope math, if the Projo is making 15 percent on its $90 million in revenue (and it’s probably not), that’s $13 million. Let’s say it’s half that, which is more in line with the rest of Belo. Warren Buffett paid four times operating profit (technically, EBITDA ) for his fairly recent string of newspaper acquisitions, so we’re looking at a price of $25 million to $50 million.

Let’s all hope it’s on the low end. Why?

First of all, proceeds of the sale go A.H. Belo, the Projo’s Dallas-based parent, its shareholders, and management, and really, who cares about them?

Management is already loaded, having sprinkled its executives with unhealthy bonuses, while presiding over a decline that is truly shocking, even by today’s mind-blowing standards.

Only one thing matters

And all Rhode Islanders should care about is a healthy news ecosystem, period.

Indeed, it is difficult to find a franchise that was once so dominant—one of the highest market penetrations in the country, in fact – and that has underperformed the national averages by such a wide margin. Here’s that circulation graphic again, updated. And look what’s happened the last couple of years.


That is correct. Newspapers have stabilized, and the Projo continues to decline in the high single digits! Pardon the exclamation point, but, come on!

And the bad news just keeps on coming. Just this last quarter, we learn that circulation of the Sunday paper– also known as a main cash generator – is now under 100,000.

Look, I understand the Rhode Island economy is tough. Its unemployment rate is, yes, the worst in the nation.
So, okay, that accounts for some of the underperformance. But, still the unemployment rate has been improving (for the most part) in the last three years, and still there’s been no moderation in the Projo’s decline.

Misguided priorities

And there is a reason for this beyond the economy, and here it is:


That’s a decline of 57 percent of unionizied employees in the decade, from 600 to just 258. And when we talk about cutting unionized employees, the point is not that they’re unionized. Those are the headcounts disclosed in the company’s financial statements, but they also happen to represent the editorial and advertising departments of the newspaper, that is to say, the department that produces the product, and the one that sells it – in other words, the heart and soul of the business. And, as you can see in the graph, yes, Belo cut the Projo at a much faster rate than the national average.

No one will seriously argue that Belo, in response to difficult times that were in part only temporary, cut beyond fat into the muscle of the enterprise, seriously undermining the quality of product and materially impairing its value.

The brain drain continued this week with the departure of longtime healthcare reporter, Felice Freyer, who decamped for the Globe, where an air of experimentation and investment is making life interesting.

Squeezing subscribers

And of course, in keeping with an unimaginative strategy, while it was cutting the content, the Projo, all together now, raised prices for the subscribers that chose to remain, the one group you really don’t want to antagonize.

But that’s all bay water over the hurricane barrier.

Belo now has a fiduciary duty to its shareholders get the highest price possible. It has engaged a Little Rock, AR, investment bank, Stephens Inc., to make sure that happens.

Stephens isn’t talking but the process is dragging out. Belo in February said it hoped to have the deal done by April or May. Late last month, Belo said it was “midway” through the process, whatever that means.

But really, at this point, we should be giving Belo a medal for doing everything possible to drive the price down, and it should be low. This will not be a turnkey operation.

Opportunity for someone

The Projo is a fixer-upper. Rebuilding it will require serious capital. For one thing, the size of the newsroom is now too small to support the kind of operation on which a profitable operation can be built for the digital age, when content isn’t the main thing, it’s the only thing. For another, the paper’s digital game needs to be stepped up, big time. In the latest quarter, the paper’s digital revenue ticked up less then 1 percent compared to a year earlier to a still-small $1.27 million. Digital growth is slowing everywhere, but again this is an area of underperformance – and, mostly, opportunity.

And that bring us to a buyer. Right now the Projo needs only a few things:

–Someone local, maybe even an East Sider and a Brown grad.
–Someone extremely rich, preferably a billionaire.
–Someone who is public spirited.
–And finally, someone who is an expert in media, with a proven track record in investing in media properties both digital and otherwise, in the United States and all over the world.

A tall order. There’s no such person, you say?

Oh, but there is:

Jonathan Nelson, #342 on the Forbes 400, with a personal net worth of $1.8 billion, runs Providence Equity Partners, which began in 1989 investing in media and now manages a portfolio of media and other properties worth $40 billion. He works right downtown, in Kennedy Plaza.

I asked his representatives if he’s interested, and will let you know if I hear back.

But why not him?


Related Slideshow: Rhode Island’s Changing Media Landscape

Radio, print, television and digital - the faces in Rhode Islands's media has changed drastically over the past months... Let's take a look at some of the biggest moves:

Prev Next

Bob Kerr

The long time Providence Journal columnist Bob Kerr was sent packing by the new ownership group.

The unceremonious dismissal ended the tenure of the Projo's only true news columnist. 

Kerr was talented and often controversial. 

Prev Next

Howard Sutton

The long-time publisher was Belo's man in Providence. Howard Sutton was the man that implemented the changes that Dallas wanted to try and make the company more efficient and more profitable.

The results were dismal. Maybe no newspaper in the country lost a higher precentage of ad revenue than the Projo over the past decade.

He was the face of the paper in the community. 

Prev Next

Andrew Gobiel

Andrew Gobeil has been named campaign manager for Republican candidate for Attorney General Dawson Hodgson.
Gobeil began his media career covering politics as a teenager for a Cape Cod radio station. He has served as one of the youngest NPR affiliate news directors in the country, Washington editor and national correspondent for a television station group, and managing editor and host of a statewide public affairs program.  
Gobeil was the morning co-anchor at Providence’s ABC-TV affiliate and co-host of a morning news program on WPRO radio.  He is currently working on a non-fiction book about the journalism business. 
Prev Next

Rick Daniels

Rick Daniels has joined GoLocal24 as Chief Operating Officer.

Daniels is the former President of the Boston Globe. He also served as CEO of Gatehouse Media for New England and led a consortium of investors who attempted to purchase the Boston Globe from the New York Times Company in 2013.

Daniels then went on to play a key role at Empirical Media Advisors based in New York, focused mainly on Tribune Publishing, where Emprical’s co-founder and CEO, Jack Griffin, recently took the role of CEO.

Prev Next

Fred Campagna

Fred Campagna has joined FOX25 in Boston.

Before Campagna began working at FOX25, he served as the Chief On-Air Meteorologist at ABC6 for fourteen years.

After leaving ABC6 in July 2012, Campagna launched his own digital weather platform, Right Weather.


Prev Next

Karen Meyers

WLNE-TV has fired anchor Karen Meyers. She had been with the station since 2011.

Meyers had anchored the 6 p.m. and 11 p.m. news with John DeLuca. Sources say station management opted not to renew her contract and decided to go in another direction.

Before Meyers joined ABC6, she was a reporter/anchor with New England Cable News and was a reporter in Washington, DC.

Prev Next

Felice Freyer

According to RIPR reporter Ian Donnis, Providence Journal's Health Reporter is leaving.  Felice Freyer has been the sole reporter covering Rhode Island's largest businss sector.

Freyer leaves for the Boston Globe.

Her departure follows Phil Marcelo who recently left the Projo for AP in Boston.

Editor's note: An earlier version incorrectly had RIPR reporter Scott MacKay as breaking the story.

Prev Next

Flo Jonic

Veteran radio reporter Flo Jonic recently was fired by RINPR after she filed complaints against the station  for gender-based pay discrimination.

Jonic is a 30 year veteran of New England news radio.

In her charge filed in February, Jonic wrote, "I believe that I have been discriminated against based on my sex by my employer," and referred to the difference in her pay and that of RIPR reporter Ian Donnis.

"Currently, [reporter] Ian Donnis earns at least $75,000 a year, while I make $51,000 per year. We perform the same duties, and I have 32 more years experience than he does," wrote Jonic in her complaint.

Prev Next

Phil Marcelo

After a seven year stint reporting for the Providence Journal's state house bureau, Phil Marcelo left the paper to take a reporting gig with the Boston office of the Associated Press.

Hailing from Long Island, New York, Marcelo came to ProJo in 2006, and covered everything from regional news, to Providence City Hall and the Statehouse. Marcelo's departure was first reported by WRNI's Ian Donnis.

Prev Next

Julie Tremmel

Formerly a nightly news reporter for WJAR, Tremmel was fired from the "Team You Trust" after two clips, one of her performing on-air handstands, and the other offering tips on what to do during a bear attack, went viral.

The video became an internet sensation, but long-time Channel 10 newsman Jim Taricani called Tremmel’s antics “a smudge on our station's reputation.”

Prev Next

Jim Taricani

A long-time staple of Channel 10’s news team, Taricani announced plans to retire after over three decades with the station. 

Taricani has won 5 regional Emmy awards, an Edward R. Murrow award for investigative journalism and a Prestigious Yankee Quill Award from the New England Newspaper Association.

He was convicted to six months in prison in 2004 for refusing to reveal a source, and is the youngest person ever to be inducted into the Rhode Island Hall of Fame.

Prev Next

John DePetro

WPRO talk show host has come under fire for comments he made on air regarding women. Leading union organizations have called for DePetro to be fired. 

Most recently, he has been on announced suspension.

DePetro apologized for his comments.

Prev Next

Helen Glover

Former star of the reality show Survivor, turned talk radio show host is out. Helen Glover departs and is replaced by radio Veteran Ron St. Pierre, who only months earlier was let go by 630 WPRO. St. Pierre is a radio Hall-of-Famer and former top sports anchor on WPRI-12.
Prev Next

Mike Stanton

Mike Stanton, the remaining reporter from the Providence Journal's once storied investigative team, is leaving Fountain Street for a teaching job at the University of Connecticut.
Stanton, who was part of the team that won the Providence Journal's last Pulitzer and is the author of the "Prince of Providence," the Buddy Cianci expose, departs leaving the Projo without an investigative reporter. 
Prev Next

Dean Starkman

GoLocal named Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative reporter Dean Starkman as a contributor and editor-at-large.
"Dean Starkman has a tremendous track record in financial, media, and investigative reporting. His work at the Wall Street Journal as a reporter and as an editor and writer at Columbia Journalism Review (CJR), coupled with ground-breaking investigations of public corruption for The Providence Journal, is unsurpassed in the region," said Josh Fenton, Co-Founder and CEO at GoLocal24, the parent company to GoLocalWorcester.com.
Prev Next

Karen Bordeleau

Karen Bordeleau takes over for Tom Heslin as Executive Editor for the Providence Journal.
Before joining the newspaper in 1996, she worked at the Kent County Times and the Woonsocket Call. 
She is a graduate of Northeastern University and a Rhode Island native.
Prev Next

Bob Whitcomb

Bob Whitcomb has been the editor of the editorial page of the Providence Journal since 1992 and Vice President since 1997. 
His book, "Cape Wind" unveiled the business and political story behind Jim Gordon's effort to build a wind farm off of Cape Cod.
Prior to being a powerful voice at the Providence Journal, Whitcomb served as Financial Editor at International Herald Tribune.
He is slated to leave later this year according to RI NPR.
Prev Next

Tom Heslin

Managing Editor of the Providence Journal, Tom Heslin, is retiring. 
Heslin who has been a journalistic leader of the Journal since the 1990's, led the paper's team the one their last Pulitzer Prize in the early 1990's and had to implement a series of staff cuts during the past decade.
Widely respected by journalists, Heslin has recently suffered from health issues.
Prev Next

Tara Granahan

The former co-host to the morning drive show is now Buddy Cianci's sidekick and co-host on the 3:00 pm to 6:00 pm drive time show on WPRO AM.
Granahan has had a host of assignments at WPRO and is the only woman on air at WPROAM. 
Prev Next

Connie Grosch

She was the star photographer for the Providence Journal for better than a decade.
Her State House/Political photos made her one of the most influential members of the Providence Journal staff. 
In late 2012, the Providence Journal let her go as part of the latest cost cutting ordered by the home office in Dallas.
In January, she was named press secretary to U.S. Congressman David Cicilline (D-1). She just announced she was leaving the Congressman's staff to return to photography.
Prev Next

Gene Valicenti

The co-host of Channel 10's 6:00 pm news is now doing double as the host for WPRO's 6:00 am to 10:00 am morning show.
Previously, Valicenti lost his 11:00 pm slot on WJAR.
Prev Next

Jennifer Jordan

One of the top Providence Journal reporters is leaving not only Fountain Street, but also journalism. 
She was one of the guild members with the least longevity - more than 10 years.
She leaves for Boston-based Opportunity Nation - a not-for-profit.
Prev Next

Ron St. Pierre

The new guy at WHJJ - he takes over the morning show from the departed Helen Glover.
For decades, Ron St. Pierre has been a key player in the media industry in both local television and radio.
St. Pierre handled sports at WPRI TV, hosted morning drive at WPRO AM, and most recently, was Buddy Cianci's co-host in the afternoon.
(Photo: Alan Levine, Flickr)

Enjoy this post? Share it with others.

Delivered Free Every
Day to Your Inbox