Video Urging RIers to Stop Complaining From RI Foundation Draws Criticism
Tuesday, July 12, 2016
The video, produced by Nail Communications, features kids reading expletive-laden Tweets that are actual quotes from Rhode Islanders, who then tell people to "be nice, or be quiet."
SEE VIDEO BELOW
"Rhode Island Foundation Tells Rhode Islanders to Shut Up and Take Their Medicine," wrote Justin Katz with The Ocean State Current in response, taking issue with the message delivery.
"The message from the people who produced this slick video...is that we're not being nice, that we're being dismissive," wrote Katz. "That we should just shut our traps and not complain about the treatment to which the powerful in our state subject us or when they do things like impose new fees, take away our rights, and slush around money sucked from our economy in a corrupt whirlpool (or when they use non-profit organizations to push political agendas) or blame them when things continue to go wrong, year after year. We’re just “trolling.”
MORE BELOW VIDEO
Mike Stenhouse, the CEO for the Rhode Island Center for Freedom and Prosperity wrote on the issue for the Current as well.
"It is further immoral that the Foundation seeks to subvert the voice of the people in their implied endorsement of the status quo politics in Rhode Island," wrote Stenhouse in his piece, "RI Foundation's Sneak Attack on Free Speech."
"Stop complaining about Rhode Island’s 48th place ranking on the national Family Prosperity Index? Stop complaining that so many of our neighbors cannot find or have given up looking for meaningful work? Stop complaining about the political corruption that continues to embarrass our state? Stop complaining about the lack of bold and decisive action to do anything significant about it?" asked Stenhouse.
About the Spot
Nail Communications produced the minute and six second spot, which the Rhode Island Foundation has featured on its YouTube page and in email communication.
The video begins with kids reading lines from anonymous Tweets, including, "What a [expletive], when I see her face I get annoyed," and "He's such a piece of [expletive] I hope someone cuts his brakes." The expletives are "bleeped" out.
The kids then go on to say, "Stop, just stop. Stop complaining, stop blaming, stop trolling."
“We’re proud of our work funding programs and services that benefit hundreds of thousands of Rhode Islanders. Our Centennial campaign celebrates the thousands of visionary donors and nonprofit partners who make that possible. Rhode Island is better place for their commitment. We’re honored to give them a platform to speak their minds,” said Chris Barnett, spokesman for the Rhode Island Foundation, of the Nail video.
Nail's Alec Beckett addressed he criticisms -- and fired back.
"Third, saying that the message of this video is to repress free speech or public debate is a deliberate and cynical misinterpretation. The intent is the opposite—challenging those who are abusive, bullying, racist, etc. to stop repressing constructive dialogue. Heck, every child who participated understood that," said Beckett. "I will defend to the ends of the Earth your right to express your opinion—whether I agree with you or not. But if your participation in the public discourse involves cruelty, insult and racism, then yes, I guess I would prefer you keep your thoughts to yourself."
Katz responded to the rationale.
"The message of the video is extremely broad, and the only specific behaviors mentioned are 'complaining... blaming... trolling.' The video does not say 'stop being abusive, bullying, and being racist,' said Katz on Monday. "In that regard, this response only further serves the point we're making: that these self-styled righteous elites see no distance between complaining and assigning blame and being cruel and insulting. They only want dialogue if it is 'constructive,' which means affirming the legitimacy of the people who've harmed our state so egregiously."
Taking State Connections to Task
Katz took issue with Nail's ties to the state, including getting a state contract.
"It’s interesting to note, though, the group behind this video, NAIL Communications, because it’s received almost $2.5 million from the state government through HealthSource RI, our ObamaCare health benefits exchange, over the past few years," wrote Katz in his Current piece. "So, yes, shut up and pay your taxes, you nasty Rhode Islanders, so that people who think they’re better than us can get big paydays from government ventures that limit our freedoms as well as redistribute our money."
Stenhouse was critical in turn of the RI Foundations role in public policy.
"The RI Foundation has turned its attention towards public policy, where it has been a supporter of multiple far-left, government-centric and federal intrusions into the affairs of Ocean Staters," wrote Stenhouse. "The Foundation has been a frequent and close public partner with the Chafee and Raimondo administrations. It was a major supporter of the controversial RhodeMap RI agenda and it largely funded the related Brookings Institution report that recommended massive crony-corporate subsidies."
Related Slideshow: 20 Things to be Thankful for in Rhode Island - 2015
newportFILM — The non-profit group is bringing Rhode Island the most innovative and interesting movies each summer. Better yet, the films are framed by the most unique and beautiful venues. Who else can screen an adventure film at an historic fort during the world's biggest ocean race?
James Diossa — The Mayor of Central Falls is a breath of fresh air. While other rookie elected officials are struggling in Rhode Island, Diossa stands out for his commitment and energy to revitalizing Rhode Island’s most devastated community. He just gave his bike to a student who needed one to ride to school.
Gamm Theater — With Trinity Rep and PPAC producing great shows, it is difficult for smaller theaters to compete, but make no mistake about it, the Gamm is producing some of the best productionsin the state. If you haven't checked out this tucked away gem in Pawtucket, put it on your list, and go to a show. You won't be disappointed.
Our U.S. Military and Public Safety Officers — At a time when concerns about terrorism is real and mounting, with recent attacks in Paris, Mali, and Beruit killing hundreds, we are thankful for the work of the United States Armed services around the world and the efforts by domestic law enforcement in the U.S. to deter terrorism on our soil.
Creative Energy - From artists to entrepenuers, the future of Rhode Island will be created and grown by thinkers driving the next generation of small businesses through temendous work and innovation. From RISD to BIF, and designers, creators, and do-ers across all genres, we are thankful to have such a creative community.
- NEW: Rhode Island Foundation Issues Report on Make It Happen RI
- NEW: Rhode Island Foundation Announces New Officers
- NEW: Rhode Island Foundation Gives Record-Setting $29.2 Million in 2010
- Rhode Island Foundation Awards $300k in Emergency Grants
- Rhode Island Foundation Grants Record Amount to Nonprofits in 2010
- Rhode Island Foundation Honors 5 Nonprofits with 2014 Best Practices Awards
- Rhode Island Foundation to Offer $25,000 Grants to Composers
- Rhode Island Foundation Awards $300,000 “Genius Grant” Fellowships
- NEW: RI Foundation Announces Record Giving Year—$30.4 Million
- RI Foundation to Award “Genius” Grants on Wednesday
- RI Foundation to Present Best Practice Awards to Five Nonprofit Organizations
- RI Foundation Awards $17.2 Million in Grants to Help Non-Profit Organizations
- RI Foundation Announces $10 Million Plan to Restore Roger Williams Park
- RI Foundation Offering Over $1.5 Million in Scholarships
- RI Foundation Announces $500,000 in Scholarships
- 13 Nonprofit Execs Receive RI Foundation Fellowships
- NEW: Sen. Jabour Demands Raimondo Return $7,000 Davos Funding to URI Foundation
- Five Prov. Non-Profits Receive Grants From RI Foundation to Mark MLK Day
- Raimondo Will Return $7,000 to URI Foundation for Trip to Davos
- NEW: URI Foundation Names New President
- National Education Publication Scrutinizes Raimondo’s Use of RIC, URI Foundations
- RI Foundation and Local Companies Raise $111K to Streamline State Government
- RI Foundation Sets Dec. 11 Deadline for $300,000 Innovation Grant Applications
- Rhode Island Foundation Awards $34.8 million in Grants in 2014
- NEW: RI Foundation + Commerce RI Release Econ. Development Report
- NEW: RI Foundation Begins Accepting “Genius” Grant Applications
- RI Foundation Begins Accepting Applications for 2015 “Genius” Grants
- RI Foundation Promotes Buy Local RI Campaign
- RI Foundation Names 14 Nonprofit Leaders to Watch
- LIVE STREAM: Center for Freedom and Prosperity Debate
- NEW: RI Center for Freedom & Prosperity Offers Set of ‘Win-Wins’ For RI
- NEW: RI Center for Freedom and Prosperity Releases 2013 Scorecard
- RI Center for Freedom and Prosperity to Challenge Claims at Healthcare Exchange Hearing
- NEW: Center for Freedom and Prosperity Report Card Gives RI Failing Grade
- RI Center for Freedom & Prosperity Blasts Proposed 2017 RI Budget
- NEW: RI Foundation Launches Statewide ‘Backyard’ Campaign
- NEW: RI Foundation Innovation Awards Honor Gagnon, Taylor Tonight
- NEW: $25K Fellowships Available to Writers—RI Foundation
- NEW: RI Foundation Names 2013 Non-Profit Fellows
- NEW: RI Foundation Awards $25K Grants to 3 RI Writers
- PODCAST: Stenhouse Reacts To Obamacare
- NEW: Stenhouse Refutes Roberts’ Claims on 2009 Health Policy Study
- Guest MINDSETTER™ Mike Stenhouse - The Bait and Switch
- Rhode Island Foundation Awarded $15.6 Million in Grants First Half of 2014
- Rhode Island Foundation Awards Providence Composers $25,000 Grants