RI Could Become First State to Legalize Pot Without Voter Approval
Tuesday, March 04, 2014
After attending a meeting of the National Governors Association in Washington, D.C., last week, Chafee discussed the possibility of "pot for potholes" – using marijuana sales revenue for infrastructure improvement – by passing a bill approved by state lawmakers.
At least one local expert thinks it’s a dangerous proposition.
“It would be extremely shortsighted and irresponsible to debate legalizing marijuana simply to raise tax revenue,” said Gary Sasse, former director of the Rhode Island Public Expenditure Council, a former director of the Rhode Island Department of Administration and the state Department of Revenue, and now director of the Bryant Institute for Public Leadership at Bryant University.
“Coloradans legalized pot and their governor noted that going out and getting tax revenue is absolutely the wrong reason to even think about legalizing recreational marijuana. He is correct. Marijuana can put young people at risk. Let's see what happens in Colorado before jumping into the pool.”
Legalization through bill vs. ballot box
Chafee agrees on the timetable. Although Rhode Island lawmakers are now contemplating the possibility of legalizing by bill instead of ballot box, Chafee wants to see how legalization works in Colorado before making a decision.
Last month, a bill that calls for the legalization of marijuana to be regulated and taxed like liquor sales was introduced. The bill was sponsored by Sen. Josh Miller, D-Cranston, chairman of the Senate Health and Human Services Committee, and Edith H. Ajello, D-Providence, chairwoman of the House Judiciary Committee.
“I would like to see a referendum but I did co-sign the legislation,” said District 65 Representative Gregg Amore (D).
“The War on Drugs has been an utter failure by every measure. The idea that marijuana use will significantly increase based on legalization does not ring true with me. I think we have a better opportunity to regulate and control if we legalize. A national legalization would dry up the black market as it did with alcohol.”
Amore is also a teacher at East Providence High School, which adds perspective to his position.
"My students will tell you that they can get pot a lot easier than they can get booze.”
Chafee has said the potential revenue is enticing for all governors. With his seat up for grabs in the upcoming election, the decision could fall into the hands of the next governor.
"It's great to see Governor Chafee expressing openness to legalizing and regulating marijuana,” said Tom Angell, chairman of Marijuana Majority, a pro-legalization group. Angell, a Rhode Island native, graduated from URI in 2004.
“Prohibition does virtually nothing to reduce use, and it causes a number of problems such as allowing violent drug cartels and gangs to make billions of dollars in tax-free profits in the black market. Bringing the marijuana trade aboveground, where it can be taxed, will benefit users and nonusers alike."
Regarding tax revenue from marijuana sales, Angell referred to recent projections from Colorado Governor John Hickenlooper, “which shows that marijuana taxes there are absolutely going to benefit schools and public health programs to the tune of tens of millions of dollars,” Angell said.
Colorado's retail marijuana shops opened in January. Though he opposed marijuana legalization, Hickenlooper released an aggressively optimistic new proposal last week regarding the revenue the legal marijuana industry could bring in for the state. Hickenlooper's budget office expects the recreational and medical marijuana industries will pump nearly $134 million in tax and fee revenue into state coffers in the fiscal year beginning in July. The proposal estimates sales in all marijuana stores to approach $1 billion for that fiscal year. Recreational pot shop sales are estimated to account for more than $600 million of that — a more than 50 percent increase over a previous projection.
Of course, projections aren’t always accurate.
"It is important to note that these amounts are estimates based on a number of assumptions of the new industry," according to the proposal. "We anticipate that these projections will change monthly as more data is collected and actual revenue could fall short of these projections."
The tallies – the first estimates since recreational marijuana sales began in stores Jan. 1 – are significantly higher than previous projections, which expected recreational marijuana stores to do $395 million in sales in the fiscal year beginning in July.
Washington State is right behind Colorado, with retail sales of marijuana slated to start this spring. Financial experts there predict marijuana revenue could bring in $190 million in taxes over a four-year period.
But what of the ethical ramifications of legalizing a substance that is still controversial, despite its growing acceptance in American culture? The comparisons to cigarettes, alcohol and casino gambling revenue are obvious. Could this be called another “sin tax?”
“Legalizing ‘pot for potholes’ is a dead end street. While it's tempting to think that this avenue will make up for lost gambling revenue, the fact is that those who sell pot through the black market will continue to do so with more pure forms,” said former Rhode Island Attorney General Arlene Violet.
“It will soon become a market for the ‘kid stuff’ – which is legalized versus what you get as the ‘real stuff’ with a better high. We are only creating more candidates for stronger "highs".
Legalizing pot for the sake of revenue may be short-sighted and dangerous, according to critics. But most agree that the issue is twofold: How much money will the state bring in versus the potential damage caused by the proliferation of legal drugs.
"Well, it certainly would help make up the gambling revenue decline RI is headed for because of the new betting operations that will be opening in RI, said former Providence Journal political columnist M. Charles Bakst. "Personally, I'm not sure legalizing non-medical marijuana would be a good thing on the merits, though I could be convinced. And if it indeed is a smart thing to do for society, the justice system etc, the revenue would be a nice bonus. But I'm with those who say look at the issue itself first, don't rush into it just to make a buck. It's terrible that RI became so addicted to the revenues from slots, which I believe prey upon people's weaknesses and turns them into robots mindlessly handing over their money."
Dan Kennedy, Assistant Professor in the School of Journalism at Northeastern University, is on the same side.
“Personally, I think casinos are a terrible idea and that legalizing marijuana is a good idea. In general, though, if you're legalizing activities that are harmful to society for the sole purpose of raising tax revenues, you're headed down a dangerous road,” he said.
Related Slideshow: Marijuana Use in the New England States
According to data collected by the Substance Abuse & Mental Health Services Administration, New Englanders are among the nation's top marijuana users in the country. See how the indivdual states compare in the slides below:
- NEW: Brown to Host Debate on Marijuana Legalization on April 23
- PODCAST: The Highest Marijuana Prices in New England by State
- BREAKING: Chafee Gives Thumbs Down On Medical Marijuana
- Guest MINDSETTERS™: A Sensible Marijuana Policy for Rhode Island
- NEW: Legalizing Marijuana Won’t Hurt Kids, Says RI Hospital Study
- RI State Report: Is It High Time to Legalize Marijuana?
- NEW: Marijuana Arrest Rates Racially Disparate Toward Blacks
- PODCAST: Will RI Be The Next State To Legalize Marijuana?
- Marijuana Less Damaging to Lungs Than Tobacco
- In Case You Missed It: Highest Marijuana Prices in New England
- NEW: Medical Marijuana ‘Consultancy’ Shut Down By Dept. of Health
- RI’s Own Miss Universe Olivia Culpo Advocates for Medical Marijuana
- NEW: Patrick Kennedy in the Middle of Super Bowl Marijuana Fight
- RI State Report: Marijuana Decriminalization & Safer Schools
- Will Rhode Island Legalize Marijuana?
- Medical Marijuana User Directs Documentary ‘License To Grow’
- NEW: Patrick Kennedy Opposed to Legalization of Marijuana
- State Budget Paves Way For Medical Marijuana Dispensaries
- NEW: RI Legalization Bill Would Tax Marijuana Like Alcohol
- State Report: Marijuana Legalization Bill + Tax Hike Proposal
- Medical Marijuana Vote Set for Today
- NEW: Top 10 National Marijuana Stories—Rhode Island’s Got One
- State Report: Medical Marijuana, RI’s Business Ranking & Obama Supports Cicilline
- NEW: RI to Introduce Marijuana Regulation + Taxation Bill
- The Highest Marijuana Prices in New England by State
- NEW: Bill Would Legalize Marijuana in Rhode Island
- Newport Manners + Etiquette: Marijuana Manners
- State Report: Strippers, Marijuana Dispensaries & Legislive Payraises
- New England States With The Highest Marijuana Arrest Rates
- The Impact of Marijuana Legalization on RI’s College Campuses
- Are Medical Marijuana Users in Rhode Island Risking Their Jobs?
- NEW: Brown, URI Named Top 10 Colleges for Marijuana Activism
- Poll Shows Half of Americans Support Legalizing Marijuana
- Jared Moffat: Now is the Right Time for RI to Regulate Marijuana
- New Gallup Poll Shows 38% of Americans Have Tried Marijuana
- The Scoop - Whitehouse Talks State and Federal Marijuana Laws
- Will Rhode Island Be The Next State To Legalize Marijuana?
- NEW: Governor Signs Marijuana Decriminalization Bills
- RI Dept. of Health Approves First Medical Marijuana Dispensary
- Leonardo Angiulo: MA Court Takes Hit of Justice in Marijuana Rulings
- PODCAST: Are Medical Marijuana Users in RI Risking Their Jobs?
- ACLU Defends Longtime Medical Marijuana Users Against State
- Breaking and Entering Doc Holding Marijuana Suspended by RI HEALTH
- NEW: Lawmakers to Take Up Medical Marijuana Bill Next Week
- RI Hospital: New Treatments for Marijuana Abuse in Parolees
- Marijuana Use in the New England States