RI Blows $644 Million in ‘Wasteful’ Spending
Tuesday, July 05, 2011
From spending millions of dollars to study obesity rates among Somoans to $250,000 for providing digital television to prison inmates, Rhode Island has blown $644 million in wasteful spending.
Waste was found at all levels of government, from cities and towns to the state budget to federal funds that were funneled back home, according to a new report. The waste and pork included:
■ $1.2 million to see if removing the ovaries of prepubescent rabbits and giving them hormone-treatments affects cardiac death rates. (Federal funds awarded to Rhode Island Hospital.)
■ $53,419 in cash rewards to young people in Mexico who do not contract an STD. (Federal funds awarded to Brown University.)
■ $20 million in federal funds to renovate state lawmakers’ offices.
■ $586,776 to operate the city-owned McDermott Swimming Pool in Warwick.
■ $5.3 million for a new elephant house and botanical exhibit at Roger Williams Park.
■ $1,000 in state funds to an artist who took pictures of naked people jumping and spitting.
The total amount of waste—which is close to a tenth of what the state spends annually—came as a surprise even to some of the most erstwhile local critics of government spending.
“I was surprised. As a former budget negotiator I was told over and over there is no savings in fraud, waste and abuse—those are picked clean,” said state GOP Chairman Ken McKay. “Democrats always say that we ‘have hard decisions to make on spending.’ Either they don’t know what they are talking about or they are misled by their leaders.”
The report—produced by Citizens Against Government Waste and the Ocean State Policy Research Institute—examined spending items in the state budget for the year that just ended and the annual 2010 finance reports for cities and towns. It also included multi-year federal stimulus projects.
“On the state level, we found a lot of questionable expenses with art funding, corporate welfare, with stimulus funds,” said Drew Johnson, the Tennessee-based author of the report, titled “2011 Rhode Island Piglet Book.”
‘Legislative grants’ unique to Rhode Island
Johnson said he was most shocked by the legislative grants that House and Senate members channel back into their districts.
Unlike just about every other form of spending at the state level, legislative grants are not voted on by the full House and Senate. Instead, members in each chamber submit a list of funding requests—everything from youth sports to food banks—which are approved or denied by the Democratic leadership. It’s the closest thing Rhode Island has to earmarks—and it is unique to the Ocean State, according to Johnson, who has produced similar studies of government waste in several other states.
“These legislative grants are pork … any way you define them,” Johnson said. “It’s pretty disgusting.”
In all, $882,620 in Senate legislative grants was distributed in fiscal year 2011. The amount in the House was far less, $248,082. (Spokesmen for the House and Senate leadership declined to comment in time for publication. Click here to read the GoLocalProv report on legislative grants.)
Cities and towns ‘horrible at balancing their budgets’
Rhode Island also stands out in another way. “On the local level basically we found a lot of wasteful spending in terms of the budget,” Johnson said. “The locals are really horrible at balancing their budgets. Cities in Rhode Island seem to be worse than cities in other states in terms of living within their means.”
From the state’s largest city to its smallest, communities across Rhode Island overspent their budgets in 2010. Providence went $58 million into the red, while Central Falls went over its budget by $2.5 million—right before the state appointed a receiver to manage its finances. A number of other communities blew through their budgets well, including:
■ Bristol—over by $5.1 million
■ Woonsocket—over by $2.6 million
■ Newport—police spent $553,000 more than budgeted
■ Smithfield—police went over their budget by $385,000
How is ‘waste’ defined?
Of course, one man’s wasteful spending is another’s worthwhile spending. Even one ardent critic of waste and inefficiency, former Moderate Party gubernatorial candidate Ken Block, took issue with some of the things the report called waste. “There are areas in the waste and fraud discussion where I agree with OSPRI’s report, and areas where we have substantial disagreement,” Block told GoLocalProv.
“Unlike OSPRI, I do not feel that spending on the arts is wasteful,” Block said. “Investing in bicycle-pedestrian infrastructure like bike paths, rail trails and greenways provide safe and necessary athletic, recreation and commuting opportunities. Bike paths raise the quality of life and housing values in areas where they have been built.” (Block noted that one of his businesses, Cross Alert Systems, sells traffic signals for the intersections of recreational trails and public roads.)
Johnson said he does not necessarily oppose all government funding at the arts. But he said it should be at the local, rather than state, level. He said that state funding of art projects, especially those that can be offensive, “crosses the line.”
He said state funding of recreational projects creates winners and losers across the state. “It just strikes me as unfair,” Johnson said.
(Click here to see how the report defines waste at the federal level.)
What about pensions?
One kind of spending not covered in the report is programs that in of themselves might be worthwhile but contain waste due to inefficiencies or abuse of the system. “This report astonishingly misses the wasteful spending and outright fraud inherent in Health and Human Services programs,” Block said. But, he quickly conceded: “It is difficult to quantify the numbers until the waste and fraud have been uncovered, but in other states the numbers have been large.” (Block has offered to help the state root out such waste and fraud in its Health and Human Services programs.)
The report also skips over the whole issue of pensions, which has dominated headlines for months in Rhode Island. Johnson said the topic is just too vast and complex to be covered in the report. “To me it would be a separate report,” he said. “You would basically end up with a pension report and a pork report on the side.”
Biggest waster: federal government
By far, the biggest area of waste was in federal funds that were spent in Rhode Island. In all, $394,268,792 in federal funds made the cut as pork-barrel spending—and that’s not counting all of the $2 billion in federal stimulus funds that found their way to the state. State spending accounted for another $167,670,321, leaving $74,997,548 to cities and towns.
Block said the state process for approval of the budget makes it particularly susceptible to waste.
“Our state budgeting process involves a budget document that has had at most a week of review by those who vote on it. A poorly vetted budget is guaranteed to have wasteful and unnecessary spending attached to it,” Block said. “Unless our state adopts a more transparent and thoughtful process for drafting and approving a budget, we will continue to spend state taxpayer dollars in unwise ways.”
Governor Lincoln Chafee’s office did not respond to a request for comment.
Click here to read the full report for Rhode Island.
If you valued this article, please LIKE GoLocalProv.com on Facebook by clicking HERE.
Related Articles
- Providence Fiscal Crisis: Audit Delayed
- Budget Rescue Plan Unveiled for Pawtucket
- Chafee’s Budget: 3 Percent Increase in Pension Contributions
- Mayor’s Budget in Peril—Tax Increase Could Be Blocked
- NEW: Taxpayer Group Praises House Budget
- Providence Mayor, Council Square Off on Raises in Budget
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT April 14, 2011 Political Fallout of Failed Chafee Budget
- Budget Wars: House vs. Senate
- Chafee’s Budget: More Money for Education
- Mixed Reviews On House Budget Proposal
- Pawtucket Mayor Defends Borrowing Money to Balance Budget
- Providence Misses Key Budget Deadline
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT April 14, 2011 The Governor’s Budget
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT State Budget
- Chafee Balancing the Budget on the Backs of Veterans?
- Chafee’s Budget: Overhauls Transportation Funding
- How Your Taxes Will Be Affected By New State Budget
- State Budget Hinges on $100 Million in Federal Aid
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT April 14, 2011 The Governor’s Budget and Proposed Sales Tax
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT State Budget
- Chafee Budget Dead
- Cost in the Millions: Unused Sick, Vacation Time Threaten City Budget
- NEW: Cicilline Says Budget Cuts Must Be ‘Responsible’
- Prov. City Council Poised to Approve $638M Budget
- State Budget: How Did Providence Make Out?
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT June 16, 2011 Part 1: State Budget
- BREAKING NEWS: Senate Approves $7.7 Billion Budget
- Chafee Budget Threatens RI Film Industry
- Elderly Group Opposes Chafee’s Budget
- NEW: Chafee—‘Running out of Time’ to Fix Central Falls Budget
- Providence Budget Bombshell: $40M in New Taxes
- Taveras Budget: Without State Action, City Won’t Survive
- Auditor: ‘There’s no question the city will run out of money’
- A LIVELY EXPERIMENT June 16, 2011 Part 2: State Budget
- BREAKING NEWS: Taveras Outlines Budget Rescue Plan
- Chafee’s Budget: $176 Million in Tax Increases
- General Assembly Surprise - Longevity Pay Preserved in Budget
- NEW: GOP Condemns Chafee Budget
- Providence Budget: What’s on the Chopping Block?
- Your Cheat Sheet on the State Budget
- EXCLUSIVE: Audit Shows Providence Running Out of Money
- Budget Breakdown: How The New Budget Impacts You
- Chafee’s Budget: $25 Million More in Aid to Cities and Towns
- General Assembly Takes on Chafee’s Budget
- NEW: Group Formed to Oppose Chafee’s Budget
- Providence Budget: Will the General Assembly Come Through?
- EXCLUSIVE: Internal Auditor—Illegal Payments and Benefits in Providence
- Budget Moves Forward Without Governor
- Chafee’s Budget: $80 Million in Cuts
- GoLocalProv Exclusive Interview: Taveras Promises to End Budget Deficit
- NEW: House GOP on Chafee’s Budget: Start Over
- Providence City Council Aims to Prevent Future Budget Crises
