| | Advanced Search


Michael Riley: Rhode Island’s Potential Pension Nightmare—Headed for disaster...

Rob Horowitz: The Civil Rights Act, 50 Years Later—Celebrating a milestone...

Fund for Community Progress Honors GoLocalProv + Other RI Leaders—Recognizing outstanding contributions to the RI community

Organize + Energize: 7 Reasons to Hire a Professional Organizer—With a little help from your friends...

International String Trio to Perform at Pot au Feu in Providence—A fabulous evening of music, food and wine

RE/MAX Reports 1.3% Increase in Pending RI Home Sales for March—Increase in pending sales, but decrease in home…

Former URI Basketball Player Arrested on Murder Charge—Former URI Basketball Player Arrested on Murder Charges

NEW: Rhode Island Named 6th Best State to Eat Local—One of the nation's best in availability of…

NEW: Providence Attorney Nicholas Hemond Joins DarrowEverett LLP—Will serve as new litigation associate

Russell Moore: The Tyranny of the One Percent—MINDSETTER™ Russ Moore analyzes the real shame of…


Memo: Providence Budget Deficit is 50% Larger than Administration Claims

Tuesday, August 07, 2012


Providence’s internal auditor believes the city’s year-end operating deficit is about $6 million more than the Taveras administration has claimed, according to a memo sent to members of the City Council last week.

In the memo, internal auditor Matthew Clarkin explains that he believes the figure is closer to $17.9 million than the $11.9 million figure the administration reported to the state Department of Revenue on July 25. Neither projection includes the city’s plan to underfund its annual required contribution to the pension system by $10 million, a decision city officials defend because of the landmark pension reform agreement reached with retirees earlier this year.

Clarkin says the difference between the two projections stems from his belief that the city will be short $2.2 million from taxes, $600,000 from fines and forfeitures, $1.5 million from the Early Retirement Reimbursement Program (ERRP), $425,000 from workers compensation and $870,000 from encumbrances.

“Both branches of our local government have made hard but necessary decisions,” said City Councilman David Salvatore. “While we are all pleased with the significant progress that has been made, we must continue to keep our eye on the ball and address our budget shortfalls and the challenges this new fiscal year will present.”

A More Transparent Process

Those challenges include what still appears to be a “$25-$30 million structural problem,” according to Gary Sasse, the former head of the Rhode Island Public Expenditure Council (RIPEC) and a consultant with the City Council.

Sasse praised the administration for taking a more transparent approach to addressing the city’s financial troubles, but pointed to decisions to underfund the pension contribution by $10 million as well as some one-time fixes such as transferring money from the Civic Center fund as examples of where the city fell short.

Mayor Taveras’ first two years in office have been dominated by the need to reduce the $110 million structural deficit he inherited upon taking office in January 2011. Since then, the administration has been forced to close schools and cut spending across most city departments while also reaching agreements with the major nonprofits to increase payments in lieu of taxes and the retirees.

“The process was much more transparent,” Sasse said. “It looks to me like the internal auditor picked up on a few things the administration didn’t.”

Cash Shortage Could Trigger Insolvency

The pension reform deal, which earned the support of the majority of the city’s police and fire retirees, is considered one of the key steps the city took to avoid filing for bankruptcy, which Taveras threatened earlier this year.

The plan freezes cost-of-living-adjustments for retirees (COLAs) for ten years, eliminates five and six percent compounded COLAs, places a cap on pensions and moves retirees over the age of 65 onto Medicare. The city projects the pension reform savings will cut its unfunded liability by $170 million.

While city officials are no longer talking bankruptcy, some City Council members say the 2013 fiscal year, which began on July 1, will still be a difficult year for city finances. Councilman Sam Zurier said both the administration and the Council will need to monitor spending to make sure the city avoids cash-flow problems.

“Because the city does not have any cash reserves, it is important for the administration and the City Council to watch closely any revenue shortfalls or cost overruns,” Zurier said. “Even with the progress the city made over the past 18 months in improving its fiscal position, a cash shortage could trigger insolvency.”

Searching for More Cost Cutting

Zurier and Salvatore, two members of the Council Finance committee, say they have each looked at ways to help the city continue to save money moving forward.

Zurier introduced and ordinance last year to enhance revenues by tying the homestead exemption to a requirement to register automobiles in the city and the plan saved the city millions.

“After residents reapplied for the homestead exemption under the new rules, the administration calculated that the current year’s real estate property tax would increase by $6 million without raising the tax rate,” Zurier said. “In addition, the state has reported to the administration that since the new rules went into effect, there has been a surge of additional automobile registrations in the city.”

Salvatore has recently called for an audit of the city’s pharmacy benefit management (PBM) agreements, a proposal he believes could help the city save between nine and 16 percent on its prescription drugs costs.

“While many difficult choices and necessary sacrifices have already been made, we must continue to directly address our City's major cost drivers,” he said. “Recently I have proposed an independent review of the City's prescription benefits in addition to the savings that have already been identified surrounding pensions. These and similar reform measures are needed to protect basic levels of City services.”

Closing the Gap

Both Councilmen agree that while the budget deficit they inherited was significant, the actual opportunities for finding savings have been much more limited. Zurier noted that half of the budget is comprised of state school aid and the city’s municipal appropriate for education, which cannot be reduced under state law.

Similarly, other portions of the budget are considered untouchable due to federal grant restrictions, debt service and other limitations. Zurier said the city’s already high tax burden makes it difficult for quick fixes on the revenue said as well.

“The city’s progress to date is a basis for optimism, but there is no doubt that closing the last $10-$20 million of the gap will be more difficult than it was to close the first $10-$20 million of the $110 million deficit identified last year,” he said.

The Taveras administration declined to comment for this story.

Dan McGowan can be reached at dmcgowan@golocalprov.com. Follow him on Twitter: @danmcgowan.


Enjoy this post? Share it with others.


donatello gori

sam zurier=jacka$$

Christopher Lee

Providence mayor and city council enact fantasy budgets. It's deja vu. Where's the news in this story?

Christopher Lee

Providence mayor and city council enact fantasy budgets. It's deja vu. Where's the news in this story?

Carol DeFeciani

Taveras is incompetent. Zurier and Salvatore are total jokes.

michael riley

Mr Taveras was left a complete mess. I worry that this hard working well meaning mayor hasn't done enough to attack the massive structural problems in Providence finances. More hard choices may be necessary immediately to rescue the city. Mr Cicilline should be embarrassed with his stewardship and the problems he exacerbated and/or covered up while mayor.

David Beagle

Perhaps the eye of the CAT 5 hurricance is over the city right now, making it appear that the storm is over.

P Diaz

It is amazing to me that people actually complain about everything behind these comments.

Personally, while not a big fan of politics,Ican see where at least this council and the mayor have tackled some of the issues. This from a guy that never held office before. All the while, staying focused on the big picture and trying to keep away from the politics of it all as much as possible.

According to this article, Sam was able to provide significant revenues by enforcing something that should have already been taking place. No one likes to pay taxes, but those that avoid paying some or all place the burden on those that are paying them to pay more.

As for the mayor, I remember a young man entering office and ordering that his pay be cut by 10% as a front end costs cutting issue, and then he started on everyone else.

How many of you posting have asked to have their pay cut? How many have asked for a raise?

I thought so. Me, I asked for a raise.

That is my two cents.

Why not start working towards solutions instead of blame-shifting. I am certain that the administration could use some help.

Harold Stassen

Is anyone really surprised at this information. After all Mayor Taveras has picked up exactly where his mentor David Cicilline left off, get an acquiescent council to approve fake budgets, then misreport the results. Sound familiar? So spare us the undeserved bouquets Mr. Riley.

However, the most disturbing information in this report is the Taveras Administration decision to skip a $10M pension payment. This is exactly how the pension mess began. If I were a retiree who just made significant concessions based upon the mayor's bankruptcy threat, I'd be just a little bit po'd. But then, the beat goes on, from one crisis to another.

Captain Blacksocks

Can only fake it for so long. When the cash is gone, it's gone. The property owners in Providence will not sit still for another tax hike to make up for the city's decades of financial mismanagement. And the city unions will not sit still for more pension cuts. It's too late now. No surprise here at all -- in fact the voters in RI are so dumb they will resounding re-elect David C to congress. Expect Providence to declare insolvency well before the problem the solved.

bill bentley

Why can't these government types ever discuss increasing revenues and not by raising taxes. The solution is always this archaic "we need to find more savings." Expanding revenues such as third party reimbursements for educational costs, maybe some additional partnerships that involve City assets, at some point you can't cut your way out of the problem.

nhardungshan billaa

National wind cotton LAC mixed colors loose knit pants CQ64040 - $34.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

Gary Arnold

Traveras has been a LOT more transparent then predecessor Sissylinie.
The city still reeks of waste, fraud and partisan politics.

Russ Hryzan

At least Taveras is letting the internal auditor examine the books...that's a lot more than can be said for Cicilline!

nhardungshan billaa

أوميغا دي فيل المشارك محوري مقياس الفترات الزمنية الوجيزة أوميغا السيدات 'كوكتيل أوميغا رجال مجموعة زينة أوميغا CUSTOM_KEYWORDS

nhardungshan billaa

Großhandel Hermes Birkin 30 Taschen, Billig Hermes Birkin 30 Beutel - Günstige Handtaschen

nhardungshan billaa

Chanel 2.55 Bag Quilted Light Skin With Gold Hardware (Red) - $187.00 : TITLE, SITE_TAGLINE

nhardungshan billaa

カモコロンビアの文字列 [UNM291] 新着 ワンピース ツーピース タンキニ Skirtini 隠す ビキニ&アップセットカバー 子供の水着 ヨガの摩耗 スポーツウェア クリアランス レディース水着 ecommerce, open source, shop, online shopping

nhardungshan billaa

マイアミ Monokiniホワイトクリアランス [VV001C] 新着 ワンピース ツーピース タンキニ Skirtini 隠す ビキニ&アップセットカバー 子供の水着 ヨガの摩耗 スポーツウェア クリアランス レディース水着 ecommerce, open source, shop, online shopping

nhardungshan billaa

ny release

nhardungshan billaa

Outdoor reppu, 15L ~ 35L urheilulaukku

nhardungshan billaa

Fendi Belts 129 Blue - $130.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

[Poly Design] the Liebo spring and summer new the Dongfeng yarn - $51.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Burberry Belt BB0030-Grey - $106.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Ландерс Lesndes открытых мужчин и женщин, кататься на этом же пу, Новая версия, Быстрая сушка белья, Чрезвычайная нижнее белье, Пара кожи и шерсти, рюкзак, Открытый обувь, Оборудование аксессуары, Муж

nhardungshan billaa

Louis Vuitton Kvinnors Väskor & Handväskor Neverfull GM Grön M93 - SEK 770.61 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

2012 new fashion popular aesthetic wrapped chest bride wedding d - $83.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Kengät: Replica Designer Käsilaukut Store, Replica Designer Käsilaukut Store

nhardungshan billaa

Breitling Bentley Motors Blanco y Negro Reloj-BB2279 - €126.62 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Louis Vuitton Women's Bags & Handbags Tulum PM Brown M40076 - $22.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Taking some Mediterranean cruise certainly is the dream for many people, for their honeymoon.Fortunately, if this is actually a dream of yours its easier previously to attain since there are numerous yachts and luxury cruise ships that look into a honeymoon vacation Mediterranean luxury cruise and earning your earliest vacation as wife and husband the best it is able to possibly end up being.

When you're on your budget, don't stress either once you can go on a Mediterranean cruise for just a good price any time you simply do a tiny amount of searching.Many go websites look at Mediterranean cruise trip vacations and quite often offer lower packages.As expected, you won't go for a discount Mediterranean sea cruise if you simply sit by and can nothing concerning this.What you decide to do is search all of the Internet internet sites that consentrate on cruises, possibly even discount cruises.Then, find available what time of year is local plumber for a Mediterranean cruise in addition to least expensive year for any Mediterranean luxury cruise.These considerations could help you save a significant bill on any Mediterranean cruise when you plan to search in your off-season.

Moreover, different working day packages plus Mediterranean cruise trip destinations may well affect entertainment your Mediterranean sea cruise.Keep this as their intended purpose and don't have your cardiovascular set upon an exact directory destinations or possibly days, but alternatively work with what is out there and less pricey.If you could be determined to look at a Med cruise for your personal honeymoon will be possible to get something which is to be pleasing to you personally including your budget.The finest advice is to start researching and having plans for your personal Mediterranean cruise as early upfront as possible to achieve the most effective deals.

nhardungshan billaa

2012 Весной и летом

nhardungshan billaa

2012 uuden kansallisen tuuli V kaulus lyhythihainen T-paidat, br - €18.92 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Specials 2012 Summer Phoenix , a new improved stylish embroidery - $39.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Den Liebo ægte originale ny fjeder efterlader to U - hals T - sh - DKK351.97 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

> Verliebte sich in Tanz Jordan Chan verheiratet Kleidung Rotgar - €37.11 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Hermes Belts Gray 451-9 - $106.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Hermes Birkin 40 Niloticus Crocodile skin Gold Hardware (Red) - $288.00 : TITLE, SITE_TAGLINE

nhardungshan billaa

> Fell in love with the white female dance costume costumes stud - $22.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

New spring single-breasted splicing fifth of jeans girl, H9088 - $50.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

The Liebo authentic 2011 New Spring and Autumn printing base rou - $43.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

andet udstyr

nhardungshan billaa

Omega klockor , mina damer och herrar omega klockor, falska omega klockor

nhardungshan billaa

2011 Hermes Silk Scarf WJH049 Black - $74.00 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Kasman / CASIMA 11 nya Valentines LOVE personligheten trend kvin - SEK 741.81 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Links of London Armband LLBL036 - €34.93 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Louis Vuitton Mahina XL Acajou M95998 - €216.85 : Zen Cart!, The Art of E-commerce

nhardungshan billaa

Omega Constellation Brushed Chronometer - $229.00 : TITLE, SITE_TAGLINE

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.