New “One Tower” Design for 195 in Providence Draws Mixed Reaction
Friday, December 09, 2016
City Council President Luis Aponte, who had criticized the first three tower proposal when it came out, said that he appreciated Fane’s willingness to take feedback.
“Looks like one evil tower is better than three,” said Aponte. “Look, it shows a willingness to understand the terrain and the concern of city leaders -- I am under impression that this was a negotiative process.”
SLIDES: See Reactions from Community Leaders BELOW
After releasing his three tower vision in November, Fane's new proposal, or "Phase One," is a proposed 43 story tower, which "will infuse a projected $150 million in new development into the state’s capitol city," according to the company.
“It's smaller scale, fewer units, and a different approach than proposed -- the design hasn't gotten better but that's something we can work on,” said Aponte. “We look forward to further discussions and I'm please with their enthusiasm that they want to move forward quickly.”
Jewelry District Association Vice-President Sharon Steele said that she opposed the original proposal, and opposes the new tower for similar reasons.
In his release Thursday, Fane acknowledge the opposition based on the towers’ size.
“Some people think that our proposed towers will be much higher than the existing tall buildings in downtown Providence. In fact, the opposite is true. Some confusion was caused by the angle of the rendering, where perspective made Hope Point Towers look much taller than the other Providence towers including the so-called 'Superman' Building,” “Our phase one, 43 story tower, is only about 20 feet taller than the Superman building and includes both residential use and parking, which Superman does not.”
Steele said that it was not only the tower’s height, but how it is designed that she is concerned about how it would fit in the area.
“These buildings - and this tower - are slated to be built on ‘podiums’ of five stories — that’s for parking,” said Steele. “116 Chestnut Street is six stories. That would be just the platform — that will read like a wall, all along Dyer Street. Behind it is the park, and the river, and pedestrian bridge. The park would be in constant shadow, and then it becomes for all intents and purposes a private park for the towers. We didn’t fight [the Paw Sox] stadium to end up with a five story podium for parking."
SLIDES: See More Reaction to the "One Tower" Proposal on 195 Land in Providence BELOW
Related Slideshow: Reactions to Fane’s “One Tower” Proposal on 195 - December 9, 2016
Former Mayor of Providence
"If the developer thinks the market is there, and the state doesn't have to subsidize it - if someone wants to come in and spend hundreds of millions of their own money, we should try and make it easier, not more difficult. Yes, they’d be getting a tax stabilization but remember that property isn't paying taxes now -- highways have never paid property taxes.
As for people opposed to it, as my dad used to tell me, that's why Howard Johnson has 28 flavors -- everyone has their opinion on what's attractive or not attractive, what’s an addition to the skyline, or a detraction. But again, if someone wants to spend hundreds of millions and employ people and create housing and add an attractive element to the city, we should be embracing it."
Project Manager, Public Policy at United Way of Rhode Island, founding member of the Millennial Professional Group of Rhode Island
“I’ve heard from young professionals who have left the state, citing our lack of development and opportunity as reasons why. If we want to tackle our brain-drain, young professionals and recent graduates need more opportunities to work and thrive.
While it's encouraging to see out-of-state developers wanting to invest in our state, any proposal should be given thoughtful review to truly understand how it can help our business community."
Executive Director, The Providence Foundation
"We certainly welcome outside investor and capital interest in downtown and growing the downtown residential community is one of our goals because of the many benefits that it brings.
However, this proposal is quite a departure from the plans that many have been developed for this area and thus requires analysis, study and discussion. At this point, the Providence Foundation does not have sufficient information nor has had the time to discuss the project."
Jewelry District Association Vice-President
“We need ‘live, work, and play’ - in scale. We have 95 Chestnut with 60 plus units, Plot 30 with same developer with 90 units, so together that’s 150 units. Then we’ll have the two seven story towers, ‘River House', after South Street landing is completed, next to Davol Square. Then we’ll have 44 Hospital Street.
These are all the right scale, appropriate to the district, all ready to go — what we need is business, lab space, bio tech, start-ups - so that we have people who then need to live there.”
- Raimondo Names 6 New 195 Commissioners
- Proposed Providence Three Towers Trimmed to Just One Tower in New Design
- Minority Contractors Question Being Blocked From I-195 Development
- NEW: 195 Redevelopment Consultant Contract Draws Nine Bidders
- NEW: Providence Stadium Deal Opponents Pressure 195 Commission into Open Meeting
- Owners of Potential New PawSox Site Issue Statement As Alternative to 195 Land
- Opponents Blast Tax Breaks for 195 Dormitory Deal
- PODCAST: Opponents Blast Tax Breaks for 195 Dormitory Deal
- NEW: Solomon Proposes Master Tax Stabilization Plan for 195 Land
- Fung, Taveras Leasing Campaign Headquarters from 195 Bidder Carpionato
- NEW: Newport Yachting Center Sold to 195 Kane’s Firm
- Providence City Council Members Question Dormitory Deal on 195 Land
- NEW: Providence Foundation Endorses 195 Location for Stadium
- 195 Commission Announces New BioTech Proposal for Providence Land
- Guest MINDSETTER™ VanderWeele: The I-195 Land - Subdivide & Conquer
- The Most Famous Band Formed Each Year Since 1951
- Thoughts on Dumbing Down Politicians, Visual Illiteracy, and I-195
- Aponte Slams 195 Tower Proposal in Providence
- Take a Tour of the Proposed 3 Towers on 195 Land
- Robert Healey, 1957-2016: Rhode Island Leaders React
- The Most Destructive Hurricanes Since 1950
- Critics Raise Questions Over New 195 Tax Break Plan for Providence
- NEW: 195 Commission Director Brodie Resigns
- Providence Preservation Society Opposes 195 Location for Stadium
- EXCLUSIVE: Major Music Promoter Eyeing 195 Stadium Land in Providence
- Will 3 Towers on 195 Land Kill Superman Building’s Future for Residential?