NEW: Chafee Disappointed with Supreme Court Ruling
Monday, January 14, 2013
The Supreme Court decision means that Pleau will be tried at the federal level, where prosecutors will seek the death penalty for a 2010 crime in which he is accused of murdering a Lincoln man outside of a Woonsocket bank.
Pleau had already agreed to serve a life sentence without parole under state law and Chafee, an opponent of the death penalty, sought to keep him in state custody but lost in a key decision back in May when the First Circuit Court of Appeals decided, 3-2, to reject his argument that, under a federal law known as the Interstate Agreement on Detainers (IAD), he had the legal right to refuse to turn over Pleau.
“I am disappointed that the United States Supreme Court has decided not to review this important case,” Chafee said in a statement. “Rhode Island and 47 other states entered into the Interstate Agreement on Detainers in good faith. That Agreement authorizes Governors to refuse a prisoner transfer request when it would violate the custodial state’s public policy. I invoked the Agreement to block the transfer of Mr. Pleau to federal custody because it appeared that the sole purpose of that transfer was to subject Mr. Pleau to the death penalty – a penalty that Rhode Island has long rejected.”
Chafee said that he believes that, under the agreement, the federal government was “obligated to respect Rhode Island’s right … to refuse to transfer the prisoner.”
“That it did not and that the federal courts did not enforce the express terms of the Agreement is cause for concern both for the future of the Agreement and for our federalism,” Chafee said. ”As I have repeatedly said, my involvement in this case was not about Mr. Pleau personally, but rather about critical states’ rights issues.”
- NEW: Chafee Will Appeal Jason Pleau Decision
- NEW: Court to Review Pleau Murder Case
- NEW: Pleau to be Turned Over to Feds Wednesday
- NEW: Chafee Remains Opposed to Death Penalty for Jason Wayne Pleau
- NEW: Feds to Seek Death Penalty for Jason Wayne Pleau
- NEW: ACLU Urges Supreme Court To Review Jason Pleau Death Penalty Case
- NEW: ACLU Wants Death Penalty Efforts for Jason Pleau Halted