| | Advanced Search


Russell Moore: Experience Makes Caprio a No-Brainer for Treasurer—Let's face it: politics is strange business.

Smart Benefits: Two Regs Issued on Contraceptive Coverage—Two regulations on contraceptive coverage were recently issued…

Peace Flag Project to Host Rhode Island Month of Peace in September—The Peace Flag Project will host over 30…

Don’t Miss: Fall Newport Secret Garden Tours—The Benefactors of the Arts will present a…

Fall Activities for the Whole Family—Mark your calendars for the best activities of…

Skywatching: Seagrave Memorial Observatory Centennial (1914-2014)—Skyscrapers, Inc., the Amateur Astronomical Society of Rhode…

Friday Financial Five - August 29, 2014—The Tax Foundation has put together a helpful…

RI Resource Recovery Collected 6K Pounds of Clothes—RI Resource Recovery has received more than 6,000…

5 Live Music Musts - August 29, 2014—We’ve got Rhythm and Roots and a whole…

The Cellar: Late Summer Values—While this week saw some fantastic weather there…


INVESTIGATION: Money Ties PPAC, Board Members to Projo Insiders

Thursday, April 03, 2014


Several top board members for the Providence Performing Arts Center have deep financial ties to the Providence Journal, which receives about half a million dollars in advertising revenue from the arts nonprofit, GoLocalProv has learned.

PPAC lists as one of its board members Scott Connolly, the senior vice president for sales and marketing at the Providence Journal. He is the second-highest ranked executive in the advertising division.

Flickr/Daniel Borman

Connolly is not the only board member with financial ties to the Providence Journal.

The chair of the board is Joe Walsh, a top lobbyist who represents the Rhode Island Daily Newspaper Association at the Statehouse. Walsh has been leading a battle against proposed new legislation that would lift the requirement that state legal notices go in designated papers of record, like the Providence Journal. Walsh earned $30,000 during the last legislative session as a lobbyist for the newspaper association, according to filings with the Secretary of State.

Walsh also sits on the board of directors for one of PPAC’s three subsidiary for-profit organizations, Professional Facilities Management. PPAC has refused to disclose whether its staff or board members have any ownership stakes in the businesses.

A third board member, Mark Ryan, is a former executive vice president for the Providence Journal Company and also worked as the company’s legal counsel and senior corporate attorney. Ryan is currently a principal at Moses Afonso Ryan. Online records show that Ryan was a board member at the same time that he held his position at the Journal. As of 2010, he was an investor in stock with the owner of the Providence Journal, the A.H. Belo Corporation, according to filings with the state ethics commission.

PPAC is a top advertiser with the Providence Journal. In 2013, PPAC generated over $450,000 in ad revenues for the Providence Journal, according to an internal sales document obtained by GoLocalProv. As ad revenue at the Providence Journal has declined—from $137 million in 2005 to $41 million in 2013—that amount represents a more significant share of the paper’s overall ad revenues that it once might have. Online archives for the Journal show PPAC is a consistent advertiser, placing at least 224 ads in the paper since 2011, with 43 in the last six months—not counting any Web advertising.

‘Not exactly kosher’

Flickr/Lain Cuthbertson

Connolly has held an executive sales position at the Providence Journal over the course of that decade. From 2005 to 2009 he was a vice president for sales and marketing. In 2009, he entered his current position as senior vice president. Connolly has been on PPAC’s board at least since early 2012, online records show.

Connolly’s dual positions could be a potential ethical issue, according to Stephen Shepard, the founding dean emeritus of the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism. But, he said, it might be more of a problem for PPAC than the Journal. “It’s really more of a governance question than a journalism ethics question,” said Shepard, a former editor-in-chief at BusinessWeek.

Shepard said Connolly should not be receiving any benefits from the organization on whose board he serves because it could potentially compromise his independent judgment. “From a governance question, it’s not exactly kosher,” Shepard said.

Connolly did not respond to a request for comment.

PPAC won’t release documents

A conflict of interest does not necessarily disqualify a person from sitting on the board of directors for a nonprofit as long as that conflict is fully disclosed to fellow board members, according to Toni Boucher, the director of the Commonfund Institute, which specializes in research and education on the best practices in the nonprofit sector, including investment practices and governance.

Flickr/Jon S

“To avoid the reputation of self-dealing the board members should disclose everything—their outside income, their outside employment, and their relationship with the nonprofit,” Boucher said.

A board member with a financial relationship between his nonprofit and his business should also abstain from any votes, Boucher noted.

GoLocalProv requested the PPAC board meeting minutes for the past three years. PPAC declined to provide those, along with any conflict of interest disclosure forms that Connolly and any other board members might have submitted. PPAC officials, through a spokesperson, also declined comment.

IRS ramps up scrutiny

Boucher said the nonprofit community remains divided over whether it is acceptable to have board members serving with conflicts of interest. But, she added, the IRS has become increasingly concerned about the issue, asking nonprofits to disclose information and compensation and potential conflicts in the annual Form 990s they must file to maintain their tax-exempt status.

According to its latest available Form 990, PPAC does have a written policy on conflicts of interest that directors and top staff are annually required to fill out. But PPAC is not required to identify those potential conflicts on the form.

A recent ethics report issued by the Commonfund Institute warns that nonprofits must be particularly vigilant about conflicts that involve the purchase of goods or services.

“The purchase of goods or services by nonprofits from board members or their companies raises special concerns about the real beneficiary of such transactions—the nonprofit or the board member. The IRS Good Governance guidelines caution that ‘in particular, the duty of loyalty requires a director to avoid conflicts of interest that are detrimental to the charity.’ Regular reviews should be made to assure that joint ventures, investments and management consulting arrangements of the nonprofit reflect reasonable investments or payments and further the mission of the nonprofit without creating a prohibited private or excessive benefit,” Boucher writes in the report.

When there would be a journalism ethics issue

The question of whether there is a conflict of interest for the Providence Journal hinges on a different set of circumstances, according to experts in media ethics.

“There are certain lines that people in the news world right up and including the news editor are not supposed to cross,” said Dan Kennedy, an assistant professor of journalism at Northeastern University. But, those rules do not apply to newspaper executives and it is not uncommon for a publisher or other executive to sit on the boards for civic or community organizations—positions that might be inappropriate for those who work on the news side, Kennedy said.

The outside affiliations of an ad sales executive would only become problematic if the executive tries to influence what happens on the news side, according to John Pantalone, the chair of the Journalism Department at the Harrington School of Communication and Media at the University of Rhode Island. “Editorial people strongly resist any pressure that comes from ad people, either to write something or to not writing something,” Pantalone said.

“That’s a classic conflict of interest at newspapers and news sites that rely on advertising,” Pantalone said.

GoLocalProv reached out to John Hill, the president of the Providence Newspaper Guild, but he did not immediately respond to a message seeking comment.

Fox recused himself from pro-PPAC vote

This is not the first time questions have been raised about potential conflicts of interest involving PPAC board members. In 2012, the state expanded the film tax credit program to encompass theaters. As written, the law was neutral—no theater was specified. But, in fact, because the credits were reserved for venues with only 1,500 seats or more, just two were eligible: PPAC and the Veterans Auditorium, which is controlled by a subsidiary business of PPAC, as GoLocalProv reported in 2012.

The credit expansion was buried in one of the articles for the annual state budget, which is developed by the Rhode Island House of Representatives. At the time, House Speaker Gordon Fox was also a board member for PPAC. A spokesman told GoLocalProv that Fox has recused himself from the floor vote on the article.

Fox resigned as House Speaker last month. Although he is no longer identified as House Speaker, Fox’s name remains on the list of board members on PPAC’s Web site.

Stephen Beale can be reached at [email protected]. Follow him on Twitter @bealenews


Related Slideshow: PPAC and Projo: How Are They Connected?

Top board members for the Providence Performing Arts Center have a vested financial interest in the newspaper into which the nonprofit funnels hundreds of thousands in advertising revenue, the Providence Journal. See the list of the board members who have a potential conflict of interest.

Prev Next

Joe Walsh

Chairman of PPAC Board, Providence Journal Lobbyist

Top lobbyist at the State House for more than two decades. He has chaired the PPAC board since the early 1990s and is on the board of the related for-profit companies. PPAC won’t disclose if he has an ownership interest.

Serves as the lobbyist for the Providence Journal and other newspapers trying to block the budget article to stop forcing cities and towns to buy newspapers for legal notices. The article would save the state and Rhode Island communities millions.

Prev Next

Mark T. Ryan, Esq.

First Vice Chairman of PPAC Board, Former Providence Journal Executive Vice President

Ryan, who serves as counsel to the Providence Journal and is a significant shareholder in A.H Belo stock (parent company to the Providence Journal), is currently a principal of Moses Afonso Ryan LTD.

He has worked in various capacities on a city and state level, including serving as a commissioner on the I-195 Commission, Chair of the Search Committee for an Economic Development Director for the City of Providence, and Co-Chair of the City of Providence Mayor Angel Taveras’ Transition Team.

Prev Next

Scott C. Connolly

PPAC Board Member and Sr. Vice President for Sales & Marketing for Providence Journal

Connolly is the top sales person at the Providence Journal and second only to publisher Howard Sutton. Connolly has led sales for the Projo during a period of decline from over $130 million to $41 million (2005 to 2013). PPAC spent over $450,000 in 2013 with the Providence Journal and PPAC refuses to disclose board meeting minutes to determine if Connolly and Ryan voted on the budget.

Prev Next

Gordon D. Fox, Esq.

(Former Speaker), PPAC Board Member

Fox has served on the board during his time as Speaker and Majority Leader. He recently resigned as Speaker of the House after his office was raided by FBI and IRS agents. Fox continues to serve on the PPAC Board. The PPAC website recently removed his Speaker title next to his name.


Related Articles


Enjoy this post? Share it with others.


OMG, RI has an Irish Arts Mafia. What's next?

Comment #1 by John McGrath on 2014 04 03

@Stephen Beale: So what's your point?

Comment #2 by Charles Beckers on 2014 04 03

What is the story here? If you report on the $1,000,000 grant they get from the state there's a story. But this article is a whole lot of nothing. Of course they have smart business men on their board, why wouldn't they!

Comment #3 by Chris Digman on 2014 04 03

So what? The majority of the General Assembly has a conflict of interest. Most are voting on issues that affect public unions while having major ties to them. No one seems to care about that! The only people that get truly represented in this state are the public union employees - the rest of us are kept around to fund their paychecks and benefits! Where's the in-depth story on that?

Comment #4 by C B11 on 2014 04 03

The Projo is for sale as we speak. I know I would want an answer to some of these relationships if I were a bidder for this newspaper. I think the price just went down.

Comment #5 by michael riley on 2014 04 03

This PPAC-Gate scandal ranks right up there with Water-Gate the Iran-Contra scandal, and the Beirut Scandal

Never forget that "Mr Hollywood" Ronald Reagan, sold some of our
most sophisticated weapons to his conservative friends in Iran, (Iran-Contra Scandal) then funneled the cash to the Contras, a conservative right-wing terrorist group who's tactics included murder, rape, beatings and kidnapping. Both the arms sale to Iran, and the money laundering were felonies at the time, and still are today
Also remember 1983 Reagan disarmed the Marines while ordering them into Beirut, 241 Marines died needlessly.

Comment #6 by Sammy Arizona on 2014 04 03

I don't know the people named in this article, and I don't know their motivations.

BUT I presume that at least part of their motivation is civic mindedness. I would imagine that they, like everyone else in RI and the people who run the Providence Journal, are nervous about the economic health of Rhode Island, Providence in particular. I presume that they see PPAC as a very valuable civic asset, and want to see it thrive financially and have the ability to attract top management talent, not just now but in the future as well. After all, PC upped the coach's compensation way beyond $800,000 in order to get the right talent, one who might even stick around.

As for the category of "non-profit," this term covers a multitude of virtues. Universities, for instance, which pay top dollar. And major arts organizations, with the majors players in the arts also paying top dollar.

PPAC is not just a non-profit, it is a player in the entertainment industry, whose major players pay execs top dollar. By being a non-profit it aims to keep ticket prices as low as possible while still succeeding as a player in the entertainment industry.

A little perspective, please.

P.S. I never go to PPAC, its prices being too expensive for me, and its offerings not to my taste. I never go to Trinity because it too is too expensive for me. But there are many others arts venues I do go to - and even contribute to - because I can afford them on a regular basis. But that does not mean that the pricing structures of PPAC and Trinity are not reasonable.

Comment #7 by John McGrath on 2014 04 03

This is not even a story! Don't people understand that in Rhode Island it is hard not to know what people do before you are elected to a board? The disclosure would be made well in advance of someone being on a board and have difficulty believing that anyone on PPAC's board are trying to influence the news. What negative things could you possibly say about PPAC and their contribution to Providence and Rhode Island in general? They have done nothing but be a positive influence in our community. Too bad we cant say the same for the legislature or Fox...

Comment #8 by Andrew Therrien on 2014 04 03

Golocal writing about journalism ethics; hah!

Comment #9 by bill bentley on 2014 04 03

Another in a series of articles by this website which verges on sensationalism and tabloid journalism. Not to mention it's always wallowing in negativity. Given this "woe is RI" modus operandi, I don't visit this site very much, but this article is so outrageous I had to comment. What a waste of space. The writers of many of these articles act like they have never been anywhere outside of RI in their negativity and provincialism. I do like the food articles though, but the rest is garbage.

Comment #10 by Otto Benson on 2014 04 06

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.