EXCLUSIVE: Police and Fire Want to Move Their Pensions from State Back to Cranston
Monday, May 04, 2015
In a move that could be viewed as a mechanism to circumvent pension reform, the Cranston Fire and Police Unions are urging state and city officials to move their pension plans -- that are currently part of the state’s system -- back under city control.
Most of the current public safety employees in Cranston are part of the state MERS system (municipal employee retirement system). In 1995, the city of Cranston and the Police and Fire Unions agreed to move new employees into a state pension system. The 1995 move was made because the Cranston system was significantly underfunded. It gave the state, not the city, control of the pension system.
As part of the state system, the plan’s design was subject to state legislative decisions. Under city control, collective bargaining, and the contracts that result from it, would govern the pension system.
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLASTMoving Back to Cranston
Paul Valletta, the President of the Cranston Fire Fighters Union, Local 1363, said that the two unions (his and the police) approached Mayor Allan Fung about the possibility of moving the plans back under city control about a year ago.
“Mayor Fung said ‘put a plan together that’s less expensive than the one we’re paying for now and I’ll take a look at it’,” said Valletta. “We’ve been running actuarial studies for the better part of a year now.”
The vast majority of Cranston’s public safety retirees are part of the older pension system, which is woefully underfunded; while its current employees are part of the new system. It’s important to note that the new plan, however, would not be merged with the older, underfunded plan, but would become an entirely new plan.
Back in 2012, the bond rating agency Moody’s Investor Service downgraded the Cranston bond rating and the chief reason they cited was that the city's police and fire pension system was only 17.8% funded.
Moving the plan would basically entail creating a new pension plan, with its own framework, which would make the plan completely outside the scope of the statewide pension reform passed in 2011.
Valletta’s Plan
The firefighters' proposal, which would need state approval, would take $69 million dollars in contributions that the employees have made over the last two decades and place them under a new system that the city would control and manage. Valletta said that Fung insisted that the new pension proposal should use a 7.5 percent rate of return as an assumption for the investment income—the rate that was enacted on the statewide level.
Valletta said the unions are working on a plan that he believes would save the city $20 million in liabilities over the long-term by reducing some of the benefits paid out.
His plan would also adopt “blue collar” mortality tables. The state currently uses so-called “white collar” mortality tables to calculate the liabilities of the plan—a practice Valletta has vociferously opposed. White collar mortality tables assume people will live longer, because they worked in less hazardous professions, which increases pension plan liabilities.
“Stumbling Block”
Valletta cautioned that while there is a framework in mind, the proposal is still far from finalized, and therefore said he couldn’t release its specific details at this juncture.
A “stumbling block" so far, Valletta said, has been the fact that the unions believe they should be entitled to a portion of the interest that’s been accumulated on the contributions they’ve made over the years. Valletta said state level leaders didn’t react favorably to that notion.
The Fung administration declined comment on the issue. Reached on Friday morning, Robert Coupe, who serves as Fung’s Director of Administration, said that he didn’t feel comfortable commenting on the issue due to statewide pension lawsuit. Asked if the issue really had anything to do with the ongoing lawsuit, Coupe still declined comment.
“This and the lawsuit has everything to do with their pension plan, so I am not going to comment on that question,” said Coupe.
Cranston City Council President John Lanni said he hasn’t been briefed on the issue, but has heard the rumors. Lanni expressed concern with the idea of the city taking over control of the pension plans – and their significant liabilities – from the state.
“At first blush, no,” said Lanni, when asked if he supported the concept.
“With the cuts that have been made to the state system, I can understand why (the unions) would want to bring it back to the city system, but I’m not sure if that it makes sense for the city," said Lanni.
Related Slideshow: Cranston Police Contributions to Allan Fung
Related Articles
- Cranston Man Convicted in Federal Court of Threatening to Assault and Kill IRS Agent
- NEW: Law Enforcement Group Criticizes Lack of Minorities for Cranston Police Chief Search
- NEW: Block Blasts Fung on Cranston Share of State Aid
- Riley: Cranston and Mayor Fung Play the Hand that was Dealt
- NEW: Cranston Police Union Attorney Blasts Fung Proposal
- Cranston Police Source of Intimidation, Say Critics
- Cranston’s Castelli, Shnapir tied for 5th at Olympics
- NEW: Cranston Police Chief Palumbo Retires
- Former Cranston Mayor Laffey is Running for Congress in CO
- LISTEN: Fung Supported Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants as Cranston Councilman
- Cranston’s Parkhurst, Attleboro’s Cameron Make World Cup Team
- Fung Supported Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants as Cranston Councilman
- Cranston Women’s Volunteer Organization Holds Membership Drive
- American Idols Coming to Cranston
- GoLocalProv Interviews George Thorogood - Rock Legend Coming to Cranston
- NEW: Crews Working on Water Main Break on Cranston/Johnston Line
- PODCAST: Cranston Police Source of Intimidation, Say Critics
- Don Roach: Fung Gains Cranston GOP Endorsement as Block Falters
- NEW: ACLU Suing Cranston Police
- Top Cranston Police Gave Thousands to Fung
- What Fung Needs to Do to Win
- The Scoop: Fung Confirms Christie RI Visit, Almonte Blasts Magaziner on Disclosure, and More
- The Scoop: Fung Hits Back at Negative Ad, Dems Blast Fung-Christie Connections, and More
- The Scoop: Block Endorses Fung; Elorza, Almonte, Magaziner Pick up Endorsements, and More
- The Scoop: Cianci’s New Plan, Fung Got New TV and More
- New: Block Calls on Fung to Explain Immigration Freedom Ride Support
- Fungs Wins RI GOP Gubernatorial Primary
- The Scoop: Fung Poll Shows Dead Heat With Raimondo
- NEW: McKee CIaims Taylor Splitting from Fung
- The Scoop: RI Democratic Governors Association Blasts Fung, Christie, and More
- Fung Fought Against Domestic Partner Benefits, Public Hearings as Insurance Lobbyist
- The Scoop: Obama, Raimondo Dine at Gregg’s, Fung Calls Out Raimondo on Ethical Standards and More
- NEW: Fung Blasts Raimondo on Point Judith Ties to Providence Contracts
- Both Fung and Raimondo Camps say Johnston, North Providence are Bellwethers
- Fung Concession: ‘I Will Be Back’
- The Scoop: Fung Blasts Raimondo on Campaign Contribution, Kilmartin Hits Hodgson Over NRA, and More
- The Scoop: Elorza Requests Investigation Into Possible Ballot Tampering, Fung Tours Brutopia
- The Scoop: Brown’s Quinn to Head Watson Institute Communications, Fung on Sales Tax, and More
- The Scoop: RI Dems Blasts Fung on Flip-Flop, New Magaziner Ad, and More
- The Scoop: Fung Blasts Raimondo on RI Housing, Taylor Calls McKee on Flip-Flop, and More
- The Scoop: Fung Releases New Television Ad, Smith Blasts Paiva-Weed, and More
- Cranston Neighborhood Named To National Register
- Cranston Teen Wins $36,000 for Social Action Service–Nat’l Award
- Daily Vine: Morning Line at the Cranston DMV
- Don Roach: Does Anyone Care About Cranston School Secretaries?
- Cranston Tax Preparers Sentenced for Stealing Identities of Minors
- Voter Turnout at Cranston High School East
- Block Battles with Fung Over His Claims About Pension/401k Savings in Cranston
- NEW: ACLU Calls for Investigation of Cranston Police Dept. Practices
- NEW: Cranston Diner Owner on Fung: “You’ve Got to be Kidding Me”
- Fung, Palombo, City of Cranston and Others Sued for Civil Rights Violation in Federal Court
- Block Calls on Fung to Explain His Role in Cranston Police Scandals