Critics Blast Raimondo Administration for $1 Million Waste on Johnson & Johnson Buildout
Saturday, September 30, 2017
A GoLocal investigation uncovered that the Raimondo administration will waste $1 million for incentives building out space for Johnson & Johnson.
The monies go to the private developer Wexford and in two years, Johnson & Johnson will leave to move into another Wexford space — which is receiving $40 million in incentives.
Reaction to the news was swift and damning.
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST“As Treasurer and now as Governor, Gina Raimondo has overseen an unprecedented transfer of Rhode Islanders' tax dollars to Wall Street interests,” said former Governor Lincoln Chafee. He has become a tough critic of fellow Democrat Gina Raimondo's economic development policies (see Video).
“Taxpayer-funded corporate subsidies are labeled as ‘senseless’, ‘foolhardy’ and ‘shortsighted’ by the New York Times, but a [public policy] that the Providence Journal continues to endorse. It is a scandal and a sad state of affairs for our struggling state,” added Chafee.
The investigation was sparked after Raimondo announced that Johnson & Johnson would move from One Ship Street -- the space that has already received $1 million in state funds via the I-195 Commission -- to the Wexford Campus.
“Rhode Island doesn’t have in-house due diligence, which makes our planning and development policies primitive. If fiscal accountability is also absent, as might be the case here, we essentially become far too reliant on ‘dumb luck’ for success,” said URI Economic Len Lardaro.
Former RI Director of Administration Gary Sasse echoed Lardaro’s comments. “Spending one million taxpayer dollars to build out space that Johnson & Johnson will occupy for only two years exemplifies a bigger public policy concern. That concern being the transparency and accountability of how CommerceRI awards tax subsidies and grants to certain businesses,” said Sasse, who heads the Hassenfeld Institute at Bryant University.
The Johnson & Johnson deal announced last December is one of the most generous of the packages provided to corporations to bring jobs to Rhode Island.
"This crony Johnson & Johnson and Wexford deals are part of a failed corporate welfare strategy, as designed by the Brookings Institution. Instead of improving our state's dismal business climate for all employers, taxpayer money is being handed out to and benefiting just a few insider corporations. Suspiciously, Rhode Island is not the first state where a Brookings report has led to massive taxpayer subsidies for Wexford; a repeated quid pro quo arrangement we believe warrants further investigation,” said Mike Stenhouse of the RI Center for Freedom and Prosperity.
GOP Candidates Were Equally Critical
More questions about the economic development strategy of RI Commerce Corp from a range of voices.
“This is just another insult to hardworking Rhode Islanders. The Governor and her Commerce Corporation staff have bent over backwards to take care of Wexford. Already taxpayers have pledged more than $40 million from CommerceRI programs, given money for a $45 million parking garage that Wexford demanded and provided them with tax treaties in Providence,” said House Minority Leader Patricia Morgan, who has announced that she will be running for Governor in 2018.
“Now it appears this private company will be the beneficiaries of $1 million of renovated office space in the Ship Street building they own. Added together, this is a large package of taxpayer subsidies. On top of that Johnson & Johnson is receiving another $6 million for a mere 75 promised jobs,” added Morgan.
“It doesn't matter how book smart someone is, what matters is there is competency to navigate crisis and make sound decisions for long-term success. It doesn't surprise me at all that a short-term view is sacrificing our taxpayers once again, because we lack proven leadership. Leaders lead...they are not led,” said Giovanni Feroce, CEO of BENRUS. Feroce has been his own financial challenges recently — losing his Newport Mansion and working to build his company.
Secret Leases
Raimondo has continued to refuse to release -- or force the release -- of the leases between the taxpayer-subsidized Wexford campus and the tenants — Brown University, CIC, and Johnson & Johnson.
In January, a GoLocal investigation found that the permanent job claims for the Wexford project by the Raimondo administration were inflated.
Raimondo had repeatedly claimed that project will create 1,000 new permanent jobs in Rhode Island. After weeks of requesting information about tenants, rents, and job creation, GoLocal was finally able to secure actual job numbers for the project and then fact check those claims.
In fact, actual jobs created will be closer to 80 to 90. This was prior to Monday’s announcement that Johnson & Johnson would move to the Wexford campus - increasing the job creation from 90 to 165.
“Even more troubling is the Governor's unwillingness to release or even discuss the specifics of the plan and the leases. Given the history of misinformation and dodging, it is important for taxpayers to know if the spaces are being rented at market rates or another sweetheart rate. The Governor refuses to divulge that information on the basis that Wexford is a private company, but they are taking our public’s money. The Governor and Wexford can’t have it both ways: too much taxpayer money is on the line,” added Morgan.
Related Slideshow: See Who Could Be Running for RI Gov? September, 2017
Related Articles
- GoLocalTV: Mattiello Calls on Commerce to Take a Second Look at $3.6M for CA Developer
- Growing Allegations About Developer that Raimondo and Commerce Just Gave $3.6M
- Commerce RI’s Pryor Calls for Review of CA Developer’s $3.6M Project
- Should Rhode Island Be Investing in LA “Slumlord?” Commerce Board Member Weighs In
- Commerce RI is Launching a Big Program to Boost Small Biz, Guest MINDSETTER Early
- 3 RI Chambers of Commerce Support Tiverton Casino
- Raimondo, Commerce Give $3.6M to “One of Most Dishonest and Unscrupulous” Developers
- Developer Says RI Commerce Corp. Holding Up Plans for Pawtucket Waterfront District
- NEW: RI Commerce Corp Votes on 38 Studios Litigation, Refuses to Disclose Details
- Guest Mindsetter™ Dr. Carriuolo: How Commerce Corp is Making RI More Business Friendly
- New Bedford Marine Commerce Terminal to be Leased to Offshore Wind Developers
- RI Commerce Corp Seeking Proposals for New Business, Tourism Advertising Agencies
- RI Commerce Spends Two-Thirds of its $12M in Contracts with Out-of-State Companies
- RI Commerce Lures Vistaprint with $2.2M in Subsidies, Unaware Competitor MOO.com is RI-Based
- Sasse Calls on General Assembly to Audit RI Commerce Corp
- Critics Blast RI Commerce Out-of-State Spending
- RI Commerce Promotes Raimondo Video; RIers Lash Out on Social Media
- RI Commerce Vice Chair and Raimondo Appointee is Massachusetts Resident
- Chafee Says $40M for Wexford is the Wrong Priority, RI Commerce Votes for Funding
- LIVE: Gary Sase “The Money Man” Talks Trump Budget, Commerce RI, and 195
- RI Commerce Corp to Pay $50,000 Penalty in 38 Studios Settlement with SEC
- Betaspring Blames Commerce Corp, Denies Responsibility for $800K in Misspending
- Raimondo, RIDOT Announce Opening of Blackstone River Bikeway Segment
- Raimondo Signs Legislation to Prevent Opioid Overdoses & Save Lives
- NEW: Raimondo Gives Comment St. Joseph’s Pension Fund Bankruptcy, Kilmartin Refuses
- Raimondo “Disappointed” by National Grid Rate Increase Approval By PUC
- Raimondo Appoints Gill as New Family Court Judge
- Raimondo’s $40K a Month Security Costs Draws Mixed Reaction
- Senate Passes & Raimondo Signs $9.2 Billion Budget Bill
- UPDATED: Raimondo Staffer Attacks Former Gov. Chafee on His Wife’s Facebook Page
- EDITORIAL: Raimondo’s Hedge Fund Problem
- Raimondo Office Emails Show NGA Corporate Sponsors Promised Access to Governors and Other VIPs
- Governor Raimondo’s Security Detail Tops More than $1.2 Million
- VIDEO: Governor Raimondo Calls for Investigation into St. Joseph Pension Fund Bankruptcy
- Moore: Raimondo’s Propaganda Program?
- Johnson & Johnson Heiress Caught Kicking Horse, Raimondo Has Provided $6M in Incentives to Company
- Raimondo Refuses to Answer Questions About Leases at Wexford — Despite $40M in Taxpayer Subsidies
- Why Are So Many Gearing Up to Run Against Raimondo? See Who Could Run for RI Governor
- Leading Invenergy Opponent Roselli Declares for Gov. Against Raimondo in Primary on GoLocal LIVE
- Sick Time Legislation Passed by Legislature - Now to Raimondo
- Nardolillo Blasts Raimondo Over DACA “Special Treatment”
- Raimondo Administration Refuses to Answer Questions About Amazon HQ2 Effort
- Raimondo’s Close Friend Sen. Booker Pushing Federal Bill that Would Kill PawSox Deal
- St. Joseph Receiver Del Sesto to Meet with Raimondo, Ruggerio Proposes Bill
- Raimondo’s Office Demands “Good News” Press Conferences by Departments to Mark 1,000 Days
- Critics Blast Raimondo Administration for $1 Million Waste on Johnson & Johnson Buildout