Bottles Thrown at Black Students by White Students at Providence College, According to Reports
Thursday, February 04, 2016
PC President Fr. Brian Shanley sent a letter to the college community (see BELOW) saying police investigations are ongoing, and that he was "deeply saddened by the incident" that he said left the women feeling "fearful, devalued, angry, and humiliated."
The head of the NAACP Providence Branch is calling for a meeting with Shanley following the reports of racially motivated violence.
"I"m going to ask for a meeting with Fr. Shanley. If there are perpetrators of racial name calling or throwing bottles, they should be expelled," said NAACP Providence Branch President Jim Vincent. "There have been issues at PC over the years, this isn't the only incident. Enough is enough. We're coming to plateau, and something needs to be done."
Professor Weighs In
Professor Julia Jordan-Zachery, Director of Black Studies at PC, spoke with GoLocal about the incident -- and aftermath.
"It's a pretty consistent story about what happened. These women went to the house to get a friend of theirs, and said the young man at the door supposedly told them, 'We don't want your people here,' and pointed in the direction of Chad Brown," said Jordan-Zachery. "Then the women say they saw white students being let in, which is when the real trouble started. I heard they called them 'black bitch'. There's a race-gender connotation of being called that. The only thing worse they could have been called is nigger bitch. Then they had bottles thrown at them. I don't think they were actually hit with water, but that's not the point."
Jordan-Zachery said she has concerns about what she heard about how the incident was reported to police.
"The students called 911, they said they've been assaulted, and this is a racially motivated assault. I just learned that Providence College pays police detail on the weekends, fascinating in and of itself," said Jordan-Zachery. "Well the police refused to help these young women. I've seen the report, it has incident type as 'person annoyed.' So if that's not bad enough, it said she's appeared intoxicated. If she were in fact intoxicated, there is protocol -- she should have been charged with public intoxication, she should have been taken in. None of that happened. There were enough adults on the scene who have written reports saying she was not intoxicated, just visibly upset. I heard from one student that he was scared that one woman was having a panic attack and couldn't stop hyperventilating. The report detracts from what happened to these women, it detracts from the history," said Jordan-Zachery.
"If we're now 'investigating" what happened, historically speaking investigations at PC of racial biases don't go well," said Jordan-Zachery. "A couple of years ago students were called "nigger" on campus, and that was long drawn out process, where the other students said they actually said another word -- that was two years ago. Nothing happened. There's a deep history. Talk to alumni, this isn't new."
"Fr. Shanley is at a board meeting in Florida, and I don't know when he's due back," said Jordan-Zachery. "This is an opportunity for him in a leadership capacity to show greater leadership. The email came out this morning -- the incident took place on Saturday."
Shanley Letter to PC Community
Shanley sent the following letter to PC community Wednesday morning, following the incident reported on Saturday night.
Dear Members of the Providence College Community:
I regret to inform you that the College received the following report regarding an incident that occurred off-campus. Late last Saturday night/early Sunday morning, a group of five female PC students of color walked to a nearby off-campus residence of some PC students to join their friends at a party. Upon arriving, they were informed that the house was full and no other people were being allowed in.
As they began to leave, the students said they noticed that other students – white students – were being allowed into the party. After raising questions as to why they were turned away, they reported that water and beer bottles were thrown in their direction from a balcony. This behavior was accompanied by comments that made the targeted students – women of color – feel fearful, devalued, angry, and humiliated.
The incident was reported to both the Providence Police Department and the PC Office of Campus Safety and Security, and investigations are ongoing. While I am deeply saddened by this incident, I applaud the courage of these students to bring their report forward.
As President, I want to assure you that this incident is being investigated thoroughly and fairly, consistent with our core value that all members of the College community be treated with dignity and respect at all times. We know from our experience at PC, and that of colleges and universities across the country, that the impact of such incidents is not limited to the students who experience them; they bring pain to our entire community.
We will continue to work collaboratively with all members of the College community toward creating and sustaining an environment in which all students feel welcome, safe and supported.
Brian J. Shanley, O.P.
Related Slideshow: Legacy of Racism in New England
Institutions around the country are currently addressing whether to acknowledge -- or not -- individuals whose past racist views are now being subject to present political pressure, whether it's Woodrow Wilson Hall at Princeton University, renaming Byrd Stadium at the University of Maryland, to renaming Jefferson-Davis Highway in Virginia.
In New England, a number of once prominent figures in the region's history are causing members of the community to revisit how a racist history plays a part in having a role in today's society.
The legacy of the former owner of the Boston Red Sox, who passed away in 1976, is currently in the media glare for his views and actions while head of the club.
“It’s time to banish the racist legacy of Tom Yawkey,” wrote Adrian Walker for the Boston Globe on Monday, of the former owner of the Sox for 44 years, starting in 1933.
Wrote Walker, “All this history raises an uncomfortable, current-day question. Why on earth does Boston have a street called Yawkey Way? Or a Yawkey MBTA station? At a time when activists, especially on college campuses, are clamoring for renaming monuments to racist history, it’s long past time for Boston to think long and hard about the official Yawkey legacy. That the Red Sox are so central to the city’s psyche makes it even more urgent for Boston to act now to banish this legacy of racism.”
Last year, the Globe’s Robert Burgess posed,"Was Tom Yawkey Boston's Donald Sterling," making a comparison to the now former LA Clippers owner who was banned by the NBA for making racist remarks.
“Unfortunately, Boston knows a thing or two about racism in sports," wrote Burgess. "While Sterling’s alleged words are offensive to many, let’s not sit too proud on our high horse.”
“In 2003, Brown University president Ruth Simmons opened an investigation into the school’s role in the slave trade. The findings exhumed unsettling accounts of the many ways in which important founders of the institution participated in and benefited from slavery, including the use of slave labor to construct the oldest and most iconic building on campus, University Hall,” wrote Northwestern Professor Jennifer Richeson in a piece entitled "What Ivy League Ties to Slavery Teach About Redemption."
As part of its recognition of its past ties to the slave trade, Brown unveiled its slavery memorial last year, which reads, “Rhode Islanders dominated the North American share of the African slave trade, launching over a thousand slaving voyages in the century before the abolition of the trade in 1808, and scores of illegal voyages thereafter. Brown University was a beneficiary of this trade.”
A Manhattan Institute Fellow broached the issue of Brown changing its name when it took up renaming Columbus Day to "Fall Weekend", but the idea got little traction.
"If you're going to get rid of the day honoring Columbus because he was involved in slavery, I don't see how you can bypass the Brown problem," said John Leo, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute. "They have to be consistent with their message on slavery. And if they’re not willing to do that, then there's no reason to take them seriously."
Now, Brown just announced it is investing $100 million to "promote diversity and inclusion" on the campus, in light of pressures from the students and community to address ongoing racial issues on campus.
H.P. Lovecraft, one of Providence’s most famous authors, known for “The Call of Cthulhu” and other works of horror fiction, is also known for a fair degree of controversy about racially-charged aspects of his writing.
“It’s OK to admit that H.P. Lovecraft was racist,” wrote Laura Miller for Salon in 2014. Meanwhile, numerous literary analyses and blog posts, including “The ’N’ Word Through the Ages: The ‘Madness’ of HP Lovecraft” and “Lovecraft, Racism, and the ‘Man of his Time’ Defense" give the author much less of pass.
Lovecraft and his work where heralded with much fanfare this past summer in Providence for NecronomiCon, “celebrating 125 years of weird in the heart of Lovecraft’s city.” Meanwhile, much more quietly, the Atlantic Cities reported that starting next year, the World Fantasy Award trophy will no longer be modeled after the massively influential horror-fiction writer H.P. Lovecraft. "Small, corrective steps matter, not for the past, but for the future," wrote Lenika Cruz.
“John Winthrop, the first governor of Massachusetts Bay Colony, kept American Indians as slaves and helped to write the first law in the US officially sanctioning the practice of keeping African slaves,” wrote C.S. Manegold for the Boston Globe in “New England’s scarlet ‘S’ for slavery” in 2010.
In terms of legacy, Winthrop is one of a number of historic figures that is subject to the “latest call by students at Harvard University for the school to purge terms or symbols deemed offensive by a vocal minority raises [in] what could be a confounding issue: How far will the 379-year-old school go to distance itself from historic figures whose actions and social values we would not approve today?” wrote Evan Lips for the NewBostonPost on December 4, as Harvard's Winthrop House” is one of a number at the school named for for a prominent Massachusetts leader who profited from slavery.
In 2007, the then 80-year-old Ralph Papitto — “a big time donor to [Roger Williams University] and a longtime chairman of its board — expressed deep regret for uttering a racist slur about black people at a board meeting,” the Wall Street Journal reported.
“I take full responsibility for this matter and ask for understanding from the community,” Papitto said in the statement. “I do not want this controversy, which at present is running out of control, to further the damage already caused to the university.”
The law school had opened at the Bristol, Rhode Island institution in 1993 and was named for Papitto in 1996, but just over 10 years later saw his name removed -- at his request -- in light of the scrutiny for the racist remarks.
Harvard Law School
“A group of Harvard Law students called Royall Must Fall, is taking issue with the law school’s seal, parts of which come from the Royall family crest. Isaac Royall, Jr. was a slave owner and son of a slavetrader who played a key role in creating Harvard Law School,” wrote WBUR on December 2.
Following an outcry from students, officials from the school are "examining the continued use of the seal, in what is the latest controversy over race and historic injustices on US college campuses in recent weeks."
“Symbols are important,” Martha Minow, dean of the law school, said this week to the Boston Globe. “They become even more important when people care about them and focus on them.”
"James DeWolf of Bristol, Rhode Island (1764-1837) was a United States senator and a wealthy merchant who, at the time of his death, was reported to be the second richest person in the country. He was also the leading slave trader in the history of the United States,” wrote the Tracing Center.
“Over fifty years and three generations, from 1769 to 1820, James DeWolf and his extended family brought approximately 12,000 enslaved Africans across the Middle Passage, making the DeWolf family our nation’s most successful slave-trading family.”
And the mission of the Tracing Centre?
“To create greater awareness of the full extent of the nation’s complicity in slavery and the transatlantic slave trade and to inspire acknowledgement, dialogue and active response to this history and its many legacies.”
DeWolf is featured prominently in a 2008 documentary" Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North" co-produced and directed by Katrina Browne, a DeWolf descendant.
- 360º: The Numbers
- 360º: The Background
- 360º: The Player
- GoLocalProv’s 360º - Exploring Important Issues from Every Angle
- 360º: The Professor
- Leaders Respond to Allegations of Racism in Johnston
- Seven Examples - Racism in New England
- Anti-Latino Racism and the Right’s Soft Underbelly
- YWCA’s Race Against Racism 5K Returns Oct. 7
- Dan Lawlor: Political Diversity Can Save Rhode Island
- Roger Williams Gets $75K From Hearst Foundations For Diversity
- RI’s Private + Parochial High School Diversity: Which Schools Reported
- Don Roach: Diversity is Overrated
- NEW: Blue Cross & Blue Shield RI Names First Diversity Officer
- NEW: PC Names First-Ever Chief Diversity Officer
- Candidates Tackle Illegal Immigration, Diversity in Debate
- RI Artist Tony Johnson to Speak on Diversity, Arts, at RIC
- Coach Herman Boone Speaks to Providence College, Addresses Diversity
- Supporters: Cutting Brown Wrestling Hurts Diversity
- NEW: Brown Sets Diversity Record With Class of 2017 Admissions
- Rhode Island Reacts to School Diversity Report
- Rhode Island’s Diversity Explosion—See Where
- Leaders Call for More Diversity in Law Enforcement Leadership in RI
- It’s All About Education: Do We Really Value Diversity in Schools?
- Don Roach: Don’t Force Diversity on the Providence Police Department
- Leaders Call for More Diversity in Raimondo Administration
- Providence’s Wheeler School to Host Diversity Conference
- GoLocalProv Wins Metcalf Award for Diversity in Media
- PHOTOS: 26th Annual Metcalf Awards for Diversity in the Media
- NEW: RI Gubernatorial Candidates to Appear at Diversity Forum
- GoLocalProv’s Nagle Wins NAACP Award for Diversity Coverage - 3rd Major Award in 2014
- 5 Charts Show How the Oscars’ Diversity Problem Goes Far Beyond the Academy