Battle Over Blackstone Boulevard Speed Bump Plan Heats Up
Monday, December 14, 2015
Sides are split on a plan to implement speed bumps and “traffic calming” measures on Blackstone Boulevard, with a meeting scheduled Monday for public input at Nathan Bishop Middle School.
The proposal comes seven years after the East Side’s major thoroughfare went from two lanes down to one, and now the city has revealed preliminary plans to add measures to slow traffic on the Boulevard, which would included twenty-four "speed lumps/humps", nineteen raised crosswalks and three signs.
Proposed Changes: Map 1, Map 2, Map 3, Map 4
GET THE LATEST BREAKING NEWS HERE -- SIGN UP FOR GOLOCAL FREE DAILY EBLAST“This effort was started by Gayle Aronson years ago, and Sam Zurier attended many meetings that she organized to discuss the issue. They have worked extensively with police, as you know police are severely under staffed and have expressed their inability to enforce traffic regulations very clearly to the residents,” said community organizer Dr. Timothy Murphy.
“So a plan for structural calming as been brewing for at least 3 years. There is a traffic calming committee that hears requests from all over the city. The boulevard residents put in a request through Nate Urso in traffic planning, it took many meetings to get to a plan,” said Murphy. “I think the majority of residents are aware of traffic issues and support traffic calming.”
Not all neighboring residents support the plan, however.
“I am opposed to the grand scheme for several reasons. I don't think it has been proven to be needed. Murphy's wanting it does not make it needed,” said East Side resident Butch Norman. “I think it will be a waste of precariously precious city funds – our taxes – when there are so many more important needs, such as schools, crime prevention, roads and other infrastructure. I very much am opposed to the process, where a few people can grab the ear of a city official and create a solution to a problem that may not exist.”
Public Input Sought
City Councilman Sam Zurier, who mentioned the meeting in his weekly newsletter to constituents, did not say if he is for — or against — the project.
“During 2012-14, I attended several meetings on the subject of speeding on the Boulevard. There was a speeding issue at that time, so I would assume there still is,” said Zurier. “I have not been involved in the design of the proposal. With that said, it is common for neighborhood groups to work directly with DPW to develop a proposal. The purpose of tomorrow’s hearing is to receive public comment before any action is taken.”
Norman said that while he is against the proposal that has been put forward, that he believes the current traffic issues still present a problem.
“I think the Boulevard (southbound) to Butler Ave. past Lincoln through Angell to Waterman to Henderson Bridge needs a reasonable plan to alleviate traffic backing up from mid-afternoon through rush hour,” said Norman. “It sometimes backs up to Lloyd, making it very difficult to enter or cross the Boulevard at its southmost end. Add in the walkers, joggers, bikers, baby strollers moving in all directions and there is a need for some comprehensive plan.”
“Tim Murphy sent out a survey to a few dozen people. My recollection is that the returns were skimpy and, therefore, were "massaged" to reflect Murphy's desired goal,” said Norman. “The first real public input will be at Nathan Bishop. It seems an undemocratic way of doing things.”
Murphy said that he anticipates hearing from opposition to the plan on Monday.
“I’m sure there will be a small minority of people who won't accept the chance that one car will be diverted to their street, people who are completely self-centered like that are the minority, but often that type of person is very vocal and I expect several of them to be at the meeting,” said Murphy. “I don't believe they represent the majority, anyone who has tried to drive the speed limit and is being reasonable would agree that traffic calming is warranted on the boulevard.”
Cheryl Simmons, who runs a community listserv, has shared numerous comments from East Siders who feel strongly on both sides.
"Personally, I see these traffic "calming" strategies as simply moving the problem on to adjacent streets, all at taxpayer expense," said Simmons. "It seems beneficial for a small group of residents at the expense of the the larger community. Boulevard residents themselves are split on this issue, and most of the comments on the listserv have been against it. I don't think that most residents knew that a preliminary plan had already been approved by City Engineer Nate Urso's committee."
Related Slideshow: Things That Providence Has Done Really Well
Here's a snapshot of ten things Providence does -- really well -- in October 2015.
Related Articles
- Showdown Looming Over Proposed Blackstone Boulevard Development
- New Arguments Made Against Proposed Blackstone Boulevard Development
- Sides Split on Future of Granoff’s Blackstone Boulevard Development
- NEW: Historic Blackstone Boulevard Bridgham Estate Sold for $4 Million
- Chad Brown-East Side Gang Rivalries Fueling Providence Shootings
- NEW: Fox’s Home on East Side of Providence for Sale
- LISTEN: Can Anyone Stop the East Side-Chad Brown 25 Year Gang Rivalry?
- Can Anyone Stop the East Side-Chad Brown 25 Year Gang Rivalry?
- City of Providence Cuts Mount Hope Out of the East Side
- Battle Heats up Between Residents, Developer Over Historic East Side House
- Crime Concerns Sweep East Side, Over 150 Breaking and Enterings Since January
- East Side Ravaged By Break-ins, Start Citizen Group
- Elorza Tackles Crime, Protestors at East Side Community Forum
- East Side of Providence Rocked by Crime
- Battle Heats up over Historic East Side Development
- Guest MINDSETTER™ Christi Reiss: Beyond the East Side: Different Post-Mortem of Cianci’s Defeat
- Blizzard Juno Hits The East Side and Pawtucket
- EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Graffiti Vandals Destroy Historic East Side House
- NEW: Providence Police Makes Arrests Connected to East Side Break-Ins
- East Side B&E King Facing Multiple New Charges After Being Back on Street
- NEW: Providence Police Investigating Hate Crime on East Side
- Smartphone Stolen from Governor’s State Car on East Side UPDATED
- Former State Rep Calls for Private Security on East Side
- East Side Realtors Sound Alarm on Spike in Crime
- Federal Investigation Prompted at Historic East Side Development
- Historic East Side Development Fails City Inspection
- NEW: East Side Physician Marvin Kerzner MD Suspended From Practice
- Over 370 Voters Turn Out On East Side Before Noon
- NEW: Long Lines at Polls on East Side