Junk Food in Schools May Not Cause Weight Gain in Kids
Monday, January 23, 2012
“We were really surprised by that result and, in fact, we held back from publishing our study for roughly two years because we kept looking for a connection that just wasn’t there,” said Jennifer Van Hook, a Professor of Sociology and Demography at Pennsylvania State University and lead author of the study, which appears in the January issue of Sociology of Education.
The study relies on data from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study, Kindergarten Class of 1998-1999, which follows a nationally representative sample of nearly 20,000 students from the fall of kindergarten through the spring of eighth grade.
Junk food in schools didn't equal weight gain
The authors found that 59.2 percent of fifth graders and 86.3 percent of eighth graders in their study attended schools that sold junk food. But, while there was a significant increase in the percentage of students who attended schools that sold junk food between fifth and eighth grades, there was no rise in the percentage of students who were overweight or obese. In fact, despite the increased availability of junk food, the percentage of students who were overweight or obese actually decreased from fifth grade to eighth grade, from 39.1 percent to 35.4 percent.
“There has been a great deal of focus in the media on how schools make a lot of money from the sale of junk food to students, and on how schools have the ability to help reduce childhood obesity,” Van Hook said. “In that light, we expected to find a definitive connection between the sale of junk food in middle schools and weight gain among children between fifth and eighth grades. But, our study suggests that—when it comes to weight issues—we need to be looking far beyond schools and, more specifically, junk food sales in schools, to make a difference.”
The need to focus on home environments
According to Van Hook, policies that aim to reduce childhood obesity and prevent unhealthy weight gain need to concentrate more on the home and family environments as well as the broader environments outside of school.
“Schools only represent a small portion of children’s food environment,” Van Hook said. “They can get food at home, they can get food in their neighborhoods, and they can go across the street from the school to buy food. Additionally, kids are actually very busy at school. When they’re not in class, they have to get from one class to another and they have certain fixed times when they can eat. So, there really isn’t a lot of opportunity for children to eat while they’re in school, or at least eat endlessly, compared to when they’re at home. As a result, whether or not junk food is available to them at school may not have much bearing on how much junk food they eat.”
Hasbro expert: two wrongs don't make a right
“This is the classic case of "two wrongs don't make a right," said Barbara B Robinson, MPH, RD, Pediatric Nutrition Specialist at Hasbro Children’s Hospital. "One of the authors' major contentions is that children develop poor eating habits and become overweight in their earlier years and that including "junk food" in the schools does not contribute further to the obesity problem."
While Robinson says she agreed that children form their eating habits early in life in the context of their families, she said that she didn't take the view that "the damage is done and therefore we don't need to continue efforts to keep unhealthy foods and beverages out of schools." We should be concerned about childhood obesity, Robinson said, "but we should also be concerned with whether our children are well nourished. Just because children were not becoming more overweight it does not mean that they didn't become less well nourished overall. For example, if children drank more soda and less milk, they might be setting themselves up for Vitamin D deficiency and poor bone density."
Should emphasis be on younger kids?
The study results also intimate that when it comes to combating childhood obesity and weight issues, policymakers should put more emphasis on younger children, Van Hook said. “There has been a lot of research showing that many children develop eating habits and tastes for certain types of foods when they are of preschool age, and that those habits and tastes may stay with them for their whole lives,” Van Hook said. “So, their middle school environments might not matter a lot.”
Schools should not abdicate their responsibility to structure a setting that is run by adults who show good judgment, Robinson said. "Implicit in allowing competitive foods in the schools is a passive stamp of approval. In essence, 'responsible' adults are condoning such foods. What kind of a message does that send to children?”
Fore more Health coverage, don't miss GoLocalTV, fresh every day at 4pm and on-demand 24/7, here.
- Bradley, Hasbro Study on HIV and Juvenile Offenders
- Hasbro/RI Hospital: 14 Ways to Keep Kids Road-Safe
- RI Hospital, Hasbro Add Snow Safety and Helmet Program
- Alex and Ani Creates HERO Charm Bangle to Benefit Hasbro
- Hasbro Children’s Hospital Introduces New Food Allergy Clinic