NEW: RI Foundation + Commerce RI Release Econ. Development Report
Thursday, January 23, 2014
The study, say its authors, is intended to serve as "a call to action." It contains over one hundred pages of suggestions for both the public and private sectors, and is organized along five major themes: Increasing the Impact of Competitive Advantages, Promoting Emerging Opportunities, Facilitating Intersections and Connectivity, Building Capactiy and the Business Ecosystem, and Supporting the Talent Pipeline.
The economic report is the final product of the suggestions that the RI Foundation and Commerce RI gathered from more than 200 business leaders and service organization representatives hailing a diverse assortment of fields and professions.
Workshops and discussions amongst these professionals have been taking place since September 2013. The study itself is particularly concerned with "intra-sector collaboration" as an economic strategy. Both the study's conclusions and its methodology emphasize the economic value and opportunity both the The RI Foundation and Commerce RI see in collaboration between businesses in Rhode Island.
Related Slideshow: New England States Battle Over Jobs
Here are several examples of business and job raiding by and against New England states, according to the Good Jobs First report,
States pirating other states for existing businesses and jobs is nothing new.
The 1950s saw heightened concern about the growing number of footloose companies that were abandoning long-standing industrial locations in the north to take advantage of benefits being offered by states such as Mississippi. Then-Sen. John F. Kennedy of Massachusetts decried southern “raiding,” especially in the textile industry. Organized labor took notice. In 1955, then-named American Federation of Labor published a pamphlet with the title “Subsidized Industrial Migration: The Luring of Plants to New Locations.”
In Massachusetts, the free market-oriented Pioneer Institute likened interstate lures to “playing the lottery” in examining the National Establishment Time-Series Database for 1990-2007.
Although the Bay State has had a small net loss of jobs to interstate moves, it loses and gains jobs from mostly the same states (New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island and Connecticut all rank in the top 5 for both directions). In addition to some cautionary findings about the Bay State’s trends, the Institute concluded, “The majority of establishments that moved to the state did not receive special incentives from the state to do so. Therefore, public thinking and public policy with respect to economic development should be reoriented to place less emphasis on interstate relocation.”
Ballooning state-budget deficits are costing millions of jobs, affecting every state, with no regard for region or corporate tax or incentive regimens.
For example, a study of job loss due to the growing trade deficit with China names New Hampshire, California, Massachusetts, Oregon, North Carolina, Minnesota, Colorado and Texas among the 10 most affected states - proportionally, and in that order. That should be a sobering fact for states such as New Hampshire (that so shamelessly pirates jobs from Mass.) and Texas (that openly lures companies from Mass. and other states).
Several states have major state-subsidy programs with restrictions on intrastate job shifting. Among them, are two in New England:
- Rhode Island:
o Corporate-income tax-rate reduction for job creation
o Enterprise-zone tax credits
o Economic-advancement tax incentives
o Employment-growth incentives
In 2011, the Boston Globe published a profile of the State of New Hampshire’s top business recruiter, Michael Bergeron, labeling him a “full-time thief.”
Bergeron, who was said to have removed the state seal from his car to be less conspicuous when visiting prospects, claimed to have lured dozens of firms from Mass. to the Granite State. Brazenly, he posted the Globe profile on his agency website.
In 2010, Connecticut Governor Jodi Rell faced allegations of inciting a border war by writing to New York City-based hedge-fund managers.
“I am personally inviting you and a few of your colleagues to meet with me. We have much to discuss!” Rell added. “The meeting will be intimate, direct and private.”
- Blais: RI’s Leaders Need an “Ah-Ha” Moment Soon for the Economy
- LISTEN: RI Economy on the Rebound?
- State Seeking Strategic Plans to Address Economy
- Block/RI Taxpayers Organization Challenge General Assembly on Economy
- Lardaro Report: RI Economy Stalls
- Study Finds Racial Gaps Putting RI’s Economy, Future at Risk
- CCI Report Shows RI Economy ‘Shifting Into High Gear’
- NEW: Providence Voters Pessimistic on Economy
- Travis Rowley: This Economy Is Gay
- Curtis Parvin: Impersonal Consumerism in a Failing Economy
- NEW: RI Economy Continues to Grow, Report Says
- Executive Office Of Commerce Won’t Help RI Economy—Critics
- NEW: Report Says RI Economy Picking Up Steam
- URI Expert: RI Economy Following ‘Stop and Go’ Pattern
- Exposing the Big Lie of the US Economy
- New RI Web Site Ties Legislatures Failure to Economy - www.OSTPA1.com
- URI Expert: RI Economy Gaining Momentum
- Alex and Ani Fuels Economy - Creates Thousands of Jobs in RI
- Is RI’s Economy on the Rebound?
- Rhode Island’s Struggling Economy: Top Stories in RI in 2012
- What Rhode Island Can Do to Move the Economy Forward
- Aaron Regunberg: How Walmart Workers Could Save the U.S. Economy
- Julia Steiny: Economy To Youth: Make Your Own Jobs
- Russell Moore: Election 2014: It’s the Economy, Stupid