Lardaro Report: Progress of RI Economic Recovery Discouraging
Monday, March 10, 2014
Lardaro points out that while the revised payroll data form 2013 shows more jobs than previously reported, the unemployment rate was also higher than original estimates.
Lardaro's Current Conditions Index:
The new year began with some happy news concerning Rhode Island employment: payroll employment was revised higher by 3,100 relative to the original estimate. But this is Rhode Island, where behind every silver lining lurks a gray cloud: our jobless rate, which was already either the highest or among the highest in the country, was also revised - even higher. So, there is some cause for celebration in the rebenchmarked payroll data, but the household survey data continues to paint a very discouraging picture as far as how this recovery is progressing.
How did Rhode Island’s cyclical economic momentum fare in light of the revised data? The Current Conditions Index, which was designed for this very purpose, also showed a continuation of the good news - bad news situation we have remained mired in for some time now. First, the good news: in light of the newly released labor market data, the CCI was revised higher for four months in 2013 (April, June, September, and November). And, for January, the CCI rose from the (downwardly revised) December value of 58 to 75, as nine of twelve indicators improved. Now for the bad news: the CCI was only revised lower for two months in 2013 (May and December), but the CCI values based on the new data show that the CCI has now failed to improve relative to its year-earlier value for six consecutive months and seven of the last eight months. So, while the values of several CCI indicators were revised higher, these upward revisions were not sufficient to permit us to exceed the favorable CCI values we experienced at the end of 2012 and into January of 2013. It should be noted though, that there were several ties (like this month).
For January, two of the CCI’s five leading indicators failed to improve. The first of these, Employment Service Jobs, includes temporary employment, which is a prerequisite to employment growth. It fell by 2.4 percent in January, which was its second consecutive decline. Continuation of its recent uptrend is now questionable as its values have apparently plateaued around 9,000 for the better part of a year. The other indicator, New Claims for Unemployment Insurance, the timeliest measure of layoffs, rose by 1.3 percent in January, its first failure to improve since last August. The downtrend in this indictor since July of 2013 may be ending. It will be necessary to observe its behavior over the next several months before any confirmation is possible, however.
Single-Unit Permits , managed to improve by 5.5 percent in January relative to its value one year ago, although weather- related factors make interpreting changes in this indicator very difficult. In spite of this, it is safe to conclude that Rhode Island is continuing to move beyond its cyclical trough in new home construction. US Consumer Sentiment rose at a double-digit rate in January (+10.1%), its second increase following three consecutive months of declines. Expect its uptrend to continue as long as the stock market improves. The final leading indicator, Total Manufacturing Hours, which measures strength in our manufacturing sector, barely rose in January (+0.2%), as a decline in the workweek almost offset the job gains that occurred. At least part of the decline in hours may be weather related.
Retail Sales have remained relatively strong overall although its rate of growth compared to a year ago has recently been declining. As was true for several of the other CCI indicators, weather has likely played some role this slowing rate of growth. Private Service-Producing Employment w as revised higher in the recent rebenchmarking. Its rate of growth, which had appeared to be slipping below 1%, remained above that level for all but one month during the last year. The performance of our state’s Labor Force must be described as ugly - its rates of decline went from bad to worse. It fell for the ninth consecutive month. What could be worse? For the past four months, rates of decrease have exceeded 1.5%! And in spite of this, Rhode Island once again claimed the #1 jobless slot in January. Our rate never fell below a value of 9%, contradicting the prior data. Finally, Government Employment rose slightly (by 0.2% ).
The news concerning the revisions to Rhode Island’s labor market data was mixed. While payroll employment was higher than we had thought, our unemployment rate was revised even higher than its prior levels. What is worse, Rhode Island’s jobless rate never fell be- low 9%. The present recovery continues to be less broadly based than it was a year ago, based on the fact that the CCI has now failed to exceed its year-earlier value for six consecutive months. Happy New Year, Rhode Island style!
Related Slideshow: Rhode Island’s Most Unemployed Cities and Towns
Below are the unemployment rates for Rhode Island's 39 cities and towns from August 2013.
The statewide average for the month was 9.1% -- the third highest rate in the country.
- NEW: Lardaro Report: Good + Bad News for RI’s Economic Performance
- RI State Report: Unemployment, Gay Marriage & Fox’s Economic Plan
- NEW: Rhode Island’s Unemployment Rate Drops to 46-Month Low
- State Report: Chafee’s Budget, Unemployment Rate & Gay Marriage Vote
- DLT Director: RI’s Unemployment Rate Won’t “Turn Around Overnight”
- NEW: RI Unemployment Rate Drops To 9.4%
- NEW: Rhode Island’s Unemployment Rate Now Worst in Nation
- Unemployment Above 25% for Rhode Island Youth
- Horowitz: Restore Unemployment Benefits to Long-Term Unemployed
- NEW: RI Unemployment Rate Drops to 9.2 percent in January
- NEW: Rhode Island’s Unemployment Rate Drops Again
- NEW: RI DLT Reports Lowest Unemployment Rate Since 2008
- NEW: RI Unemployment Rate Increased in December
- NEW: Unemployment rate falls to 10.2 percent
- NEW: RI Qualifies For Increased Federal Unemployment Funding
- NEW: Rhode Island Unemployment Climbed to 9.1 Percent for August
- RI 1 of 5 States that Didn’t Improve Unemployment Rate in November
- Lardaro Report: RI Economic Performance is Moving Forward, Slowly
- NEW: Rhode Island Unemployment Rate Increases
- RI State Report: EDC Nominees, Unemployment & An E-Cigarette Ban
- Lardaro Report: RI Economy Stalls
- NEW: RI Unemployment Numbers Dropped to 8.8 Percent in April
- NEW: Rhode Island Unemployment Rate Up For May 2013
- RI Unemployment Higher than Originally Reported: Up to 9.3 Percent
- Lardaro Report: Rhode Island’s Economic Rate of Growth Slowing
- NEW: RI Unemployment Rate Down Slightly in November
- NEW: Rhode Island Unemployment Remained at 8.9 Percent for June
- Rhode Island Owes Feds $200 Million for Unemployment Benefits