Guest MINDSETTER™ Mitchell: RI’s Marketing Program, or “I’ve Bitten My Tongue for the Last Time”
Sunday, April 17, 2016
Most of our clients were out of Rhode Island, but two local clients of note have used our work for the last decade: Rhode Island PBS carries our branding and Rumford Pet Center is still using our jingle.
So, while the now infamous botched up roll-out of the state’s tourism campaign shows how disorganized those in charge were, the plan going forward indicates how clueless they still are.
The fact that the Administration is nixing the slogan, or for that matter any slogan at all, while staying with the new “sail” logo, boggles the mind.
The building blocks of ANY multi-faceted communications program is a strategic, overarching theme, logo and slogan. They are the strategic shorthand by which the campaign’s underlying message(s) can be consistently told, readily identified and remembered. Their efficiency and impact allows for faster communication, higher recognition and more bang for the buck as online, print or direct media is purchased. Without them the value of media purchased is woefully diminished.
First, let’s look at the Logo that we’re (ill-advisedly) keeping. Yes, we know its creator, Milton Glaser created “I Love New York”, but a look at his work indicates, to me at least, that the sail logo probably did not come from the hand of the Maestro. And the unused logos presented recently are farther removed from the quality of Glaser’s work which can be viewed on www.miltonglaser.com. One clue could be that in an interview, Glaser himself complained that governor’s team had failed to lay the groundwork for the end product and provide context for it.
Second, as the branding process moves from science to art, there ARE rules: look at the display of state logos on GoLocalProv and you'll see in all cases the name of the state takes up most of the graphic space, because the state name IS the product. (And, by the way 80% of the logos have a slogan).
Looking at the Sail logo itself, the state name takes up about 10% of the available logo space. We're all used to seeing this logo as a large graphic in an internet article, but once it takes its rightful place and size top left or lower right of a digital or printed page, the state name will be relegated to 4 point type (I can't believe Glaser didn’t realize that). To borrow a phrase from the group America, the existing logo helps us be “A State with no Name.”
Now for the "Sail" itself. Without looking at any of the pre or post design research data, as a Rhode Islander I can confidently say that the “essence" of Rhode Island is no more a sail, than it is a quahog or lobster or anchor. Those images are one step removed.
We're about the Ocean and the bay and coastline it has blessed us with. Without it Rhode Island is not Rhode Island. Narragansett Bay attracted Roger Williams, The Capital is at the head of the Bay, our Bay and coastline makes our geography unique in the country, and has given us the bounty of its food, lifestyle, restaurants, oceanography, 5 star restaurants and resorts. And yes, a world class sailing, yachting and boat building hub. Good God, the Ocean is the very soul of the state. To ignore it, or not get it is unconscionable.
Last weekend saw interviews with Seth Goldenberg, the interim program director, touting how we’ll have local meetings seeking input on the details of what makes RI marketable by entertaining alternate slogans that would lead to content for articles, blogs, brochures, events, online reviews and other content. Good move. But steak without the sizzle is still just meat.
While those in charge of the state’s marketing seem to be more comfortable with numbers, data and theoretical concepts and have little background, understanding or regard for the fundamentals of branding or the creative process, they need to get their heads out of the clouds and pay attention to basics.
My unsolicited and surely unwanted advice to them would be to swallow your pride, re-tool as you said you would, and launch a new coordinated position based, brand campaign.
And oh yes, be very careful about abdicating control of the campaign by opening it up to citizens, schools, contests etc. The results could be more problematic than you think.
The reason why these campaigns are expensive is because the good ones are really difficult, deliberated and technically complex. Take input from everyone, but leave execution to the professionals. If you don’t believe it look at Apple, Nike, Coca Cola, Volvo, Yada yada yada.
Make us proud of the state’s new campaign and its leadership.
Retired since 2004, Bill continues to consult with clients deemed fun and interesting and keeps his creative chops honed by writing Parody Songs about Rhode Island (the most infamous being “I Know a Guy”) which can be viewed at http://www.BillyMitchellSongs.com (Hey, cut some slack, he’s retired).
Related Slideshow: Tourism Logos For All 50 States (and D.C.)
- Guest MINDSETTER™ Rep. Carson: Mismanagement of Tourism Campaign Has Jarred RI
- Before Running RI’s Tourism PR, Havas Worked for Cianci’s Campaign
- Raimondo’s National Press Problem Following Tourism Fallout
- NEW: Raimondo Fires Betsy Wall For Tourism Campaign Debacle
- More than 100 Errors on RI Tourism Website
- RI Tourism Campaign in Chaos
- EDITORIAL: Raimondo’s “I Know an Out-of-State Guy” Caused the Tourism Disaster
- Local Comedians Spoof “We are RI” Tourism Video
- Raimondo’s Out-of-State Contracts Extend Beyond Tourism
- Agency Finalist for RI Tourism Account Wins Top Award for Montana Tourism Ads
- The Tourism Logos of all 50 States
- GoLocal Secures Copy of Deleted RI Tourism Video
- Raimondo’s Tourism Problems Are Far From Over
- Westerly Chamber Boss Asks Commerce’s Wall and Pryor to Put Westerly in RI’s Tourism Video